Joint Committee on Financial Services and Markets Second Report


APPENDIX 1

Memorandum from The Right Honourable The Lord Hobhouse of Woodborough

  Thank you for sending me a copy of the Treasury Memorandum dated 14 May and inviting me to comment upon it.

  The Memorandum is specifically directed to the impact of the European Convention on Human Rights upon the present draft of the proposed Financial Services and Markets Bill. As the question whether a bill in accordance with the draft is compatible with the Convention would be a justiciable issue, I must continue to decline to express an opinion. But the Memorandum also touches upon questions upon which I have given evidence and I will shortly respond to these.

  The Memorandum recognises the distinction between the disciplinary parts of the draft Bill and the provisions of Part VI. However the mere fact that both are designed to be protective does not provide a relevant similarity. The important point is that the disciplinary provisions apply to the regulated community whereas the market abuse provisions apply to the world at large. Paragraph 12 of the Memorandum repeats that Part VI applies to "anyone who participates in the financial markets". As I have said in my evidence, the present draft does not so provide.

  Paragraph 15 of the Memorandum refers to the question whether clause 56 is sufficiently certain for the purposes of the Convention. I express no view about this. But it is a mistake to believe that there is no need to address the drafting of clause 56. The existing draft is defective in ways to which I and other witnesses have drawn attention independently of the Convention. These defects of drafting can be remedied if the Treasury so chooses. So long as the draft for clause 56 remains in its present form, there will be a serious risk that it will fail in its objective and, far from providing a scheme which will catch the unscrupulous, will provide them with a means of escape which a properly drafted provision would foreclose.

17 May 1999


 
previous page contents next page

House of Lords home page Parliament home page House of Commons home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 1999
Prepared 2 June 1999