Independent Police Complaints Commission - Public Accounts Committee Contents


Summary

Since April 2004, the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) has been responsible for the police complaints system in England and Wales. The IPCC investigates complaints about police officers and staff, recommending what action should be taken by the police force concerned. Where necessary, it forwards information to the Crown Prosecution Service for a decision on possible prosecution. The IPCC gets involved either as a result of a direct complaint from the public or in response to a referral from the police. In cases involving death or serious injury the IPCC is required by statute to investigate.

In 2007-08, nearly 29,000 complaints were made against the police, the vast majority of which were dealt with locally by the relevant police force and did not involve the IPCC. Complaints of a more serious nature requiring IPCC involvement led to it opening 100 independent investigations in 2007-08, compared to 31 in 2004-05. The IPCC also received 4,141 appeals about local police investigations which was a four-fold increase on the number in 2004-05. As a result of its increasing workload, the IPCC has found itself working at above full capacity.

The IPCC has no formal quality control framework in place. The measures that do exist to assess quality have generally not been working as intended. The IPCC's Commissioners have not been formally approving all investigation reports, one of their key responsibilities.

Public confidence in the police complaints system is essential. While the IPCC has commissioned research to look at levels of public confidence in the complaints system, it has not sought the views of complainants, police officers and appellants about their experiences of the IPCC's processes. The absence of feedback from those who have had direct experience of dealing with the IPCC is a significant oversight which the IPCC is now in the process of rectifying.

There is a lack of clarity about who has responsibility for monitoring the implementation of IPCC recommendations. The IPCC accepts responsibility for recording each police force's acceptance or rejection of the recommendations following an investigation, but not for monitoring the implementation of the recommendations. The IPCC has, therefore, only limited evidence on the impact of its work. No other organisation has responsibility for monitoring the implementation of IPCC recommendations. The Home Office needs to decide who should be carrying out this monitoring to ensure that there is a clear and well established line of accountability.

On the basis of a report by the Comptroller and Auditor General,[1] we examined how well the IPCC is managing its resources, the adequacy of the IPCC's quality assurance arrangements and how far the IPCC has sought to assess the impact of its work.





1   C&AG's Report, The Independent Police Complaints Commission, HC (2007-08) 1035 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2009
Prepared 31 March 2009