Select Committee on Public Accounts Forty-Eighth Report


1 Getting advice and support to the young people who need it

1. Connexions is committed to providing a basic level of advice, information and guidance to all young people who want it. Moving away from providing an automatic careers interview for all pupils was intended to free up resources for those areas, schools and young people most in need. In addition to enabling a broader range of support and advice to be offered to young people in different contexts through a single point of entry, Connexions recognised that some young people need more flexibility in the way that they access advice and guidance. New means are being developed, including one-stop shops and Connexions Direct. At March 2004, over 400 one-stop shops providing local services under one roof were open or planned. Around 70% of them are open after school hours and at the weekend. Connexions Direct allows contact with advisers by telephone or text message, or by web chat and email from the Connexions Direct website (www.connexions-direct.com). Of the calls to Connexions Direct, 57% are about careers, learning and jobs.[6]

2. The success of Connexions depends on young people knowing how and where to seek advice when they want it. For many young people, parents and schools are the main sources of advice on careers options and the avenues through which they can seek to achieve their aspirations. Many schools can and do provide such advice and Connexions should be complementing them by providing impartial advice and guidance specific to the young person. The success of Connexions depends on it being visible and accessible, and the Department therefore introduced a clear branding and wide advertising for Connexions. Young people have been involved in developing the service, and independent customer surveys are showing a high degree of satisfaction with it.[7]

3. Informing young people about the range of opportunities available, guiding them on how to develop their careers and how to get the advice they need to decide the right mix of options, are all key elements of the careers curriculum. Schools have a statutory duty to provide appropriate careers education. However, careers education has to compete with other priorities, and the quality of schools' provision is very variable. Half of the schools surveyed by the National Audit Office claimed they had insufficient time to develop the curriculum to incorporate careers education, and in nearly two-thirds of the schools it was being coordinated or delivered by staff without any formal qualification in careers education.[8]

4. Connexions' tasks include helping schools to improve their careers education as well as to understand when and how to refer young people to Connexions. It now has a toolkit for schools, developed by a head teacher, showing how to use Connexions in schools and how it works with other support systems. Connexions partnerships also have agreements with schools in which the schools set out what they want from Connexions, including a minimum level of contact time they can expect from a Connexions Personal Adviser.[9]

5. Connexions is a universal service in terms of the overall offer of information and advice, but also involves a substantial targeting, with resources being focused on areas, schools and teenagers who need it most. According to the National Audit Office's survey, two-thirds of schools considered that staff did not fully understand the role of Connexions' Personal Advisers, and two-fifths considered that staff were uncertain how to identify and refer pupils who need specialist advice to Connexions. The latter is an important role for schools so as to secure early intervention with young people who could develop multiple problems.[10]

6. Connexions management information includes records of "interventions" with young people, based on each occasion when a Personal Adviser offers some element of substantial or meaningful assistance. Interventions are classified into three groups: intensive and sustained support for those students with multiple problems; in-depth guidance and help for those at risk of disengaging from education, employment or training; and information, guidance and review of careers, learning and personal development choices. Total resources for 13-19 year olds will differ, and some variation between partnerships in the categories of intervention is to be expected, for example, depending upon the resources the area already has through other programmes. For interventions with young people in need of the most intensive support, the range is from two to 63% and half of all partnerships are spread between 17 to 38% (Figure 2).[11]


7. The Department explained that deprivation indices suggest a higher proportion of young people requiring intensive support in, for example, Humber, than in Essex, Southend and Thurrock. The age of the partnership can also have an effect, since as partnerships mature, they tend to learn of more young people previously not known to them, many of whom require intensive support. The Department is setting up a system to track the different categories of intervention and use the information for comparing partnerships' performance.[12]


6   C&AG's Report, paras 2.28, 3.30-3.31; Qq 13, 57-58, 76, 89 Back

7   C&AG's Report, para 3.32; Qq 12, 96 Back

8   C&AG's Report, paras 3.19-3.21; Q 17 Back

9   C&AG's Report, paras 3.19, 3.21; Qq 7-9, 16-18, 60-61, 66 Back

10   C&AG's Report, para 3.22; Qq 18, 59, 76 Back

11   Qq 26-29, 83-88 Back

12   Q 87; Ev 16 Back


 
previous page contents next page

House of Commons home page Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries index

© Parliamentary copyright 2004
Prepared 30 November 2004