E-mail correspondence between the Mr John
Maxton MP and the Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards
|To:||The Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards
|Date:||25 May 2000 13:00
|Subject:||Nelson`s unsubstantiated complaint
1. Will you confirm that nothing in Paul McKinney's
testimony relates to me and if this is the case why did you include
his testament and the supposed transcript of his conversation
with Dean Nelson?
2. Why have you sent only partial transcripts of
the three witnesses and not all of them?
3. Why is the third interview with John Rafferty
in note form and not a verbatim transcript.
Lastly I ask that, you provide me with the list of
others you interviewed, including dates and places as I requested
sometime ago. I also believe as a Member of Parliament that I
am entitled to see transcripts of all the witnesses you interviewed.
I assume you do not wish to show me those that confirm my story.
Perhaps you could tell me why?
To: John Maxton
From: The Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards
Date: 25 May 2000 16:18
Subject: Complaint by Dean Nelson
Thank you for your message of 25 May 2000. To turn
to your questions.
1. You are the only person who can confirm that nothing
in the record of Mr McKinney`s conversation with me relates to
you. For example, I do not have the details of those involved
in the meetings mentioned in paragraph 3 of Mr McKinney`s evidence.
2. I am not clear which 3 records you believe are
partial. I have sent you the whole record of my conversations
with each of the people listed at (ii) and (iii) in my letter.
Three of those meetings were recorded in writing rather than on
3. I do not tape every interview I undertake. Where
I make a written record of an interview I ask the person interviewed
to check that my record is correct. This is what I did in this
As you are aware, I do not give a Member the names
of those from whom I am seeking information during the investigation
process. I can assure you that I have sent you all the evidence
I have collected which might be at variance with your initial
response. As I have said, if any other such information is forthcoming
I will put it to you before I come to any conclusion on these
I look forward to receiving your response.