|Social Security Fraud Bill [Hl] - continued||House of Commons|
|back to previous text|
Clause 2: Electronic access to information
43. Clause2(1) provides that new section 109BA shall be inserted into the Social Security Administration Act 1992 after section 109B.
44. New section 109BA(1) provides that, subject to subsection (2), where it appears to the Secretary of State that: any person listed in section 109B(2A) keeps any electronic records; that those records may contain information relevant to any one or more of the purposes at 109A(2); and that electronic access to those records is, or is capable of being, provided; the Secretary of State may require that person to enter into arrangements under which authorised officers are allowed access to those records.
45. New section 109BA(2)(a) provides that an authorised officer may only obtain information under the arrangements at 109BA(1) if his authorisation explicitly states that it applies for the purposes of that subsection.
46. New subsection 109BA(2)(b) provides that officers authorised for the purposes of this subsection may only obtain information under the arrangements provided for by subsection (1) where the information relates to a particular person and where it is information that they have the power to obtain under provisions at section 109B.
47. New section 109BA(3) sets out the matters which may be included in arrangements made under subsection (1).
48. New section 109BA(4) provides that an authorised officer who is allowed access to electronic records in accordance with any arrangements entered into under subsection (1) may make copies of, and take extracts from, those records.
49. Clause 2(2) provides for the insertion of new section 110AA after section 110A of the Social Security Administration Act 1992. The provisions are similar to clause 1 and enable authorities administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit, that have the Secretary of State's consent, to make arrangements for electronic access to information in relation to Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit claims.
50. New section 110AA(1) provides that, subject to subsection (2), where it appears to an authority administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit that: any person listed in section 109B(2A) keeps any electronic records; that those records may contain information relevant to any one or more of the purposes at 110A(2); and that electronic access to those records is, or is capable of being, provided; the authority may require that person to enter into arrangements under which authorised officers are allowed access to those records.
51. New section 110AA(2)(a) provides that an authorised officer may only obtain information under the arrangements at subsection (1) if his authorisation explicitly states that it applies for the purposes of that subsection.
52. New subsection 110AA(2)(b) provides that the authorised officer may not obtain information under the arrangements at subsection (1) unless the information relates to a particular person and it is information that he has the power to obtain under provisions at section 109B as applied to him by provisions at section 110A(8).
53. New section 110AA(3) provides for the matters which may be included in arrangements made under subsection (1).
54. New section 110AA(4) provides that an authorised officer who is able to access records in accordance with arrangements under subsection (1) may make copies of, and take extracts from, those records.
55. New section 110AA(5) provides that an authority administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit may only require a person to enter into arrangements for giving authorised officers electronic access to records if it has the consent of the Secretary of State. It also provides that the authority may not enter into arrangements with a person specified in section 109B(2A) to give persons acting on behalf the authority electronic access to private information (otherwise than in accordance with the requirement imposed under this section) unless it has the consent of the Secretary of State. In either case, the arrangements entered into may be subject to any conditions imposed by the Secretary of State when he gives consent. "Private information" is defined in section 110AA(7) as any information held by a person who is not entitled to disclose it except in compliance with a requirement imposed by the authority in exercise of its statutory powers.
56. New section 110AA(6) provides that, for the purposes of subsection (5), consent may be given in relation to a particular case, or to any case that falls within a particular description of cases.
57. Clause 2(3) amends section 111 of the Social Security Administration Act 1992. Section 111(1) provides for any person found guilty of obstruction or delay to be liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 3 on the standard scale. That is currently up to a £1,000 fine. Section 111(2) provides that, where a person who is convicted under section 111(1) continues to refuse to provide required information or to answer questions, he will be guilty of a further offence. On summary conviction he will be fined £40 for every day thereafter that the requirement to provide information is not met.
(a) Clause 2(3)(a) amends section 111(1) to provide that the offence at section 111 also applies where a person refuses or neglects to comply with any requirements under sections 109BA and 110AA.
(b) Clause 2(3)(b) provides that the provisions at 111(2) apply to requirements under sections 109BA and 110AA.
Clause 3: Code of Practice about use of information powers
58. Clause 3 provides for the issue and revision of a Code of Practice relating to the exercise of the provisions set out in clauses 1 and 2 of the Bill.
59. Clause 3(1) provides that the Secretary of State shall issue a Code of Practice relating to the use of provisions at Section 109B of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 where they are being used to make enquiries of persons listed at Section 109B(2A) - banks, building societies, credit reference agencies etc. The Code would also relate to the use of the powers to obtain electronic access to information - new Sections 109BA and 110AA.
60. Clause 3(2) provides that the Secretary of State may revise the Code of Practice. The Department intends to review the operation of the Code of Practice to ensure that it is working as intended for both investigators and for business. The code could be revised if any review demonstrated this was necessary.
61. Clause 3(3) relates to consultation on the Code. It provides that the Secretary of State shall prepare and publish a draft of the Code of Practice, consider any representations made to him upon the draft, and may make any changes he considers appropriate before publishing the final version. It provides for the Secretary of State to do the same in relation to any revisions of the code.
62. Clause 3(4) provides that the final, and any revised, version of the Code of Practice should be laid before both Houses of Parliament.
63. Clause 3(5) provides that the Code of Practice, and any revised version, shall come into force when it is issued by the Secretary of State.
64. Clause 3(6) provides that authorised officers must have regard to the Code of Practice currently in force when exercising their powers under the provisions covered by the code.
65. Clause 3(7) provides that failure on the part of an authorised officer to comply with the Code of Practice would not, in itself, render him liable to civil or criminal proceedings. If authorised officers misuse their powers, they are already liable to proceedings under the Data Protection Act 1998 and the Computer Misuse Act 1990.
66. Clause 3(8) provides that the Code of Practice shall be admissible in any civil or criminal proceedings - for example, if an investigator was charged with misuse of these powers under the offences in the Data Protection Act 1998 or the Computer Misuse Act 1990.
67. Clause 3(9) defines authorised officer. It has the same meaning as in the Social Security Administration Act 1992.
Clause 4: Arrangements for payments in respect of information
68. Clause 4(1) provides that it shall be the duty of the Secretary of State to ensure that such arrangements as he considers appropriate (if any) are in place to ensure that he can authorise such payments as he thinks appropriate and in cases that he thinks fit, in respect of organisations subject to "relevant obligations". The organisations that may be paid under these arrangements are credit reference agencies, telecommunications, gas, water and electricity providers and the servants and agents of the above. Payments may also be made to persons added to the list at section 109B(2A) by Order as provided for in Clause 1(3) and their servants and agents.
69. Clause 4(2) defines "relevant obligation" for the purposes of subsection (1).
70. Clause 4(3) provides that the Secretary of State may make arrangements for payments to be made from money provided by Parliament in order to comply with his duties under this section.
71. Clause 4(4) provides that authorities administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit shall be under a duty to comply with any specific or general directions that the Secretary of State makes regarding payments in accordance with arrangements made under clause 4(1).
Clause 5: Exchange of information with overseas authorities
The current position
72. People are not entitled to means-tested benefits if they are claiming similar benefits in another country or working abroad. In some cases benefits cannot be paid to people living in other countries. Other countries have similar rules. Some people fraudulently claim benefit in more than one country at a time or use false, borrowed or stolen overseas identities to claim benefit fraudulently in the UK.
73. Sharing information with another country about people claiming benefit and living abroad could help both countries prevent and detect benefit fraud. Some limited information is already exchanged with other countries under the regulations that co-ordinate social security provision within the EU and under reciprocal agreements for payment of social security benefits with countries outside the EU. However, these do not provide for the exchange of all the information needed to prevent and detect social security fraud and error.
74. A Memorandum of Understanding between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Ireland concerning co-operation and mutual assistance in the administration of social security programmes (the Memorandum of Understanding) was signed on 9 October 2000. It will enable both countries to improve the administrative efficiency, cost effectiveness and integrity of their social security systems
The measures in the Bill
75. The measures in the Bill will provide for social security information to be supplied to authorities in other countries that carry out functions relating to social security to facilitate the carrying out of those functions. Information may only be supplied where the Secretary of State is content that arrangements have been made with those countries to exchange information and that the country in question has adequate safeguards in place against the improper use of any information disclosed. As these measures involve international relations, with the agreement of the Northern Ireland Executive, the equivalent powers for the Northern Ireland Department of Social Development to supply social security information to authorities in other countries are provided in this Bill.
COMMENTARY ON CLAUSE 5
Exchange of information with overseas authorities
76. Clause 5(1) inserts a new section 179A after section 179 of the Social Security Administration Act 1992. Section 179 provides for reciprocal agreements relating to social security with countries outside the UK to be given effect by Order in Council.
77. The new section 179A provides for the Secretary of State to disclose any relevant information to authorities in countries outside of the UK under agreed arrangements for the exchange of relevant information, where those countries have adequate safeguards against improper use of that information.
78. New section 179A(1) provides that the provisions of new section 179A to supply information to authorities in countries outside the UK will only apply where:
79. New section 179A(2) provides that the Secretary of State may disclose relevant information where this is necessary to give effect to the arrangements mentioned in section 179A(1)(a). The information must be supplied for the purposes of helping the other country carry out functions relating to anything corresponding to, or in the nature of, social security benefits.
80. New section 179A(3) provides that the Secretary of State shall be under a duty to take reasonable steps to ensure that any information received under an arrangement mentioned in section 179A(1)(a) is not used for any purpose that is not covered expressly or impliedly in that arrangement. For example, the Memorandum of Understanding with the Government of Ireland contains an agreement that the Secretary of State will not pass information to the security services.
81. New section 179A(4) provides that this section does not apply where section 179 gives effect to any arrangements.
82. New section 179A(5) extends the purposes for which the Secretary of State may require information in respect of Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit from the authorities administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit under section 122D of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 or section 116D of the Northern Ireland Administration Act to include disclosure to other countries in accordance with this section.
83. New section 179A(6) provides a definition of relevant information for the purpose of this section as information held by the Secretary of State or any authorities in a country outside the UK for the purposes of any function relating to a social security benefit or anything corresponding to, or in the nature of, a social security benefit.
84. Clause 5(2) inserts a new section 155A after section 155 in Part XIII of the Social Security Administration (Northern Ireland) Act 1992. It provides the same measures for the Northern Ireland Department which administers social security benefits as the new section 179A provides for the Secretary of State.
Clause 6: Exchange of information by authorities administering benefit
The measures in the Bill
85. The proposed amendment is a technical change to the provisions under which an authority administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit can be required to provide information to DSS or to another authority.
86. Section 122D of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 enables the Secretary of State to require an authority administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit to supply information to him. But, if the Secretary of State wishes to impose requirements relating to the manner and form in which the information is provided he must make regulations under subsection (3). This measure will allow the Secretary of State to specify in directions, rather than regulations, the manner and form (and other requirements) in which information is to be provided.
87. Section 122E of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 provides for the exchange of information between authorities administering Housing Benefit or Council Tax Benefit. Subsections (3) and (4) enable the Secretary of State to require information to be supplied by one authority to another. Those subsections have not yet been commenced. However, as subsection (4) mirrors section 122D(3), it is also being amended for the sake of consistency.
COMMENTARY ON CLAUSE 6
Exchange of information by authorities administering benefit
88. This clause amends sections 122D and 122E of the Social Security Administration Act 1992 by replacing the word "prescribed" with "specified in directions given by the Secretary of State or, as the case may be, the Northern Ireland Department". This means the Secretary of State or the Northern Ireland Department can specify the manner and form in which information is to be supplied under those sections (or any other requirements relating to the supply of information) by way of directions rather than by regulations.
LOSS OF BENEFIT PROVISIONS
Clauses 7 to 13
89. The report by Lord Grabiner concluded that the Government should consider introducing new ways to tackle those who are involved in the hidden economy, including a 'two strikes and you're out' approach for people convicted twice of social security benefit fraud.
90. The report spelt out how Lord Grabiner saw a 'two strikes' sanction working. He indicated that a tough approach for persistent offenders would be to simply deny them benefit altogether as in parts of the United States and Canada. However, any measure of this kind must have safeguards to protect the innocent and the vulnerable. There are already arrangements in place to allow people to claim reduced-rate payments of benefit while they are subject to benefit sanctions provided they can show that they or their dependants would otherwise suffer hardship.
91. The report concluded that those who persistently defrauded the benefit system should lose their right to benefit in the same way as people who have failed to meet other responsibilities under the social security system. The existing sanctions regime provided a precedent, and many of the details of how such a scheme might work in practice are already established. Furthermore, if the sanction were restricted to a hard core of convicted cheats it could act as a deterrent even if it were infrequently used.
The measures in the Bill
92. The measures in the Bill provide that certain specified benefits shall be reduced or withdrawn where a person is convicted twice of committing offences in relation to specified benefits within the space of three years. The sanction will be for a fixed period of 13 weeks and will begin after conviction for the second offence where benefit is in payment or, if benefit is not in payment, when entitlement first arises in the three-year period following the second conviction. The decision that the sanction applies will carry with it the right of appeal to an appeal tribunal on a question of fact and law.
93. The measures will apply to offences involving fraud against all social security benefits and War Pensions with the exception of Statutory Sick Pay, Statutory Maternity Pay, and Maternity Allowance. Tax Credits are also excluded. Offences relating to Retirement Pension, Graduated Retirement Benefit, Disability Living Allowance, Attendance Allowance, Child Benefit, and Guardian's Allowance will activate benefit loss but these benefits will not be subject to sanction by removal of payment. Also exempt as sanctionable "benefits" are Social Fund payments and Christmas bonuses. All other benefits will be withdrawn or reduced as a result of a second conviction.
94. The intention is that while relevant benefits will be sanctioned, an underlying entitlement will remain to ensure that the link between benefits and other entitlements such as free prescriptions and school meals remain. For recipients of both contributory and income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, the benefit will be withdrawn for the period of the sanction. Jobseeker's Allowance claimants will also have their Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit withdrawn during this period. It is intended that regulations under the powers for which this Bill provides will mirror current provisions for hardship payments arising from employment condition sanctions. If a Jobseeker's Allowance claimant falls into a vulnerable group they could apply for hardship payments from the first day of the sanction. The term "vulnerable group" refers to the group of people specified in regulation 140(1) of the Jobseeker's Allowance Regulations 1996. Those who do not fall into a vulnerable group will be eligible to apply for hardship payments from the 15th day of the sanction.
95. Claimants will retain an underlying entitlement to Jobseeker's Allowance throughout the period of the sanction whether or not they are entitled to hardship payments, ensuring that the "passporting" back on to Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit is maintained. If hardship is established under the regulations, and the claimant satisfies the other conditions of entitlement, they will be awarded a reduced payment of income-based Jobseeker's Allowance. The rate of reduction will be prescribed in regulations, but the intention is that the reduction will normally be 40 per cent of the single person's allowance, although where someone in the family is seriously ill or pregnant, the reduction will be 20 per cent.
96. Joint-claim Jobseeker's Allowance is dealt with in a different manner. Joint- claim Jobseeker's Allowance was introduced by section 59 of, and Schedule 7 to, the Welfare Reform and Pensions Act 1999. These provisions are to be commenced on 19 March 2001. The requirement to make a joint claim for Jobseeker's Allowance will impact on couples without children where one or both of the partners is in the 18-24 years age range on the date when the measure is introduced. Coverage will apply to those born on or after a certain date, so older couples without children will be included as time passes. Under joint claims, both members of the couple will have to claim Jobseeker's Allowance and both will have to meet Jobseeker's Allowance labour market conditions.
97. It is intended to prescribe in regulations that in cases where couples without dependants are in receipt of joint-claim Jobseeker's Allowance, and one member of the couple is subject to the sanction, the non-convicted member will continue to receive the equivalent of the rate of Jobseeker's Allowance which is applicable to a single person during the period of the sanction.
98. For Income Support claimants the effect of the sanction will be to reduce the amount of benefit in payment, rather than withdraw the benefit in its entirety. It is intended that the effect of this measure will be to reduce benefits in line with the calculation of Jobseeker's Allowance payments i.e. by 40 per cent of the single person's allowance, or 20 pert cent where a member of the family is pregnant or seriously ill. The reduction will always leave a minimum of 10p Income Support in payment to enable Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit as well as other "passported" benefit entitlements to remain.
99. Where the sanctioned benefit is neither Income Support nor income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, a claimant may claim such benefits under normal rules. Such benefits will be subject to sanctions but the claimant may still be entitled to payments of these benefits under the hardship regime. Entitlement to a hardship payment will also provide entitlement to Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit (even where these have been sanctioned).
100. In any case where a claimant is neither eligible for Income Support nor income-based Jobseeker's Allowance under normal rules (e.g. if their income, capital or hours worked excludes them from these benefits), it is intended to prescribe in regulations that Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit entitlement will be reduced by a specified amount similar to that used in Income Support cases. This would be by 20 per cent of the Income Support personal allowance where a member of the family is pregnant or seriously ill and 40 per cent in all other cases. The decision whether to award hardship payments and the amount of the award will in all cases each carry the right of appeal to an appeal tribunal on a question of fact and law.
101. To prevent cases where a couple attempt to avoid the sanction by swapping which of them makes the claim, regulations will enable the Secretary of State to reduce the amount of benefit paid to the partner or any dependent of the "offender" by a specified amount for the duration of the sanction.
102. The provisions for members of an offender's family only apply when one of the specified income-related benefits is to be sanctioned - Income Support, income-based Jobseeker's Allowance, Housing Benefit and Council Tax Benefit as these are the only benefits where it is possible for a couple to choose which of them makes the claim.
103. With Jobseeker's Allowance, the effect of the sanction, as prescribed in regulations, would be to reduce the level of Jobseeker's Allowance by removing the element of personal allowance paid in respect of the offender. The partner may receive any allowances and premiums in respect of themselves and their dependants. Hardship provisions similar to those which currently apply with joint-claim Jobseeker's Allowance will also be put in place to protect families in vulnerable circumstances.
104. There will be a number of occasions when a claimant will have deductions taken from their benefit to pay for items such as fuel arrears, court fines and Social Fund loans. Under current arrangements, a claimant has to agree with the Secretary of State which payments to third parties should remain 'deductible' during a period of sanction. There will be times when it is either in the claimant's best interests to continue third party payments (i.e. where money is being deducted to pay for essential fuel costs), or where it is in an innocent third party's interest to have the payments maintained (i.e. child maintenance deductions introduced by the Child Support, Pensions and Social Security Act 2000). The provisions will allow a certain amount of flexibility to the current system and the powers in clause 10(2) allow the Secretary of State to prescribe in regulations which circumstances this may apply to.
|© Parliamentary copyright 2001||Prepared: 13 March 2001|