Implementing the transparency agenda - Public Accounts Committee Contents


Summary

The transparency agenda is a pledge by the Coalition Government to make government more open. The Government's objectives for transparency are to strengthen public accountability, to support public service improvement by generating more comparative data and increasing user choice, and to stimulate economic growth by helping third parties develop products and services based on public information. The Government announced a programme of information release in two open Prime Minister's letters in May 2010 and July 2011, and made further commitments as part of the Autumn Statement in November 2011.

The Government has met the majority of commitments set out in the Prime Minister's letters. Public bodies in both local and central government have significantly increased the volume and range of information released, linking many datasets to the Government's data.gov.uk portal. We recognise the progress made and that the case for transparency is inherently strong. There are, however, areas where further work needs to be done to realise the full benefits of transparency.

It does not help government to meet the objectives of the transparency agenda when large quantities of raw data are released without ensuring that the data are fit for purpose. Some data are very difficult to interpret, such as on local government spending, and there are important gaps in information, such as incomplete price and performance information on adult social care. We are also concerned about some information not being presented on a consistent basis, again for example in local government.

Poor or incomplete data hinders the ability of users to exercise effective choice, for example on care providers. It also undermines the ability of service deliverers and policy makers to focus on improving quality.

The Government has not yet developed a full understanding of costs and benefits of making information transparent, and so decisions on what data to make available and in what form are not yet guided by value for money considerations. The Cabinet Office told us that the Open Data Institute will establish a fuller evidence base on the economic and public service benefits of open data. It is important that Government evaluates progress against the full range of objectives it has set for transparency, looking for unintended as well as planned effects.

The push for release of more data has also thrown up new challenges which departments need to meet, facilitated by strong leadership from the Cabinet Office. These include questions on how to sustain interest in data after the initial launch (for example crime maps), how to ensure sufficient disclosure of information by private firms delivering government contracts, vigilance over protecting personal privacy, and how the benefits of data disclosure can be realised by those without internet access. How departments respond to these challenges will go a long way to supporting the success of the transparency agenda. On the risk to personal privacy, the Cabinet Office assured us that it would set out policies and controls adequate to protect privacy in its White Paper.

On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General,[1] we took evidence from four expert witnesses representing users of data and information released under the transparency agenda; and from the Cabinet Office, the Home Office, and the Department for Communities and Local Government on how the transparency agenda is being implemented across Government.





1   C&AG's Report, Implementing transparency, HC 1833 (2010-12)  Back


 
previous page contents next page


© Parliamentary copyright 2012
Prepared 1 August 2012