House of Commons portcullis
House of Commons
Session 2005 - 06
Publications on the internet

House of Commons
Wednesday 29 March 2006
Notices of Motions for which no days have been fixed
(‘Early Day Motions’)

* The figure following this symbol is the total number of Members' names submitted in support of the Motion, including names printed for the first time in this paper.

After the initial printing, Motions are reprinted only when names are added or amendments are submitted; only the first six names and any names added since the last printing are listed. After the week in which a Motion is submitted and the following week, added names and amendments appear only in the paper distributed on the next Thursday. In the meantime they are available for inspection by Members in the Table Office and the Library.



1CYSTIC FIBROSIS AND PRESCRIPTION CHARGES17:5:05
Bob Russell
Mr James Clappison
Andrew Stunell
John Mann
Tom Brake
Tim Farron
* 113
 Stephen Williams
   That this House believes people with cystic fibrosis should not have to pay prescription charges.


48FUTURE OF COUNCIL HOUSING17:5:05
Simon Hughes
Paul Holmes
Tom Brake
Tim Farron
Mr David Heath
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 142
 Mr Adrian SandersHelen Goodman
   That this House supports the proposal from the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister Select Committee for an investment allowance to create a level playing field for council housing and enable local authorities to finance borrowing under the prudential framework to meet the Decent Homes Standard as an alternative to the Government's three current options of stock transfer, private finance initiative and arm's length management organisations; shares the concerns expressed in the critical reports by the Public Accounts Committee and the National Audit Office on the cost-effectiveness of stock transfer; believes that a fourth option, allowing councils to improve their own stock, can be funded by re-investing all the income from tenants' rents, capital receipts and savings on expensive set-up costs; notes the broad consensus of support from tenants, the Local Government Association and local authorities, the TUC and trade unions for the fourth option; welcomes the recognition by the Deputy Prime Minister on 26th September that `public financing of housing doesn't treat local authorities on a level playing field and I want to see that changed and I promised to do that and look at an inquiry into it'; and urges him to stand by this promise so that tenants can have a real choice, councils can compete on a level playing field and the public housing stock can be repaired, refurbished and expanded to make its contribution to the growing need for public rented housing, instead of wasting millions to give it away.


67MOBILE PHONE MASTS17:5:05
Mrs Caroline Spelman
Tim Loughton
Mr John Randall
Dr Vincent Cable
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Derek Conway
* 119
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House notes that industry sources have recently indicated that 3G technology will require a substantial increase in the number of mobile phone masts, with as many as four times the present number, suggesting up to 200 more masts in every constituency; believes that the current planning process in England is inadequate, failing to consider local, environmental and safety concerns; observes that the Government is reviewing planning regulations for masts and that tougher protection is already in place in Scotland and Northern Ireland; and calls on the Government to introduce full planning permission for all masts, including Network Rail and TETRA masts, and to allow health concerns to be taken into account near homes, schools and hospitals.

As an Amendment to Mrs Caroline Spelman's proposed Motion (Mobile Phone Masts):

Hywel Williams
Albert Owen
Mr Fabian Hamilton
Mr David Jones
Mark Williams
* 5
Line 4, after `England', insert `and Wales'.
24:5:05(a1)


70FOOD JUSTICE17:5:05
Alan Simpson
Mr Don Foster
Mr David Amess
Dr Vincent Cable
Tim Farron
Mr Adrian Sanders
* 200
 Mr Jamie Reed
   That this House notes the report by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation published in 1999 that highlighted that over four million people in the United Kingdom do not have reasonable access to a healthy diet; further notes reports by the Malnutrition Advisory Group that show that up to 5,000 people in each parliamentary constituency may be malnourished and that one in seven people over 65 years are malnourished or at serious risk of malnourishment; recognises that this situation can be caused by a number of factors such as inadequate income, lack of reasonable access to shops or other outlets selling healthy food and inadequate information; further notes that one of the causes of childhood obesity is inadequate access to, or information concerning, healthy food; and therefore supports the provisions in the Food Justice Strategies Bill which was introduced in the last Parliament and supported by over 200 honourable Members.


85PARLIAMENTARY APPROVAL FOR PARTICIPATION IN ARMED CONFLICT17:5:05
Mr Neil Gerrard
Norman Baker
Alan Simpson
Paul Flynn
Mr David Drew
Mr Adrian Sanders
* 232
 Mr Tim YeoMr Jamie Reed
   That this House believes that the decision to deploy British armed forces in conflict is of the most serious nature possible; notes that this is a decision to be taken by Ministers via the Royal Prerogative and that Parliament has no right to decide on the matter or even to be consulted; further notes that the Public Administration Select Committee has recommended in its report of 4th March 2004 that this situation should be ended and that Parliament should have the right to decide this matter in advance, or in cases of emergency retrospectively; further notes that in the last session of Parliament over 200 honourable Members supported this view; and therefore calls on the Government to introduce legislation to this effect.


92ANIMAL TESTING OF DRUGS17:5:05
Mr Mike Hancock
Dr Rudi Vis
Peter Bottomley
Paul Holmes
Jeremy Corbyn
Dr John Pugh
* 210
 Mr Brian JenkinsMrs Ann CryerJanet Anderson
 Mr Joe BentonDanny AlexanderMark Pritchard
   That this House, in common with Europeans for Medical Progress, expresses its concerns regarding the safeguarding of public health through data obtained from laboratory animals, particularly in light of large numbers of serious and fatal adverse drug reactions that were not predicted by animal studies; is concerned that the Government has not commissioned or evaluated any formal research on the efficacy of animal experiments, and has no plans to do so; and, in common with 83 per cent. of general practitioners in a recent survey, calls upon the Government to facilitate an independent and transparent scientific evaluation of the use of animals as surrogate humans in drug safety testing and medical research.


98WELFARE OF ANIMALS17:5:05
Mr Mike Hancock
Dr Rudi Vis
Tom Brake
David Taylor
Mr Roger Godsiff
Bill Etherington
* 61
 Mr Piara S. KhabraMr Jimmy Hood
   That this House believes that all animals should be treated as sentient beings and is concerned that unacceptable practices where animals are treated as objects continue; further believes that all animals, at whatever stage of evolution, deserve protection and recognition; welcomes New Zealand's decision to introduce a bill to grant apes certain basic rights; and calls upon the Government to improve the welfare and status of all animals in the United Kingdom.


102ASTHMA AND FREE NHS PRESCRIPTIONS17:5:05
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Rudi Vis
Bill Etherington
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Mr Anthony Wright
Jeff Ennis
* 81
 John Bercow
   That this House commends the role of the charity Asthma UK and its campaigns on behalf of UK sufferers; is alarmed that the number of emergency hospital admissions due to asthma remains unacceptably high in the UK and accepts that part of the reason for this may be individuals' inability to pay for their prescribed medication; and believes such a strategy to be both unjust and economically negative, as limiting asthma treatment in such a way not only prolongs suffering and a deterioration in patients' qualities of life, but also burdens valuable NHS resources with further spiralling ongoing costs for treatment.


128PARENTING TIME PRESUMPTION18:5:05
Mrs Theresa May
Tim Loughton
David Taylor
Mr Edward Garnier
Michael Fabricant
Peter Bottomley
* 268
 Sir John ButterfillMr Alan DuncanMr David Curry
 Dr Richard TaylorPeter LawSammy Wilson
   That this House believes that separated parents should each have a legal presumption of contact with their children, so that both parents can continue to parent their children and children are able to benefit from being parented by both their parents, as well as from contact with any grandparents and extended family members able and willing to play a role in their upbringing; and urges the Government to replace the legal term `contact' with `parenting time' and to ensure that parenting time orders can be and are made and enforced by the courts, save where a child's safety would be at risk.


174DRAFT MARINE BILL24:5:05
Paddy Tipping
Linda Gilroy
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Mr John Randall
Norman Baker
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 230
 Nia GriffithSir Peter Soulsby
   That this House welcomes the inclusion of a draft Marine Bill in the 2005 legislative programme; notes that, in the light of increasing degradation of the marine environment and decline in its wildlife, the United Kingdom urgently needs a strategic and co-ordinated approach for managing and protecting its marine resources; therefore believes that this Marine Bill must be based on a system of spatial planning which allows different activities in the marine environment to be developed in a coherent and rational way and seeks to reduce conflict between the many users of the seas; further believes that the Bill must include reform of inshore fisheries; further believes that, given that more than half of the UK's wildlife is found in the sea, the Bill must put protection of wildlife at the heart of marine policy through measures including the designation of a network of nationally important marine sites; and calls on the Government to introduce a comprehensive Marine Bill at the earliest opportunity.

As an Amendment to Paddy Tipping's proposed Motion (Draft Marine Bill):

Robert Key
Andrew Stunell
Mr Michael Fallon
Mr Jeremy Hunt
Dr Evan Harris
Mr Nick Clegg
* 41
Line 11, after `sites;' insert `further believes that new provisions for marine archaeology must be included;'.
25:5:05(a1)


178CLIMATE CHANGE24:5:05
Mr Michael Meacher
Mr John Gummer
Norman Baker
Vera Baird
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr David Chaytor
* 351
 Dr Phyllis StarkeyMark Pritchard
   That this House agrees with the Government's Chief Scientific Adviser that climate change is a threat to civilisation; welcomes the cross-party agreement in favour of major cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, and particularly in carbon dioxide emissions, by 2050; believes that such a long-term target will best be met through a series of more regular milestones; and therefore notes the Climate Change Bill that was presented by a cross-party group of honourable Members in the final days before the General Election, and hopes that such a Bill will be brought forward in this Parliament so that annual cuts in carbon dioxide emissions of 3 per cent. can be delivered in a framework that includes regular reporting and new scrutiny and corrective processes.


197STUDENT BURSARIES FOR TRAINEE MIDWIVES24:5:05
Chris McCafferty
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jim Dobbin
Mr Mike Hancock
Tony Lloyd
Bob Russell
* 183
 Paul FarrellyMr Jamie Reed
   That this House recognises the vital role that midwives play in the NHS; notes that many student midwives face financial problems during their training and that, according to the Royal College of Midwives' poll, around a fifth of midwives fail to complete their studies due to financial hardship; and therefore supports the RCM campaign to provide a £10,000 non-means tested bursary for all student midwives, ensuring more students are attracted to midwifery, are able to complete their course and go on to become practising midwives.


220REVIEW OF NHS FUNDING FOR CHILDREN'S HOSPICES25:5:05
Jeff Ennis
Mr Fabian Hamilton
Mr Terry Rooney
Mr Anthony Wright
Roger Berry
Bob Russell
* 73
 Mr Jamie Reed
   That this House calls on the Government to undertake an urgent review of NHS funding for children's hospices through lead primary trusts; and given that children's hospices often serve wide geographical areas, believes that alternative models of NHS funding need to be explored, preferably involving local strategic health authorities.


237COMMERCIAL SEAL HUNTS AND THE IMPORTATION OF SEAL PRODUCTS INTO THE UK26:5:05
Mr Eric Martlew
Lynne Jones
Kelvin Hopkins
Peter Bottomley
David Lepper
Mr Martin Caton
* 192
 Peter LuffDr William McCreaMr Gregory Campbell
 Mr Lee Scott
   That this House notes with grave concern the killing of 317,672 seals in Canada's cruel commercial hunt in 2005; is appalled by the unacceptable cruelty of the hunt; notes that a team of independent veterinarians who observed the Canadian seal hunt in 2001 found that 42 per cent. of the seals skulls examined were found to have minimal or no fractures, suggesting that these animals were conscious when skinned; is concerned that the current level of killing is unsustainable for the harp seal population; further notes that trade data shows that thousands of seal skins were imported into the UK between 1995 and 2003; further notes that the US banned imports of all seal products in 1972 and that Belgium and Italy currently have initiatives to ban such trade; and calls on the Government to prohibit the import of all seal products into the UK.


241EXTRADITION ACT 200326:5:05
Mr Boris Johnson
Lynne Jones
Damian Green
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Paul Holmes
* 151
 Mr Robert WalterMark Pritchard
   That this House urges the Government to defer approving the extradition to the United States of any British subjects until such time as the United States Senate ratifies the Extradition Treaty of March 2003; further calls upon the Government to amend the Extradition Act 2003 (Designation of Part 2 Territories) Order 2003 and replace it with a new Order which requires the United States to supply prima facie evidence to accompany its extradition requests to the United Kingdom, as the UK has to do in relation to an extradition from the US; and further calls upon the Government to amend the Extradition Act 2003 to reflect the terms of Article 7 of the European Convention of Extradition on Place of Commission.


260SCIENTIFIC RESEARCH INTO MYALGIC ENCEPHALOPATHY/ENCEPHALOMYELITIS6:6:05
David Taylor
Mr Neil Gerrard
Dr Desmond Turner
John Robertson
Mr David Heath
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 225
 Mr Robert WalterMr Nick Clegg
   That this House notes that 2005 is the 50th anniversary of the first description in medical literature of the illness myalgic encephalopathy/encephalomyelitis (ME); is concerned by the subsequent lack of scientific research into the illness during that time, which has been a cause of distress to the quarter million ME sufferers in the UK; reminds the Government of the study, ME: Cost to the Nation, that put the annual economic cost of ME at £3.5 billion; is dismayed to learn that one of the few contemporary scientific studies into the causes of this illness, carried out at Glasgow University, is under threat from lack of funds; and calls on the Government to provide the necessary funds to secure and promote this and other studies into the cause and treatment of ME.

As an Amendment to David Taylor's proposed Motion (Scientific Research into Myalgic Encephalopathy/Encephalomyelitis):

Andrew Selous
Anne Milton
Tim Loughton
Dr Liam Fox
Sandra Osborne
Mr Laurence Robertson
* 21
Mark Pritchard
Line 9, at end add `by prioritising this study within existing research budgets.'.
27:6:05(a1)


355HUMAN AND TRADE UNION RIGHTS IN COLOMBIA16:6:05
Mr Frank Doran
Sir Menzies Campbell
Tony Lloyd
Peter Bottomley
John Battle
Mr Robert Walter
* 289
 Mr Alan BeithMark Pritchard
   That this House notes with concern the continuing human rights crisis in Colombia and the increase in assassinations of Colombian trade unionists last year; further notes that the vast majority of abuses are carried out by paramilitary groups that have documented links to the Colombian state security forces and that reports of extrajudicial executions carried out directly by the armed forces increased in 2004; calls on the Colombian Government fully to implement UN human rights recommendations in line with the policies of Colombian and international human rights organisations such as the TUC-backed Justice for Colombia coalition; and calls on the UK Government to freeze military aid to Colombia.


366FROZEN PENSIONS20:6:05
Nick Harvey
Mrs Gwyneth Dunwoody
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Nigel Evans
Andrew George
* 133
 Mr Mike Weir
   That this House believes that British pensioners living in Canada, New Zealand, Australia, South Africa and Zimbabwe suffer unfairly because the value of their pensions is frozen and not up-rated annually in line with inflation; notes that approximately 480,000 out of the UK's 900,000 expatriate pensioners live in these five countries; considers that treating these pensioners differently from those living in other countries is a grave injustice; welcomes the opinion given by Lord Carswell in the House of Lords on 26th May that once it is accepted that pensions should be paid to contributing pensioners resident abroad, then no justification remains for paying some less than others and less than UK residents; recalls the noble Lord's observation that `The Government may have been entitled under domestic law to take this course if it so chose, but for the reasons which I have indicated I consider that article 14 of the Convention [ECHR] operates to prevent such discrimination'; and urges the Government to expand the up-rating of pensions for all British pensioners living abroad.


378CHILDREN'S FOOD21:6:05
Mary Creagh
Peter Bottomley
Mr Gregory Campbell
David Taylor
Mr Andrew Dismore
Paul Holmes
* 283
 Mr Nigel EvansMr Alistair Carmichael
   That this House believes that, while the Government has introduced some measures to improve school meals, the crisis in children's diet-related health remains; notes that data from the Health Survey for England shows that between 1995 and 2003, the prevalence of obesity among children under 11 years rose from 9.9 per cent. to 13.7 per cent; welcomes the British Medical Association's report calling for tough action to tackle this alarming increase; recognises that in order to defuse the Food Standard Agency's `diet timebomb', additional measures are needed to address a number of factors, including marketing to children of foods containing high levels of fat, sugar and salt, the poor composition of foods on sale in schools, the lack of practical cooking skills in the national curriculum and insufficient promotion to children of healthy foods; and therefore supports in principle the provisions under the Children's Food Bill, introduced in the last Parliament and supported by 248 honourable Members and 137 national organisations, which seek a range of statutory measures to improve children's diets and future health.


388DYNAMIC DEMAND22:6:05
Colin Challen
Mr David Chaytor
Mark Lazarowicz
Peter Bottomley
Norman Baker
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 83
 Mr Ian Austin
   That this House notes that around £80 million a year is spent by National Grid on `response', a control system for handling unpredictable fluctuations in electricity demand; further notes that this is achieved largely by running thermal power plant at variable rates and partly loaded, a practice that reduces the efficiency and leads to additional carbon-dioxide emissions of around two million tonnes a year; further notes that the increasing use of renewables such as wind, solar and wave power will lead to a greater variability of generation; welcomes therefore the formation of the Dynamic Demand campaign to promote the use of very cheap controllers in industrial or domestic refrigerators and other suitable appliances which enable them, whenever acceptable operationally, to switch off during shortages of capacity and on at times when there is surplus capacity on the Grid; and calls on the Government to ensure this technology is widely adopted in order to reduce carbon-dioxide emissions and to facilitate the integration of an increasing proportion of electricity generated from renewable sources.


391CLIMATE CHANGE AND SUSTAINABLE ENERGY BILLS22:6:05
Mark Lazarowicz
Dr Alan Whitehead
Mr John Denham
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Andrew Stunell
Mr Mike Weir
* 329
 Mr Jonathan DjanoglyMr Jamie Reed
   That this House believes that climate change is one of the most pressing issues facing the world today and so views with concern the continuing increase in emissions of carbon dioxide; believes that new initiatives are needed to deal with these problems; therefore welcomes the introduction with cross-party support of the Climate Change and Sustainable Energy Bill and the Management of Energy in Buildings Bill by the honourable Members for Edinburgh North and Leith and Southampton, Test respectively; and notes that these Bills taken together would require the Prime Minister to report annually to Parliament on greenhouse gas emissions, require the Chancellor of the Exchequer to implement a fiscal strategy to promote energy efficient microenergy generation, require targets to be set for microgeneration, introduce a number of policies to help achieve those targets including the granting of permitted development status and the use of building regulations to ensure that new building will include a minimum standard for energy generation, introduce a renewable heat obligation requiring utility companies to supply heat from renewable sources, and would also facilitate the development of small community based sustainable energy schemes.


452COUNCIL OF EUROPE CONVENTION ON TRAFFICKING29:6:05
Sandra Gidley
Chris McCafferty
John Bercow
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Andrew George
* 116
 Kerry McCarthyMr Shahid Malik
   That this House notes with concern that trafficking of women, children and men is a growing problem in the UK, and that 32 out of 33 London boroughs have identified a problem with trafficked children; welcomes the fact that trafficking for sexual and labour exploitation are criminal offences in the UK, but is dismayed at the lack of measures needed to protect and support people who have been trafficked into the country, including safe housing and emergency medical support; and calls upon the Government urgently to sign and ratify the new Council of Europe Convention Against Trafficking, which is specifically aimed at protecting trafficked people's rights, and for the UK to use its presidency of the EU to encourage other member states to do the same.


468CIRCUS ANIMAL WELFARE29:6:05
Norman Baker
Mr Eric Martlew
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Mr John Randall
* 106
 David Lepper
   That this House is concerned about the welfare of wild animals in circuses; notes the large body of evidence collected by the Born Free Foundation, Animal Defenders International, RSPCA and others showing that a circus environment cannot provide for the needs of wild animals, including Anne the elephant; is appalled that Anne the elephant is still being moved around the country with Bobby Roberts Super Circus even though she suffers from arthritis; asserts that it would be in her best interests to be retired from circus life; recognises that the proposed duty of care requirement cannot be met in a circus environment; and calls on the Government to introduce measures to end the use of wild animals in circuses in the forthcoming Animal Welfare Bill.


524GUANTANAMO BAY6:7:05
Dr Desmond Turner
David Lepper
Ms Celia Barlow
Lynne Jones
Mr David Drew
Mr Mike Hancock
* 111
 Mr Andrew LoveKeith Vaz
   That this House calls on the Government clearly to condemn the inhumane treatment of detainees at Guantanamo Bay and to urge the United States Administration either to charge them, to prosecute them under due process of law, to keep them in acceptable prison conditions, or to release them if there is no reasonable evidence against them, and in particular to make representations to the United States Administration for the release of Omar Deghayes, a Libyan national and refugee normally resident in Brighton Kemptown constituency.


596ECUMENICAL ACCOMPANIMENT PROGRAMME OF THE WORLD COUNCIL OF CHURCHES14:7:05
Sir Menzies Campbell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Neil Gerrard
Mr David Drew
Andrew George
Bob Russell
* 111
 Michael Jabez Foster
   That this House welcomes the Ecumenical Accompaniment Programme of the World Council of Churches in arranging for human rights observers to work in Israel and Palestine; and encourages the UK Government to work with intergovernmental organisations to establish a human rights observation force in the Occupied Territories, and to press for an end to the occupation in a just and peaceful solution to the conflict on the basis of UN resolutions and the international rule of law.


622USE OF 0870 TELEPHONE NUMBERS BY GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENTS19:7:05
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
David Simpson
Mrs Iris Robinson
Bob Spink
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 59
 Mark Pritchard
   That this House notes the proliferation of 0870 prefix telephone numbers used by a range of Government Departments for members of the public to get in touch; recognises the fact that they can cost up to two and a half times more than regional numbers, and that in some cases departments make substantial profits from such numbers; further notes that last year the Government's Central Office of Information urged Departments not to use 0870 numbers as the cost could act as a barrier to communicating information that the citizen should have access to as a right; and calls upon the Government to take action to end this indefensible practice.


641SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES BILL20:7:05
Julia Goldsworthy
Mr David Drew
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Alan Simpson
Matthew Taylor
* 270
 Mr James ArbuthnotMiss Julie KirkbrideMr Jonathan Djanogly
   That this House welcomes the Sustainable Communities Bill introduced into the House before the General Election and supported by over 200 honourable Members; notes that the bill requires the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Afairs and the National Assembly for Wales, in conjunction with local authorities and local communities, to draw up and implement strategies to promote local services and local economic activity and measures for protecting the environment, social justice and greater political involvement; further notes that the bill specifically enables councils and communities significantly to influence Government policy and actions on these issues; further notes too that this philosophy is in accord with the idea of localism being espoused by many honourable Members; and therefore hopes that the bill will be re-introduced in this Parliament.


697MODERNISING COMPANY LAW10:10:05
Sarah McCarthy-Fry
Martin Salter
Lyn Brown
Helen Goodman
Mr Sadiq Khan
Mike Gapes
* 210
 Dr William McCreaMrs Iris RobinsonMr Jamie Reed
   That this House believes companies are critical in achieving the aims of sustainable development and to making poverty history, but that in order to be able to do so their freedom to operate must be balanced with clear responsibilities to society and the environment; and urges the Government to enshrine in new company law a duty for directors to identify, consider, act and report on any negative social and environmental impacts caused by a company's activities in the UK or overseas.

As Amendments to Sarah McCarthy-Fry's proposed Motion (Modernising Company Law):

Mr Ian Taylor
Mr John MacDougall
Colin Burgon
Mr Kevan Jones
Mr Barry Sheerman
Mike Wood
* 6
Line 4, leave out from `urges' to end and insert `companies to embrace corporate social responsibility by engaging in activities most suitable to their own objectives and resources'.
25:10:05(a1)
Martin Horwood
* 1
Line 6, after `overseas', add `and further urges that such a duty should place a lesser responsibility on small businesses, in recognition of the already heavy burden of regulation on small business, while holding larger corporations to account.'.
28:3:06(a2)


728HYPOTHYROIDISM11:10:05
Mr Mark Oaten
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Bob Spink
Mr Mike Hancock
* 149
 Mr David CurryMark Lazarowicz
   That this House calls on the Government to raise awareness of hypothyroidism and the dangers of misdiagnosing an underactive thyroid and to promote the use of a range of treatments including thyroxine to address the current inadequacy of testing, diagnosis and treatment of the condition.


729CHILDREN AND HUMAN RIGHTS11:10:05
Mr Greg Pope
Mr Kevin Barron
Mr Paul Burstow
Helen Goodman
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Dr Richard Taylor
* 164
 Mr Austin MitchellMr David ClellandMr Jamie Reed
   That this House notes the July 2005 report from the Council of Europe Committee of Social Rights, monitoring conformity with the European Social Charter, which finds the UK in breach of human rights obligations by failing to afford children the same protection under the law on assault that adults take for granted; and believes that this modernising and progressive reform proposal is a fundamental issue of equality and human rights that has been trivialised for too long.


750CASH MACHINE CHARGES12:10:05
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Jim Dobbin
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
* 99
 Mr John Leech
   That this House condemns the sharp rise in the number of cash machines which charge customers for removing their money; notes that convenience machines placed at locations such as supermarkets, public houses, post offices, factories, amusement parks and service centres charge customers in the region of £2.00 for each transaction, with the number of machines charging rising each year; further notes that overall this is costing an estimated £125 million a year, hitting those on low incomes hardest; and calls on the firms operating the machines to remove these charges.


783ALCOHOL TREATMENT18:10:05
Dr Howard Stoate
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Martin Caton
Laura Moffatt
* 83
 Mr David Burrowes
   That this House welcomes the campaign by Alcohol Concern to increase investment in alcohol treatment; notes that eight million people in the United Kingdom drink at harmful or hazardous levels; is concerned that alcohol misuse causes around 22,000 deaths each year and costs the UK £18 billion a year; recognises the excellent work of alcohol treatment services for individuals and for society; further notes the recent study showing a saving of £5 for every £1 spent on treating people with alcohol problems; and calls upon the Government to make alcohol treatment the priority it should be.


787LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSION SCHEME18:10:05
Paddy Tipping
Judy Mallaber
Kelvin Hopkins
Joan Walley
Helen Jones
Mr David Drew
* 185
 Gwyn ProsserMr Don Foster
   That this House welcomes the successful discussions between Government and public sector trade unions on future pension provision; notes that the retirement age will normally remain at 60 years for present employees; acknowledges that, given an ageing population, pension changes are necessary for the future; believes that these changes are best achieved by meaningful discussion between employers and employees; and looks forward to an early and successful settlement on the Local Government Pension Scheme.


816HOUSING BENEFIT REFORM20:10:05
Mr Andrew Love
Dr Brian Iddon
Kelvin Hopkins
Clive Efford
Jon Cruddas
Dr Desmond Turner
* 149
 Norman Lamb
   That this House notes that October marks the ninth anniversary of the introduction of the single room rent restriction on housing benefit available to single, childless under 25 year-old claimants; notes that research published by the Department for Work and Pensions in July records single room rent (SRR) claimants as experiencing an average shortfall of £35.14 per week between their benefit and the rent they owe; notes that this is more than double the average £16.34 shortfall faced by non-SRR housing benefit claimants; is concerned this has left many vulnerable young people facing serious rent arrears, eviction and homelessness; notes that the Department for Work and Pensions research concludes that the July 2001 changes, designed to reflect more adequately the costs of shared accommodation, have had no more than a marginal impact on the level of benefit shortfalls and access to accommodation; and supports the call by Centrepoint, Child Poverty Action Group, Citizens Advice, Crisis, Shelter and the YMCA to persuade Ministers not to carry additional restrictions for young people into the local housing allowance being introduced in the forthcoming Housing Benefit Reform Bill.


869WORKING OF THE CHILDREN ACT 200426:10:05
Mr Eric Pickles
James Brokenshire
Mr Mark Field
Vera Baird
Mrs Iris Robinson
Mr Brian Jenkins
* 163
 Norman LambMark Pritchard
   That this House urges the Government to remove the veil of secrecy from the workings of the Children Act 2004; considers that the closed door policy of the family courts breeds suspicion and a culture of secrecy which does nothing to instil confidence in those using them, which affects not just the courts but the social services departments of local authorities; and believes that it is possible to preserve the anonymity of children involved in the proceedings without the cumbersome rules which obstruct parents from receiving advice and support, which in particular works to the disadvantage of parents with special learning difficulty.


902UN SECURITY COUNCIL INTERVENTION IN BURMA31:10:05
Vera Baird
John Bercow
Sir Menzies Campbell
Dr Liam Fox
Mr Alistair Carmichael
Joan Ruddock
* 253
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House warmly welcomes the report Threat to Peace-A Call for the UN Security Council to Act in Burma, commissioned by Desmond Tutu and Vaclav Havel from DLA Piper Rudnick Gray Cary, which finds that Burma meets the criteria for the United Nations Security Council to intervene in the crisis in that country; supports a resolution that would outline the major reasons for the Security Council intervention, focusing on the threat to the peace caused by the regimes; requires the Government of Burma to work with the Secretary-General's office in implementing a plan for national reconciliation and a restoration of a democratically-elected government; requests the Secretary-General to remain engaged with the dispute resolution process and requires that he report to the Security Council on a regular basis: urges the Government of Burma to ensure immediate, safe, and unhindered access to all parts of the country for United Nations and international humanitarian organisations to provide assistance to the most vulnerable groups, including internally displaced persons; calls for the immediate unconditional release of Aung San Suu Kyi and all prisoners of conscience; and calls on the Government to work with UN Security Council members to ensure a resolution in such terms is passed.


908SAFETY ON THE THAMES1:11:05
Mr Alan Duncan
Mr Julian Brazier
Mr John Hayes
Mr Greg Knight
Justine Greening
Mr David Evennett
* 112
 Mr Iain Duncan SmithMark Pritchard
   That this House salutes the robust standards for qualifying as a waterman on the River Thames introduced since the loss of 51 lives on board the Marchioness in 1989; welcomes the introduction of a national Boatmasters' licence for other waterways as a result of a European Directive, but observes that it requires lower standards than the existing requirements for Watermen of the Thames; is concerned that the new licence will diminish the standards and experience demanded of Watermen on the Thames; notes that 77 per cent. of the responses to the recent consultation were from Thames practitioners, all expressing similar concerns; and calls on the Government to make arrangements with the European Union which continue to allow special arrangements to be made for the Thames, as proposed for the Rhine and Danube.


922HORSE RIDING ESTABLISHMENTS AND INSURANCE2:11:05
Mr Stephen Crabb
Mr Roger Williams
Mark Williams
Mr Richard Benyon
Sandra Gidley
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 42
 Mrs Maria MillerMark Pritchard
   That this House notes that horse-riding establishments are encountering difficulty with insurance claims following accidents and in obtaining insurance cover generally following the House of Lords interpretation of the Animals Act 1971 in the case of Mirvahedy v Henley [2003] 2 AII ER 401; further notes that this decision has limited the availability of insurance and increased the cost, adversely affecting the commercial viability of the equine sector; further notes the petition of the Country Land and Business Association (CLA), which attracted 911 signatures at country shows in 2005; and supports the CLA in its calls on the Government to remedy this situation by way of legislative amendment as soon as possible.


957RIVER ACCESS FOR NON-POWERED CRAFT7:11:05
Mr John Grogan
Mr David Heath
Andrew George
Mike Penning
Peter Bottomley
Derek Wyatt
* 114
 Mr Rob Wilson
   That this House urges the Government to extend legislation on access to the countryside to allow canoeists and users of other non-powered craft the same access rights as those provided for walkers; acknowledges that the most successful Olympic canoeing nation, Germany, requires land owners to tolerate the use of non-powered craft on their waterways; and believes that with increased access to waterways, there will be greater participation in canoeing leading both to obvious health benefits for the nation and to increased chances of future Olympic success.

As Amendments to Mr John Grogan's proposed Motion (River Access for Non-Powered Craft):

Martin Salter
Mr Martyn Jones
Mark Tami
Jon Cruddas
Robert Key
Mr Mark Lancaster
* 20
Line 1, Line 1, leave out from `House' to first `to' and insert `notes the campaign'.
6:12:05(a1)
Martin Salter
Mr Martyn Jones
Mark Tami
Jon Cruddas
Robert Key
Mr Mark Lancaster
* 28
Line 3, Line 3, leave out from `walkers' to end and insert `but urges the Government not to alter riparian rights; recommends that any increase in access to canoeists and non-powered craft be by voluntary access agreements only, which have been proven to work in both England and Wales; believes that the users of all canoes and non-powered craft on inland waterways should be subject to the same restrictions as anglers, and the same penalties for infringements; further believes that the Environment Agency should have the power to close any waterway to any craft in the interests of protecting sensitive aquatic environments; and considers that, notwithstanding the forthcoming Olympic Games, it should be remembered that angling is a sport which has 4 million participants in England and Wales with an annual economy of £3.5 billion and which has had great success in recent World Championships.'.
6:12:05(a2)


967COMBATING CASH DELIVERY CRIME8:11:05
Daniel Kawczynski
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mike Penning
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Nigel Dodds
* 95
 Mr David CrausbyMr Nicholas Brown
   That this House deplores the number of cash and valuables in transit (CVIT) attacks on security industry staff over the past two years; is concerned about the increased use of violent weapons such as guns and knives in such attacks; notes that in 2004 a member of the public was tragically killed and a number of staff were shot and stabbed; commends the bravery of the crews who deliver the cash; recognises that the provision of cash is an essential service to consumers and business alike; welcomes the joint initiatives pursued by Group 4 Securicor, GMB union, BSIA and police forces in order to prevent attacks and protect employees and the general public; calls on the Government to recognise CVIT attacks as a human rather than purely a business crime and to tackle this problem urgently as part of its wider organised crime agenda.


969STABILITY FOR BABIES IN PUBLIC CARE8:11:05
Ms Dari Taylor
Tim Loughton
Annette Brooke
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Mr Julian Brazier
Vera Baird
* 129
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House believes that no baby in public care should have more than two placement moves in its first year of life and supports the campaign by the British Association for Adoption and Fostering to require Government and local authorities to publish annual statistics about how many times these children are moved and to invest in concurrent planning.


999RELIGIOUS PERSECUTION IN CHINA10:11:05
Mr David Burrowes
Steve Webb
Mike Penning
Andrew Selous
Mr Mark Lancaster
Mr David Gauke
* 82
 Mr Robert Walter
   That this House expresses grave concern at the persecution suffered by Christians in China, through imprisonment, torture, financial penalties and other mistreatment; condemns the numerous arrests of Christians which have taken place in recent months, especially those accompanied by beating resulting in serious injury, and condemns the ongoing incarceration of several church leaders who are in poor health; notes in particular the sentencing of Pastor Cai Zhuohua, his wife and brother-in-law in Beijing on 8th November to three years', two years' and one-and-a-half years' imprisonment respectively for charges relating to the production of bibles and religious literature; expresses concern at the prosecution of religious activities under the guise of economic crimes; and calls on the Chinese Government to refrain from those acts which defeat the object and purpose of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, which protects the right of the individual to religious freedom, and to which it is a signatory, and to discontinue treating with impunity those who perpetrate human rights abuses against religious believers in violation of international human rights standards.


1001UPRATING OF FROZEN PENSIONS10:11:05
Mr David Laws
Nick Harvey
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr Nigel Evans
Danny Alexander
Sandra Gidley
* 104
 John BercowMr John WhittingdaleMr Robert Walter
 Miss Julie KirkbrideMr Bob LaxtonMr Joe Benton
 Mrs Linda RiordanMr Greg HandsRosie Cooper
 Jeremy Wright
   That this House believes that British pensioners living in countries where the value of their pensions are frozen and not uprated annually in line with inflation is an injustice that should not be allowed to continue given that they have paid taxes and national insurance for their pensions; considers that treating these pensioners differently from those living in other overseas locations who have their pensions automatically uprated is increasingly out-dated in a world of great freedoms; further believes that the state's role is to support individuals in planning and retirement security and that this cannot be achieved if for no logical reason an individual's entitlement is affected by where they retire; and calls on the Government as it considers proposals for future pension reform to meet groups representing pensioners affected by frozen pensions to discuss how reform of the pension system to one fit for the 21st century will affect them, and how a just system of pension provision can be secured for those who move overseas.


1020FUNDING FOR PRIMARY CARE TRUSTS TO PROVIDE HERCEPTIN14:11:05
Mr Andrew Lansley
Mr John Baron
Mr Crispin Blunt
Mr Simon Burns
Tim Loughton
Dr Andrew Murrison
* 75
 Mr Mark Harper
   That this House welcomes the decision of North Stoke Primary Care Trust (PCT) to fund the cancer drug Herceptin for Ms Elaine Barber; expresses concern over recent reports that many women with breast cancer are being denied funding for Herceptin; believes that all women suffering from both early-stage and advanced breast cancer should have access to Herceptin where it is clinically appropriate; notes that a recent study in the New England Journal of Medicine shows that where women are HER2 positive Herceptin can cut the risk of breast cancer returning in women by up to half; recognises that, although Herceptin is not yet licensed for early-stage breast cancer, many clinicians are prepared to accept liability for prescribing it; notes with concern that many PCTs are already burdened by deficits and unable to provide the drug; and therefore calls on the Government to make funding available for PCTs to provide Herceptin for early-stage breast cancer until such time as the drug is approved by NICE.

As an Amendment to Mr Andrew Lansley's proposed Motion (Funding For Primary Care Trusts To Provide Herceptin):

Ann Winterton
* 1
Line 3, after `Herceptin', insert `including Mrs Joanne Leese of Alsager'.
15:11:05(a1)


1024PARDONS FOR SOLDIERS EXECUTED DURING THE GREAT WAR14:11:05
Andrew Mackinlay
David Lepper
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Mr Alistair Carmichael
John Cummings
* 81
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House regrets that 13 years have passed since the tabling of a motion which requested the restoration of the names and reputations of the 307 soldiers of the British Empire Forces court martialled and executed, mostly on the Western Front in the four years from 1914 to 1918, and now reiterates that request; recalls that those men faced charges ranging from desertion, cowardice, quitting posts, sleeping at posts, disobedience, striking a superior officer and casting away arms; regrets the deficiences in their opportunity to prepare adequate defence and appeals; recognises that these soldiers endured long periods of severe cold and damp, lack of food and sleep coupled with the stress associated with constant shellfire; considers that the vast majority of the 307 executed were as patriotic and brave as their million other compatriots who perished in the conflict, and that even if the behaviour of a small minority of the 307 may have fallen below that of the highest standards then time, compassion and justice dictates that all of these soldiers should now be treated as victims of the conflict; and urges the Prime Minister to recommend a posthumous pardon for all 307, thus bringing to a close a deeply unhappy and controversial chapter in the history of the Great War.


1026LYMPHOMA MANIFESTO15:11:05
Mr David Lidington
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr Paul Burstow
Mr John Baron
Daniel Kawczynski
Mike Penning
* 206
 Derek WyattPeter LuffLembit Öpik
 Mr Jonathan DjanoglyLynne FeatherstoneDavid T. C. Davies
   That this House applauds the Lymphoma Association, Leukaemia CARE, Leukaemia Research Fund and CancerBACUP on the launch of the Lymphoma Manifesto; notes that every hour of every day one person in the UK is diagnosed with lymphatic cancer; further notes that given the appropriate treatment at the appropriate time, many lymphoma patients can have their disease managed effectively or even be cured; recognises that successful treatment of lymphoma depends on accurate diagnosis; believes that all patients should have access to the best treatment regardless of where they live; agrees that every patient deserves high quality care and support throughout diagnosis and treatment; acknowledges that treating the patients of tomorrow requires investment in research today; and calls on the Government to respond constructively to the Lymphoma Manifesto objectives of securing accurate diagnosis, universal access to treatment, quality care and information, and investment in research that will ensure that lymphoma patients receive the best treatment, by making lymphoma care and research a high priority within overall NHS spending and investment.


1031PLANNING AND RENEWABLE ENERGY15:11:05
Norman Baker
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Joan Walley
Norman Lamb
Dr Alan Whitehead
Gregory Barker
* 83
 Mr Michael MatesMr Tim Yeo
   That this House acknowledges that climate change is a significant threat which must be tackled; recognises that reducing energy consumption is the most sustainable response to climate change; believes that a broad range of renewable technologies have an important role to play in a low carbon economy; supports the need for effective community involvement in considering renewable energy projects; notes that the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee Report on the Practicalities of Renewables concluded that planning should not be seen as an obstacle to new renewables development; further recognises that the land use planning process plays a vital role in ensuring projects are planned sensitively and community concerns addressed; expresses concern that under Section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989 decisions over renewable energy projects over 50 megawatts are taken outside the planning process; and calls for amendments to the Act to address this democratic deficit by ensuring only onshore wind projects above 200 megawatts that are of a genuine strategic nature are considered in this way.


1038END VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN CAMPAIGN15:11:05
Vera Baird
Mike Penning
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Martin Caton
Jim Sheridan
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 248
 Mr Simon BurnsColin BurgonMr Jimmy Hood
 Mr Peter RobinsonColin ChallenKerry McCarthy
 Mr Shailesh VaraMr Shahid MalikDanny Alexander
 Emily Thornberry
   That this House condemns all forms of violence against women; notes that almost half of women experience domestic violence, sexual assault or stalking in their lifetime and that at least 200 women are forced into marriage and 2000 women are trafficked into the UK for sexual exploitation each year; and therefore supports the End Violence Against Women Campaign's call for an integrated approach to addressing violence against women in all its forms.


1046BREASTFEEDING IN PUBLIC PLACES16:11:05
Annette Brooke
Paul Farrelly
Mrs Janet Dean
Julie Morgan
Jo Swinson
Sandra Gidley
* 172
 Norman LambChris Huhne
   That this House recognises the benefits of breastfeeding for babies and welcomes the provisions of the recently introduced Breastfeeding etc. Bill which propose to address some of society's attitudes to breastfeeding; notes that research shows that breast milk is the ideal first food for most babies; regrets that the UK has one of the lowest breastfeeding rates in Europe, with just one in five babies receiving breastmilk by the time they are six months old, although the World Health Organisation recommends that babies need nothing other than breastmilk for the first six months of life; is deeply concerned that many mothers report having been harassed for breastfeeding in public, while others have stopped breastfeeding early or chosen not to breastfeed as they have anticipated embarrassment or difficulties in feeding their babies whilst in public; supports UNICEF's call for legislation to protect breastfeeding mothers' rights to feed their babies in public areas and the Baby Friendly Initiative; appreciates that social attitudes are slowly changing but that there is a long way to go; and calls for greater understanding and positive attitudes to ensure that breastfeeding is a normal part of everyday life.


1068INTEREST RATES CHARGED BY DOORSTEP LENDERS17:11:05
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Gregory Campbell
Paul Holmes
Bob Russell
Mr Mike Hancock
* 87
 Mr Robert Walter
   That this House is appalled by the extortionate interest rates that doorstep lenders charge low-income households; welcomes the Pathway to Financial Inclusion campaign launched by the National Housing Federation and Debt on Our Doorstep; calls on honourable Members to support its three step approach; urges the Government to reduce the average annual percentage interest rate of 177 per cent. charged by doorstep lenders by placing a ceiling on interest rates; recommends that the Government provide a pathway into financial inclusion by requiring doorstep lenders to register borrowers' repayment records with credit reference agencies, thus allowing them to build up a credit history; and recommends that the Government investigate legislation which will introduce the right to a basic bank account for every UK citizen, giving the one in 12 households without access to a bank account, 60 per cent. of them social housing tenants, access to mainstream banking.

As an Amendment to Mr Andrew Dismore's proposed Motion (Interest Rates Charged by Doorstep Lenders):

David Taylor
David Lepper
Andrew George
Jeremy Corbyn
Mark Durkan
Mr David Drew
* 44
Line 12, after `banking', insert `; and calls on the Government to do more to promote the virtues of community credit unions as an excellent means of extending financial inclusion and discouraging people on low incomes from using doorstep lenders.'.
21:11:05(a1)


1085SUNDAY TRADING HOURS22:11:05
Mr Brian Jenkins
Mr Simon Burns
Mr Alan Beith
Mr Edward Leigh
Charlotte Atkins
Mrs Janet Dean
* 223
 Mr Jamie ReedMeg Hillier
   That this House cherishes the importance of Sundays as a collective day of rest and worship and as a day for families to spend together; believes that deregulation of Sunday trading would have a detrimental impact on Britain's 2.7 million shopworkers, on the police, security, banking, distribution, transport, health and catering staff who also have to work when shops are open, on the children and families of all these staff and on the communities around large stores which already suffer congestion and noise for six and a half days a week; welcomes the NOP poll that shows that 62 per cent. of the public do not want any extension of the current six hours of Sunday opening by large stores; agrees with the public that 150 hours per week is enough for anyone to do their shopping; and believes that any extension of Sunday trading hours of large stores would have a serious impact on neighbourhood and community stores and would lead to job losses in this sector and a deterioration in local services.


1102POLICE INJURY RETIREMENT PENSIONS23:11:05
Mr Edward Garnier
Patrick Mercer
Mrs Cheryl Gillan
Mr Jonathan Djanogly
Chris Grayling
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 134
 Mr Michael MooreMr Jamie Reed
   That this House notes that a number of retired police officers who have been receiving injury awards face having those awards cut when they reach statutory retirement age; further notes that many of those officers believed that the awards would be paid to them for life; further notes that awards of this kind were normally made to officers injured while engaged in protecting the interests of the public; and calls on the Government to investigate whether officers have been misled about the rules that would apply to their awards.


1113TRIDENT24:11:05
Mr David Chaytor
Joan Ruddock
Sir Menzies Campbell
Mr Michael Moore
Mr Desmond Swayne
Mr Tobias Ellwood
* 177
 Mr Robert Goodwill
   That this House welcomes the Government's decision to launch a public debate on the future of the United Kingdom's nuclear weapons; recognises the significantly changed international circumstances from those in which the current Trident missile system was conceived, designed and constructed; is aware that there are a number of options available to the Government in considering replacements for the current system; and, therefore, calls on the Government to publish a consultation paper setting out the issues, including threat assessments, estimated costs and all nuclear and non-nuclear options, as a basis for the public debate.


1125LOCATION OF FEE-CHARGING CASH MACHINES28:11:05
Dan Norris
Bob Russell
Jeremy Corbyn
Mark Durkan
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Brian Iddon
* 72
 Dr Doug NaysmithMr Bill OlnerMr John Grogan
   That this House strongly condemns the fees levied by a rapidly growing number of cash machine operators who charge bank customers to access their own money; and calls on the banks to assist customers who wish to boycott fee-charging machines initially by widely publicising their exact location, following the example of the Bristol Evening Posts's `Don't Feed the Money Monsters' campaign, and ultimately by working with the firms which operate the machines to remove these charges for the benefit of all bank customers across the UK.


1126ARMS TRADE TREATY28:11:05
John Bercow
Roger Berry
Tony Baldry
Sir Menzies Campbell
Malcolm Bruce
Mike Gapes
* 98
 Annette BrookeMrs Madeleine Moon
   That this House is dismayed at the continued uncontrolled proliferation of arms around the globe which results in one death every minute, undermines development, fuels conflict and enables criminal activity to flourish; notes that the UK is the second biggest arms exporter in the world and has a particular responsibility better to control this trade; acknowledges that the development of an international Arms Trade Treaty (ATT) would ensure all states were bound by better rules governing arms transfers; congratulates the UK Government for its leadership in the promotion of such a treaty, which now has the support of over 40 countries across the world; further notes the Government's intention to begin negotiations for an ATT within the UN General Assembly during 2006; and calls on all hon. Members to use every chance to promote the ATT over the coming months, particularly with their international counterparts, in order to ensure that next year's historic opportunity is not missed and that negotiations begin.


1138MOTORWAY DRIVING (No. 2)29:11:05
Kitty Ussher
David Taylor
Dr Rudi Vis
Graham Stringer
Mrs Iris Robinson
Mr David S. Borrow
* 110
 Julie MorganEmily ThornberryNia Griffith
   That this House recognises the importance of improving the quality of motorway driving; and urges the Government to introduce measures to make it compulsory for newly qualified drivers to undertake some form of motorway tuition, such as Pass Plus, before obtaining a driving licence permitting driving on motorways, to reduce the present number of motorway accidents.


1141CONTRACTION AND CONVERGENCE APPROACH TO CLIMATE CHANGE29:11:05
Colin Challen
David Taylor
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Alan Meale
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr Martin Caton
* 52
 Matthew Taylor
   That this House welcomes the presentation of the Climate Change (Contraction and Convergence) Bill, which seeks to establish a clear, full-time framework for tackling climate change; notes that humankind has no choice but to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to a sustainable level within a defined period; further notes that it is unlikely that any international framework will succeed if it is not based on the principle of equity through the equal distribution of emissions rights, and that any solution put forward which does not solve the problem of climate change faster than the problem is created is no solution at all; and calls upon members of parliaments around the world to put forward similar bills in their own legislatures.


1162ESTABLISHMENT OF A DAILY NEWSPAPER IN WELSH30:11:05
Hywel Williams
Julie Morgan
Bill Wiggin
Mark Williams
Mr Angus MacNeil
Mark Durkan
* 33
 David Lepper
   That this House concurs with the view expressed in 2003 by the Committee of Experts monitoring UK implementations of the Council of Europe's Charter for Regional or Minority Languages that the lack of daily news in printed form in Welsh is an anomaly when compared with other regional or minority languages in Europe; welcomes plans to establish a daily newspaper in Welsh as an important contribution to democracy in Wales; notes the return of the Committee of Experts in December; and calls on the Government and devolved administration to take all possible steps to facilitate the establishment of a daily newspaper in Welsh.


1170CAMPAIGN FOR A TRADE UNION FREEDOM BILL30:11:05
Tony Lloyd
John McDonnell
Alan Keen
Mr Frank Doran
Jon Cruddas
Frank Dobson
* 128
 Ms Celia BarlowMary Creagh
   That this House recognises that free and independent trade unions are a force for good in UK society and around the world, and are vital to democracy; welcomes the positive role modern unions play in providing protection for working people and winning fairness at work; notes the 1906 Trades Disputes Act granted unions the legal freedom to take industrial action; regrets that successive anti-union legislation has meant that trade union rights are now weaker than those introduced by the Trades Disputes Act; notes the overwhelming support at both the Trades Union Congress and Labour Party Conference for the Gate Gourmet workers and for improvements in union rights, including measures to simplify ballot procedures and to allow limited supportive action, following a ballot, in specific circumstances; further notes that these conferences called for legislation which conformed to International Labour Organisation Conventions ratified by the UK; and therefore welcomes the decision of the 2005 Trades Union Congress to campaign for a Trade Union Freedom Bill to mark the 100th anniversary of the 1906 Trades Disputes Act.

As an Amendment to Tony Lloyd's proposed Motion (Campaign for a Trade Union Freedom Bill):

Peter Bottomley
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 2
Line 4, leave out from `work' to end.
1:12:05(a1)


1186NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE REPORT ON TREATING STROKES1:12:05
Mr Andrew Lansley
Ben Chapman
Mr Michael Jack
Judy Mallaber
Dr Doug Naysmith
Mark Hunter
* 171
 Derek WyattSimon Hughes
   That this House welcomes the publication of the National Audit Office's (NAO's) report on stroke, Reducing Brain Damage; believes that through treating stroke as a medical emergency much more can be done to ensure efficacy in stroke care; is concerned at the shortfalls identified in service provision, despite some recent progress; notes with concern the huge cost to society, the NHS and the wider economy that stroke represents each year; is disturbed at the large disparities in investment and service provision between stroke and coronary heart disease revealed in the report; shares the view of the NAO and the Stroke Association that stroke should be given a much higher priority by the Government and the NHS; and calls on the Government to take urgent action to address the NAO's recommendations, not least to tackle the alarming lack of awareness of stroke.


1197REPLACEMENT FOR TRIDENT WEAPONS5:12:05
Mr Michael Meacher
Graham Stringer
Dr Ian Gibson
David Lepper
Mr Ken Purchase
Lynne Jones
* 106
 Dr Howard Stoate
   That this House believes there should be the fullest possible public debate on a decision to replace the Trident nuclear weapons system; notes that a successor to Trident could cost as much as £25 billion, therefore affecting significantly other public spending options; calls on the Government to produce a Green Paper on Trident replacement that considers all possible options, including non-replacement; and further calls on the Government not to conclude any agreements, or to engage in preparations to build a new generation of nuclear weapons, until after this debate and a deciding vote held in Parliament.


1198DECENNIAL CENSUS RECORDS5:12:05
Mr Mike Hancock
Bob Russell
Graham Stringer
Mr David Heath
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
* 165
 John BercowCharles HendryMr Rob Wilson
   That this House notes that the Freedom of Information Act 2000 repealed the 100-year closure period for decennial census records, but that, nevertheless, the Department for Constitutional Affairs and the National Archives assert that it is Government policy that the 1911 Census shall remain closed to inspection for 100 years; and urges the Information Commissioner to take an early opportunity to publish his advice on this matter.


1252INTERNATIONAL DEVELOPMENT REPORTING AND TRANSPARENCY13:12:05
Ann McKechin
John Battle
John Bercow
Mr Nicholas Brown
John Barrett
Dan Norris
* 96
 Graham StringerMalcolm BruceMark Hunter
   That this House welcomes the publication of the Private Member's Bill of the right hon. Member for Coatbridge, Chryston and Bellshill on international development; notes that the Bill promotes the target of spending 0.7 per cent. of gross national investment on overseas development assistance and embraces the Millennium Development Goals; further notes that the Bill calls for an annual report to Parliament and promotes greater accountability, effectiveness and transparency in overseas development assistance; and urges all hon. Members to attend the Second Reading of the Bill on 20th January 2006.

As an Amendment to Ann McKechin's proposed Motion (International Development Reporting and Transparency):

Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Mrs Betty Williams
Lynne Featherstone
Lorely Burt
Nia Griffith
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods
* 8
Line 7, after `Members', insert `who can'.
20:12:05(a1)


1259INFLAMMATORY ARTHRITIS13:12:05
Mr David Amess
Mr Paul Burstow
Bob Spink
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Peter Bottomley
* 84
 Angela WatkinsonMr Brian Binley
   That this House welcomes the launch of the new All Party Parliamentary Group on Inflammatory Arthritis; recognises that over 750,000 people in the UK are living with a form of inflammatory arthritis; supports all efforts to raise awareness of a range of "Everyday Everests" - which are everyday activities which inflammatory arthritis patients find difficult or impossible to carry out; believes that the disease deserves a higher public profile; calls on all parliamentarians to help prioritise this worthwhile cause; and urges the Government to take action to improve the lives of the thousands of people around the country affected by inflammatory arthritis.


1281PROCUREMENT IN THE HEALTHCARE SECTOR15:12:05
Mr Mark Oaten [R]
Bob Spink
Mr Adam Holloway
Mr Mike Hancock
Mrs Iris Robinson
Annette Brooke
* 67
 Mr Frank FieldJohn Thurso
   That this House is concerned that the Government's policy on procurement in the healthcare sector will undermine patient choice, innovation and patient care, particularly with the provision of stoma care products and services, pressure area care, chemical reagents and wound care, where patients, industry and professionals are expressing alarm at the potential for increased risk to patient safety and well-being; recognises that an emphasis on financial savings could be counter-effective in passing the cost on to other areas of public sector provision; notes that the Assistive Technology sector of medical devices, in particular, is highly service-orientated and failure to recognise this in value for money calculations will result in patients being seriously disadvantaged; and calls for the current policy to be brought to an immediate halt and for more appropriate models to be reviewed urgently in conjunction with patients, industry and professionals.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1293ZIMBABWEAN ASYLUM SEEKERS AND THE RIGHT TO WORK19:12:05
Kate Hoey
Mr Graham Stuart
Annette Brooke
Peter Bottomley
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mike Penning
* 75
 Patrick HallEmily Thornberry
   That this House accepts that Zimbabweans refused asylum in the UK cannot be returned to Zimbabwe because of conditions prevailing in that country; is concerned that their ineligibility for state benefits renders many destitute; and calls on the Home Secretary to grant them the right to work so they can support themselves financially and make a contribution to society during their time in the UK while developing their professional and technical skills in order to contribute to the rebuilding of Zimbabwe once political change renders it safe for them to return.


1300TERMINATOR TECHNOLOGY19:12:05
Andrew George
Mr Michael Meacher
Alan Simpson
Joan Ruddock
Angus Robertson
Mr Peter Ainsworth
* 224
 David LepperMr Austin MitchellMr Jamie Reed
 Mr Rob WilsonPhilip Davies
   That this House notes the recent efforts to commercialise Terminator Technology, a genetic use restriction technology, which is designed to prevent through genetic modification farm-saved seeds from germinating; further notes the recent granting of a Terminator patent in Europe; is concerned that this technology will force farmers to purchase new seed each season, thus increasing corporate control of the food supply and threatening the food security of people in developing countries; is not convinced that this technology will prevent GM contamination of non-GM crops, food and feed supplies; is further concerned that this technology may present a threat, especially to farmers' and indigenous peoples' livelihoods, health and biodiversity; and urges the UK Government to follow the precautionary principle and therefore continue to defend, in upcoming meetings of the United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity and elsewhere in 2006, the existing decision that products incorporating Genetic Use Restriction Technologies should not be approved for field testing and commercialisation.


1325SCOPE'S SPEAK FOR YOURSELF CAMPAIGN9:1:06
Roger Berry
Bob Russell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Mike Hancock
* 122
 Mr Doug Henderson
   That this House notes the significant difficulty many people with communication impairments face in getting the augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) equipment and on-going support they need to communicate; further notes that without the means to communicate people cannot express themselves freely, discuss ideas or make choices, which severely limits their life chances; further notes that current statutory provision is a lottery based on age, postcode and impairment type; regrets that there is no statutory right to AAC equipment; further regrets that local equipment budgets often will not meet the high costs of complex assessment, AAC equipment and on-going training and support that AAC users need; further regrets that the Communication Aids Project, which has provided much needed additional funding for communication equipment for more than 4,000 children since 2002, is set to end in March 2006; and calls on the Government to establish a statutory right to AAC and national standards for provision of AAC services to ring-fence adequate funding so that every person with a communication impairment in the UK can speak for themselves.


1338LAW RELATING TO UNMARRIED COUPLES10:1:06
Mary Creagh
John Bercow
Steve Webb
Mr Andrew Dismore [R]
Joan Ruddock
Ms Sally Keeble
* 118
 Mr Jamie Reed
   That this House believes that the law relating to unmarried couples is shambolic and in urgent need of reform because there is little or no legal protection for cohabitants on relationship breakdown; and, while welcoming the introduction of civil partnerships for same sex couples, calls on the Government to introduce a new law to provide a safety net for couples of whatever sexual orientation who live together as its next priority.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1342FLOODING10:1:06
Norman Baker
Michael Jabez Foster
Mr David Curry
Mr Paul Keetch
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods
Greg Clark
* 63
 Mr Brian Binley
   That this House notes with concern the increased incidence of flooding in the UK, a situation which the onset of climate change can only exacerbate; acknowledges the increased investment in flood defence monies which the Government has provided; notes however that a national assessment of needs for flood defences, commissioned by the Government last year, predicts that the current level of funding will fall short of what is needed by £700 million over the next 10 years; agrees with the Association of British Insurers that `investment must continue to rise in real terms over a sustained period'; and calls on the Treasury to respond accordingly.

As an Amendment to Norman Baker's proposed Motion (Flooding):

Bob Spink
Lembit Öpik
Mr Brooks Newmark
Julia Goldsworthy
Sir Michael Spicer
Daniel Kawczynski
* 7
Line 4, after `that', insert `the Government's policy of scrapping local flood committees has been unhelpful and that'.
11:1:06(a1)


1373PROPOSED CLOSURE OF CENTRE FOR ECOLOGY AND HYDROLOGY RESEARCH LABORATORIES16:1:06
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Norman Baker
Mr Alan Duncan
Mr Dan Rogerson
Gregory Barker
David Howarth
* 101
 Mr John Grogan
   That this House notes with concern the proposal to close the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology scientific laboratories at Monk's Wood, Banchory and Winfrith; believes that their closure would severely impair the long-term monitoring and study of ecological change; further believes it would reduce the quality of independent science-based advice to Government on environmental matters, including climate change; and would dissipate the expertise of up to 200 experienced scientists; further believes that the savings expected from the closures will be more than offset by associated restructuring costs; supports the campaign by leading environmental charities to prevent the closure; applauds the work of the centres over many years; and calls on the National Environment Research Council and the Government to ensure their survival.


1387SUPPLY OF STOMA CARE PRODUCTS17:1:06
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
Ann Winterton
Mike Penning
* 62
 John Thurso
   That this House notes the excellent and expert care and advice given by specialist nurses on the use of stoma care products to ostomates; is concerned that the Secretary of State for Health has issued a consultation document on the purchase and supply of stoma care products and the care of people with stomas; and calls on the Secretary of State to continue the current efficient, effective and convenient stoma care and product supply arrangements and to continue to support stoma nurses.


1397EDUCATION COALITION 2010 (No. 2)17:1:06
Dr Ian Gibson
Paul Farrelly
Tim Farron
Mr John Grogan
Nick Harvey
Mr George Mudie
* 89
 Lembit ÖpikNorman Lamb
   That this House welcomes the launch of the Coalition 2010 campaign fronted by the National Union of Students, National Association of Teachers in Further and Higher Education, AUT, National Union of Teachers, Association of Teachers and Lecturers and the National Association of Schoolmasters/Union of Women Teachers; supports the Coalition's aim to fight against the removal of the £3,000 cap during the lead up to the Government's review of education funding beginning in 2008; questions whether the Government's pledge to widen participation in education can be reconciled with the prospect of ever-growing fees for students; believes that the removal of this cap will serve to deter students from poorer and less traditional backgrounds from going to university; and urges the Government not to increase the £3,000 cap following the review period.


1408WAR PENSION JUSTICE FOR GILLIAN CAMPAIGN18:1:06
Mr Richard Benyon
Hon Nicholas Soames
Danny Alexander
Susan Kramer
Martin Salter
Mr Ronnie Campbell
* 173
 Dr Evan HarrisMr Mark Harper
   That this House is deeply concerned by the revelation that the late William Norbury was denied his due war disability pension by the Government following the failure of the Kenyan Government to pay it after independence in 1962; recalls with admiration the award of the Military Cross in the field, given to Lt Norbury for the charging of Japanese lines in the course of which he was severely wounded; regrets that he suffered from his resultant disabilities until the end of his life; and accordingly calls on the Government belatedly to re-instate this pension for the benefit of his widow, Gillian, together with an appropriate sum of arrears, so that she no longer has to live in straitened circumstances which bring shame on this country.


1412GROWING THE RAILWAYS CAMPAIGN18:1:06
Dr Alan Whitehead
Tom Brake
Mr John Horam
Bob Spink
Mike Penning
Bob Russell
* 97
 Patrick HallDr Phyllis StarkeyMr Robert Walter
 Mr Bill OlnerDr Richard TaylorSarah McCarthy-Fry
 Mr Nick Clegg
   That this House welcomes the increasing demand for rail travel but is concerned that no plans currently exist to increase capacity on the railways, and alleviate congestion on parts of the rail network which are already congested; and, therefore, supports Transport 2000's Growing the Railways campaign, as endorsed by 21 organisations, which calls on the Government to draw up a clear investment planning framework for rail, through the High Level Output Statement, which ensures that money spent is used more efficiently, promotes partnership working, appraising rail projects fairly, and, above all, plans for an expanding railway for passengers and freight.


1416TONY BANKS AND THE CANADIAN SEAL HUNT18:1:06
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr Eric Martlew
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr David Amess
Ms Diane Abbott
Dr Nick Palmer
* 127
 Mr Roger Williams
   That this House notes with great sadness the sudden death of Tony Banks (Lord Stratford); recognises his tremendous work in the field of animal welfare and pays tribute to his efforts and dedication; further notes his commitment to end the cruel slaughter of hundreds of thousands of seal pups for their fur each spring in Canada and his wish that the UK end its trade in seal products in line with public opinion; and calls on the Government to prohibit the trade in all harp and hooded seal products in the UK as soon as possible.


1417BEVIN BOYS18:1:06
Gordon Banks
Mr David Anderson
Mr Jim Devine
Mrs Siān C. James
Mr David Hamilton
Rosie Cooper
* 171
 Colin BurgonMark Durkan
   That this House acknowledges the role played by the Bevin Boys, who served this nation during the period 1943 to 1948; notes that many paid the ultimate price in their endeavour to rid Europe of Nazi tyrants; and calls upon the Government officially to recognise by the way of an award similar to that available to military veterans the importance of the Bevin Boys to victory in the Second World War.


1424BRAIN TUMOURS19:1:06
John Bercow
Mrs Betty Williams
Dr Evan Harris
Peter Law
Mr Anthony Wright
Mr James Arbuthnot
* 82
 Jeremy Wright
   That this House notes that 16,000 people each year, including 450 children, are diagnosed with brain tumours; is disturbed that brain tumours have become the biggest single disease killing children; acknowledges that survival rates have not increased in line with the rate for childhood leukaemia and some other adult cancers; applauds the work of scientists and clinicians; supports the efforts of United Kingdom brain tumour charities which support research and raise awareness of issues surrounding brain tumour care; further notes that NHS expenditure on brain tumour patients is well below that devoted to other cancers; recognises the problems faced by brain tumour patients in accessing treatment; seeks improved NHS funding and care, including approved access to radiotherapy and rehabilitation services and treatments, such as carmustine implants and temozolomide, which are better tolerated, offer the best hope of improved survival and/or rehabilitation; and calls upon the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence to act quickly to approve clinically and cost effective new treatments so that they are available to all NHS patients.


1443GLOBAL AIDS TARGETS23:1:06
Mr Jeremy Hunt
Mr Neil Gerrard
Malcolm Bruce
Mr Andrew Mitchell
Hugh Bayley
Nick Herbert
* 243
 Dr Phyllis StarkeyMr John WhittingdaleMr Andrew Love
 Dr Doug NaysmithCharlotte AtkinsMr David Hamilton
 Kerry McCarthyMr Shahid MalikMs Celia Barlow
   That this House strongly welcomes the target to provide universal access to anti-retroviral drugs for HIV/AIDS sufferers by 2010 as an invaluable contribution to economic growth and poverty reduction in the world's poorest countries; notes that the UK Department for International Development is co-chairing the UN steering group with responsibility for the 2010 target; believes that any strategy to promote the availability of HIV/AIDS treatment drugs must go together with an increased emphasis on preventing the spread of the disease; and strongly urges the Government to secure the agreement of the international community for interim targets to be put in place and published which commit the UK and other G8 nations to concrete and measurable milestones between now and 2010 to ensure that the universal access target is met.


1452SAVE THE CHILDREN'S REPORT ON BRITAIN'S POOREST CHILDREN REVISITED23:1:06
John Battle
Mr David Laws
Bob Spink
David Taylor
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
* 179
 Simon HughesMs Celia BarlowEmily Thornberry
 Mr Brian Binley
   That this House welcomes Save the Children's recent report, Britain's Poorest Children Revisited; notes with extreme concern the findings that one million children in Great Britain live in severe and persistent poverty; further notes that additional action is needed if the Government is to meet its targets and if disadvantaged young people are to be given opportunities to fulfil their full potential; and urges the Government to measure the number of children living in severe and persistent poverty and commit to a strategy that explicitly targets these children, who may number up to one million.


1464NEW COMMITTEE ON RADIATION EFFECTS24:1:06
Mr Michael Meacher
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Mike Weir
Jeremy Corbyn
Mr John Leech
* 30
 Mrs Betty Williams
   That this House notes that the National Public Health Service Wales and the Committee on Medical Aspects of Radiation in the Environment (COMARE) have accepted a report from the Welsh Cancer Intelligence and Surveillance Unit (WCISU) denying the reality of a serious excess of childhood cancer and leukaemia around the Menai Strait in North Wales; further notes that a countervailing report has been published on the web site of the Low Level Radiation Campaign and by the journal European Biology and Bioelectromagnetics; further notes that WCISU stands accused of recklessly using false data for populations in the study area with the effect of minimising the risks apparent in the cancer cases observed despite having been warned of an exactly similar error in 2001; is concerned that COMARE's endorsement of WCISU calls its epidemiological expertise into question; and calls on the Government to replace COMARE with a Committee on the Health Effects of Ionising Radiation with a neutral chair, a full-time civil service secretariat, a budget sufficient to permit independent research, and a membership paid for their work on the Committee and which represents all shades of relevant scientific opinion.


1468BIKE AND RAIL INTEGRATION24:1:06
Emily Thornberry
Peter Bottomley
Andrew Stunell
Nia Griffith
Gwyn Prosser
Stephen Hammond
* 133
 Patrick HallDr Phyllis StarkeyDr Howard Stoate
 Mr Edward DaveyMr Robert WalterJoan Walley
 Sarah McCarthy-Fry
   That this House notes that individual railway companies have different policies towards cycling and that provision for cyclists at railway stations and on trains is patchy at best but generally remains completely inadequate; further notes that the winding up of the Strategic Rail Authority and the transfer of authority to the Department for Transport provides an excellent opportunity for ministers to issue minimum standards to railway franchises and Network Rail to improve provision for bicycles on trains and at railway stations; and believes that bicycle and rail transport should be integrated and promoted to provide a seamless and environmentally sound `doorstep to destination' alternative to car travel.


1487GOOGLE AND CENSORSHIP WITHIN CHINA26:1:06
Norman Baker
Peter Bottomley
Graham Stringer
Lynne Jones
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Mike Hancock
* 45
 Mr Don Foster
   That this House deplores Google's decision to launch a censored version of its search engine in China; believes this can only encourage China to continue its draconian policy on freedom of expression and democracy; and calls on the Government to make clear to the Chinese authorities its strong concern and doubt about China's commitment to bring democracy and freedom of expression to its people in the light of its continued policy to only allow companies that have signed a censorship agreement to run internet-based businesses within the People's Republic of China.


1488ENFORCEMENT OF THE GENETICALLY MODIFIED ORGANISM TRACEABILITY AND LABELLING REGULATIONS26:1:06
Norman Baker
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Joan Ruddock
Mr Dan Rogerson
Mr James Paice
Mr David Drew
* 70
 Mr Michael ClaphamEmily Thornberry
   That this House notes the all-party support for the genetically modified content of food and animal feed to be clearly labelled to ensure that consumers and farmers have the right to choose products free of GM ingredients and to enable potential health and environmental impacts of GM crops to be monitored post-marketing; expresses concern about the illegal import over four years of GM Bt10 maize into the EU from the United States which went undetected; further notes the conclusions of a survey carried out by GM Freeze in 2005 that the current level of enforcement of the GMO Traceability and Labelling Regulations across the United Kingdom cannot be said to guarantee the accuracy of GM labelling on food or feed or that no unapproved GM varieties have been imported into the United Kingdom and entered the food chain; and therefore calls upon the Government and the Food Standards Agency to recognise the importance of enforcement at local level, ensure that port health authorities monitor every incoming cargo which may contain GM and take a positive lead in enforcement by providing clear guidance and advice.


1494ASSISTED DYING IN THE UK AND OVERSEAS26:1:06
Joan Ruddock
Dr Evan Harris
Dr Ian Gibson
Anne Milton
Sandra Gidley
Dr Tony Wright
* 65
 Glenda JacksonJulie Morgan
   That this House is saddened by the death of the terminally ill doctor Anne Turner who chose to travel to Switzerland to receive assistance to die; hopes that her son and daughters who accompanied her are treated with compassion and sensitivity by the authorities on their return to the UK; is concerned that this is the 42nd case of its kind in the past three years and yet the Director of Public Prosecutions still refuses to publish guidance as to whether family members who accompany their relatives overseas for an assisted death are breaking the law; notes that recent research by Clive Seale from Brunel University has uncovered that, on average, there are eight illegal assisted deaths performed by doctors in the UK every day; and believes this sensitive issue should be further discussed in this House.

As an Amendment to Joan Ruddock's proposed Motion (Assisted Dying in the UK and Overseas):

Dr Brian Iddon
Mr David Crausby
Ann Winterton
Paul Rowen
Mr Angus MacNeil
Jim Dobbin
* 9
Mr Lindsay HoyleGeraldine SmithMr Joe Benton
Line 1, leave out from `of' to end and insert `Dr Ann Turner and regrets the manner in which her assisted suicide in Switzerland was politicised by the euthanasia lobby to promote the legalisation of euthanasia; notes that what was described in The Times as as a `grisly travelling theatre of death' for which a television team and other journalists were present throughout has been used relentlessly by the Voluntary Euthanasia Society to promote Lord Joffe's Bill to legalise assisted suicide; notes however that Dr Turner was not terminally ill and would not have qualified under the proposed legislation which requires a prognosis of death within six months whereas Dr Turner had six to eight years to live; further notes that she was diagnosed as having progressive supranuclear palsy (PSP) in 2004 for which the average survival is 10 years; further notes that the clinical course of PSP is not unlike Parkinson's disease and, although not curable, treatment is available that considerably improves the quality of life; hopes the authorities treated Dr Turner's son and daughters who accompanied her with compassion; nonetheless reminds the Government that every Disability Rights group in the UK is opposed to the Joffe Bill and any form of euthanasia because they consider it would totally undermine the basic rights of disabled people; and calls on the Government to invest extensively in research into PSP and similar diseases, to finance major extensions to the hospice movement and to oppose euthanasia.'.
29:3:06(a1)


1499ELDER ABUSE26:1:06
Mr Paul Burstow
Ann Keen
Mr Andrew Pelling
Hywel Williams
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Nigel Dodds
* 165
 Mr Malcolm MossNia GriffithEd Balls
 Mr Nick Clegg
   That this House condemns the abuse of older people as a national shame; supports the Help the Aged campaign, which is being taken forward in partnership with Action on Elder Abuse, to raise awareness of abuse and increase recognition that all should take responsibility for putting a stop to the abuse of older people; believes that older people have the right to live free from fear and harm; urges immediate action to prevent and tackle elder abuse; and calls for improved mechanisms to address elder abuse through more effective regulatory systems and law enforcement, vetting and barring of health and social care workers and increased access to advocacy and support for people affected by elder abuse.


1503GAMING MACHINE STAKE AND PRIZE LEVELS26:1:06
Mr John Grogan
Mr Don Foster
Mr Malcolm Moss
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Nigel Evans
Peter Bottomley
* 138
 Mrs Siān C. James
   That this House notes with concern that the Government has not implemented the Gaming Board of Great Britain's recommendation to raise the prize level for Category C machines to £35 nor to implement its own proposal to raise the stake to 50 pence; recognises the lack of a suitable stake and prize has been damaging to many leisure sectors which have seen a severe decline in income in recent years; further notes that the effect is felt particuarly in rural and community pubs and local bingo halls where the income stream generated by low stake and prize gaming is of vital importance to those businesses; and notes that the leisure industry as represented by the BBPA, BACTA, BALPPA, BISL and the Bingo Association are urging the Government to introduce the stake and prize increase as a matter of urgency under the current arrangements which provide sufficient safeguards in an existing and established market.


1504CAP ON RENEWABLES OBLIGATION CERTIFICATES FOR COFIRING WITH BIOMASS26:1:06
Mr John Grogan
Richard Ottaway
Mike Penning
Glenda Jackson
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
* 79
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That this House welcomes the Government's commitment to secure, sustainable and affordable energy and a balanced mix of electricity generation; notes that cofiring biomass with coal is significantly lowering carbon dioxide emissions and appreciates the potential for further reductions; observes with regret the Government's decision to reduce the cap on renewables obligation certificates (ROCs) for cofiring with biomass from 25 per cent. to 10 per cent. effective from 1st April, representing a 60 per cent. cut in the use of biomass; is concerned that this may lead to an over-supply of cofired ROCs, causing a collapse in their price and a consequent loss of confidence in the short-term energy crop market for farmers and the suppliers of biomass; and therefore calls on the Government to revise the Renewables Obligation (Amendment) Order 2004, or alter the ROC pricing system to prevent a collapse in the market.


1507JAPANESE WHALING IN THE SOUTHERN OCEAN SANCTUARY30:1:06
Daniel Kawczynski
Mr Adrian Sanders
Andrew Stunell
Mike Penning
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
* 144
 Adam Price
   That this House condemns the government of Japan for its scientific whaling within the Southern Ocean Sanctuary; deplores the cruelty of Japanese whaling operations as shown in recent film footage of harpooned minke whales suffering long and painful deaths; regrets deeply that more than 6,800 minke whales have been killed in the name of science in Antarctic waters since the moratorium on commercial whaling was introduced in 1986; fears that Japan is close to commanding a majority bloc in the International Whaling Commission; welcomes the 17-nation demarche in January, which included the UK, calling on the government of Japan to cease immediately its lethal scientific research and curtail its plans to catch 935 minke whales and 10 endangered fin whales; notes the huge public interest in, and sympathy for, the northern bottlenose whale recently found in the Thames; and strongly urges the UK Government to recognise the public interest in whales and put further pressure on the government of Japan at the highest diplomatic levels to cease its whaling programme.


1514AGRICULTURE (S.I., 2005, No. 3459)30:1:06
Mr David Cameron
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Gregory Barker
Mr James Paice [R]
Bill Wiggin
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 33
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Common Agricultural Policy Single Payment and Support Schemes (Cross-compliance) (England) Regulations 2005 (S.I., 2005, No. 3459), dated 14th December 2005, a copy of which was laid before this House on 19th December, be annulled.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1515AGRICULTURE (S.I., 2005, No. 3460)30:1:06
Mr David Cameron
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Gregory Barker
Mr James Paice [R]
Bill Wiggin
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 31
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Common Agricultural Policy Single Payment Scheme (Set-aside) (England) (Amendment) Regulations 2005 (S.I., 2005, No. 3460), dated 14th December 2005, a copy of which was laid before this House on 19th December, be annulled.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1516AGRICULTURE (S.I., 2005, No. 3433)30:1:06
Mr David Cameron
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Gregory Barker
Mr James Paice [R]
Bill Wiggin
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 31
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Cattle Compensation (England) Order 2005 (S.I., 2005, No. 3433), dated 8th December 2005, a copy of which was laid before this House on 13th December, be annulled.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1517TOXIC PROPERTIES OF ASPARTAME30:1:06
Mr Roger Williams
Bob Spink
David Taylor
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 46
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That this House expresses deep concern over the numerous independent toxicological studies and thousands of subjective reports attesting to the toxic effects of the artificial sweetener aspartame on human health; notes that aspartame, once patented as a biochemical warfare agent, is the synthetically produced methyl ester of a dipeptide which is readily broken down in the gut to release methanol; further notes that in naturally occurring foodstuff methanol is either not released into the body or present together with natural defence mechanisms that mitigate its toxic effects; recognises that methanol is a well known poison and is further converted into formaldehyde, a class A carcinogen according to the World Health Organisation's International Agency for Research on Cancer; accepts that severe health concerns occur from the gradual accumulation of formaldehyde in the body which cannot be excreted and that further research has shown that long term low level exposure to formaldehyde induces leukaemia and nasopharyngeal cancer in humans; acknowledges that of the 166 studies conducted on aspartame's safety deemed relevant to humans, 92 per cent. of independently sponsored studies identified one or more problems with aspartame's safety whereas industry-sponsored studies found unanimously in favour of aspartame's safety; and urges the Government to abide by the precautionary principle and make use of Statutes 13 and 16 of the 1990 Food Safety Act to remove aspartame from the permitted list of additives on the UK market.


1531ABOLITION OF THE POST OFFICE CARD ACCOUNT31:1:06
Kate Hoey
Mr Owen Paterson
Mr Alan Reid
Mrs Gwyneth Dunwoody
The Reverend Ian Paisley
Mr Iain Duncan Smith
* 296
 Hugh BayleyMr David ChaytorJanet Anderson
 Mr Iain WrightMr Jamie Reed
   That this House is gravely concerned by the Department of Work and Pensions' (DWP) decision to withdraw support for the Post Office Card Account when the existing contract expires in 2010 and in particular by the Department's attempt to kill off the Account in advance of 2010, through pilot schemes being introduced immediately when it will deny to new benefit claimants the option of opening a Post Office Card Account, inform 35,000 existing customers that they will have to use a bank or building society instead of the Post Office Card Account and require them to provide their account details, and pay benefits of 2,500 existing customers into a bank account rather than the Post Office Card Account, ignoring the preferences they made when their benefit books were stopped; condemns the fact that, in breach of all plans, these pilot schemes are being introduced without consultation; and calls on the Government to halt these pilot schemes immediately and to institute an immediate review of the DWP's proposal to abolish the Post Office Card Account by 2010.


1540UNIVERSITY SALARIES31:1:06
Mr Gordon Marsden
Helen Jones
Chris McCafferty
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr David S. Borrow
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 165
 Patrick HallSteve WebbDr William McCrea
 Mark WilliamsEmily Thornberry
   That this House believes universities, and the staff who work within them, are a valuable part of society and the economy; applauds how well university staff have performed in addressing the many challenges in the sector over the last two decades, not least the expansion in student numbers; notes with concern that student-staff ratios have increased by nearly 150 per cent., so that whereas one lecturer taught nine students in 1976, they now on average teach 21; remains concerned that university salaries are still uncompetitively low despite this improved productivity and the recent increases in funding for higher education; supports the Association of University Teachers and NATFHE, the university and college lecturers' union, in their campaign for at least a third of additional future income from top-up fees and other sources to be invested in university staff salaries; and urges university vice chancellors to make their staff a priority and to seek a settlement to the current pay dispute which is in the interests of staff, students and the country as a whole.


1542LEGAL SERVICE COMMISSION'S DECISION TO END FUNDING FOR SPECIALIST SUPPORT IN ENGLAND AND WALES31:1:06
Julie Morgan
Vera Baird
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr Roger Williams
Mr David Jones
Barbara Keeley
* 168
 Miss Julie KirkbrideMr Jamie Reed
   That this House condemns the Legal Service Commission's (LSC) recent decision to end all funding of specialist support services in England and Wales from July 2006 despite the outcome of its own review in 2003-04 which recognised the value and importance of specialist support advice, mentoring and training in complex areas of social welfare law for LSC approved agencies working directly with the public; notes that this will mean, in Wales, the end of the Wales Specialist Support Service, which provides expert help and training in housing, welfare benefits and debt, and across England and Wales, the loss of essential advice and training in mental health, community care, employment, HIV/AIDS, immigration and human rights, as well as housing, welfare benefits and debt, provided by acknowledged expert agencies such as the Child Poverty Action Group, Disability Law Service, Citizens Advice, Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants, Liberty, MIND, Shelter, Terrence Higgins Trust and others; further regrets the implications of this cut in funding for vulnerable clients who are not in a position to employ specialist advisers; and calls on the Government to restore funding for specialist support and to strengthen the provision of legal advice for those in the greatest need.


1550LINDA CARTY1:2:06
Vera Baird
Jenny Willott
Mr John Gummer
Mark Durkan
Peter Bottomley
Jeremy Corbyn
* 104
 Peter LuffMr Nick Clegg
   That this House is extremely concerned at the plight of British National, Linda Carty, who has spent more than three years on Death Row in Texas, convicted of a murder she has always denied, solely on the evidence of other suspects who avoided the death penalty themselves by testifying against her; is further concerned that the US authorities failed to notify the British Consul of her arrest, so that Linda Carty, who was suffering the aftermath of both rape and domestic violence at the time, had no support to obtain a good lawyer, being allocated a weak one with a poor record, who failed properly to represent or even consult her; and calls on the Government to take all possible steps to safeguard her legitimate interests.


1553BETTER DEAL FOR CANCER PATIENTS CAMPAIGN (No. 2)1:2:06
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Dr Ian Gibson
Dr Howard Stoate
Peter Bottomley
Jo Swinson
Dr Roberta Blackman-Woods
* 145
 Mr Paul Truswell
   That this House recognises that one in three people will be diagnosed with cancer during their lifetime; notes that 39 per cent. of working age cancer patients have experienced significant financial difficulties as a result of cancer; further recognises that disability due to cancer is often sudden and unpredictable and that many cancer patients make up to 60 trips to hospital in total for life-saving treatment and often travel long distances for radiotherapy; is concerned by the National Audit Office finding that 77 per cent. of cancer patients are not given information about financial benefits and the Public Accounts Committee finding that there is a scandalous lack of benefits take-up for some cancer patients; therefore applauds Macmillan Cancer Relief's Better Deal campaign which calls on the Government to inform all cancer patients about their eligibility for financial benefits through effective referral mechanisms such as benefits awareness training for healthcare professionals and access to specialist benefits advice; and calls on the Government to revise the qualifying criteria for disability living allowance and attendance allowance which unfairly discriminate against cancer patients, to review fast-tracking procedures for terminally-ill patients and to exempt cancer patients travelling for treatment from road tolls and charges and from hospital car parking charges.


1562ITV NEWS WHO CARES? CAMPAIGN2:2:06
Dr Hywel Francis [R]
Barbara Keeley
Tony Baldry
Mr Paul Burstow
Lady Hermon
Hywel Williams
* 159
 John BercowMr Barry Sheerman
   That this House recognises the needs and the role of the UK's six million people who care for their elderly, sick or disabled relatives, partners or friends which is being highlighted by the ITV News Who Cares? Campaign; realises that despite the work already undertaken to support carers, many still face significant challenges; is concerned that carers still can face poverty as a result of caring, can find it difficult to combine work and care and that they are statistically more likely to suffer ill-health as a result of caring; commends Carers UK for its work in bringing these issues to the fore and for working with others to find solutions; notes that carers' support saves £57 billion a year; and calls for the appointment of a champion within Government to overcome these barriers for carers to ensure that they have choices and opportunities for a better life.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1564DEBATE AND VOTE ON NUCLEAR POWER6:2:06
Jenny Willott
Lembit Öpik
Mark Williams
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Nia Griffith
Mr Martin Caton
* 50
 Norman Baker
   That this House notes the consultation under way over future energy policy; further notes the considerable amount of public concern over the possibility of building a new generation of nuclear power stations across the UK; further notes the huge importance of such a decision in terms of prudence over public finances, security of energy supply, climate change, public health, environmental protection and national security; further notes that such a decision will have a long-lasting impact and represents a major crossroads in UK energy policy; believes that such an extraordinary decision must be legitimised by a strong element of democratic accountability; and calls on the Government to give Parliament a full debate and vote on whether or not to build a set of new nuclear power stations before any final decision from the Government is made.


1570ELECTRIC SHOCK COLLARS6:2:06
Tony Baldry
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
David Taylor
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Edward Vaizey
* 57
 Dr Desmond TurnerDr Brian IddonPaul Farrelly
   That this House condemns the sale and use of remote control electric shock collars to train and control dogs; considers the use of such devices to be cruel and unnecessary; understands that alternative positive training methods produce dogs which are trained more quickly and reliably with no potential for abuse or cruelty; recognises that because dogs are highly reactive to learning experiences and have a strong bond with humans that their natural instincts can be utilised to train them easily; and calls upon the Government to introduce a complete ban on the sale and use of electric shock collars as part of the Animal Welfare Bill.


1574VIRGIN CROSS COUNTRY6:2:06
Jeremy Corbyn
John McDonnell
Mr Alan Meale
Graham Stringer
Mrs Ann Cryer
Rob Marris
* 28
 Mr Neil Gerrard
   That this House is deeply concerned at the ongoing dispute between Virgin Cross Country and the Rail Maritime and Transport Union (RMT); is further concerned at reports that Virgin may be compromising the safety of passengers by the use of untrained and medically restricted personnel on strike days; regrets that Virgin has refused to return to the negotiating table; and therefore calls on Richard Branson to urge his company immediately to re-open negotiations with the RMT.


1575BETTER MENTAL HEALTH ACT CAMPAIGN6:2:06
Lynne Jones
Angela Browning
Sandra Gidley
Gwyn Prosser
Mrs Madeleine Moon
Peter Bottomley
* 132
 Michael Jabez FosterMr David AmessSimon Hughes
 Peter LuffMrs Maria MillerMr Andrew Pelling
   That this House regrets the Government's decision to reject many of the pre-legislative scrutiny committee's recommendations on the 2004 draft Mental Health Bill; believes that unless the measures proposed in the draft Bill are significantly altered as proposed by the committee, the resultant new Mental Health Act will seriously restrict the rights, choices and wellbeing of people with mental distress and force too many people into compulsory treatment; calls for a new Bill that ensures that powers to treat people compulsorily are only used when there is a definite therapeutic benefit and that compulsion is only used when a person's ability to make a decision about accepting treatment is significantly impaired as a result of mental disorder; supports the committee's view that compulsory treatment in the community is appropriate in only a relatively small number of cases whose clinical characteristics should be clearly defined; further believes that people must have access to voluntary care and treatment when they need it in order to achieve the Government's declared aim of minimising the risk of people with a mental health problem deteriorating to the point where the need for consideration of compulsory treatment arises; calls on the Government to provide evidence for its assertion, in its response to the committee, that the general public does not share the committee's belief that the Bill is inappropriately concerned with public safety; and supports the Mental Health Alliance's campaign for a better Mental Health Act.


1577WAR CRIMINALS7:2:06
Jeremy Corbyn
Alan Simpson
Dr Phyllis Starkey
Richard Burden
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Peter Bottomley
* 107
 Mr Andrew LoveSimon HughesMr Jim McGovern
 Mike PenningSir Peter Soulsby
   That this House expresses concern that the Government may be considering diluting laws relating to the arrest of alleged war criminals and torturers entering or residing in the UK; notes that no good reason has been given to alter the status quo and that the current system wherein a judge makes a decision whether to grant an arrest warrant has worked satisfactorily to date; further notes that such arrest warrants have been issued very infrequently and that this would indicate that the granting of them is taken very seriously indeed by the judiciary which is a safeguard against frivolous applications; calls upon the Government to uphold the UK's duty and right to arrest and prosecute alleged war crimes suspects if they arrive on or reside in its territory and to fund the police and immigration authorities adequately to enable such arrests to be made so that this country cannot be regarded as a safe haven for such persons.


1581UNETHICAL PRACTICES BY PHARMACEUTICAL COMPANIES7:2:06
Paul Flynn
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
David Taylor
Graham Stringer
Jeremy Corbyn
* 30
 Frank Cook
   That this House deplores the violation of privacy arising from the release of confidential general practitioner NHS patient records to a representative of Merck pharmaceutical company and the routine access to hospital confidential records to nurse advisers employed by pharmaceutical companies; is alarmed that a nurse adviser employed by Glaxo Smith Kline used her access to patient records to push the company's drug Seretide and that the Wyeth company offered general practitioners financial inducements to prescribe its drugs; believes the activities of nurse advisers, trained and employed by drug companies, distort clinical priorities and lead to the unethical over-prescription and mis-prescription of medicines; and calls for an inquiry into the practice of allowing employees of drugs companies access to NHS patients and influence over prescribing decisions.


1582HON. MEMBER FOR BEACONSFIELD7:2:06
Mr David Cameron
Mr Michael Howard
Mr William Hague
David Davis
Sir Michael Spicer
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 146
 Mr Andrew Pelling
   That this House congratulates the hon. Member for Beaconsfield on recently being named Channel 4 Opposition Politician of the Year, in addition to receiving the House Magazine's Award for the Opposition Politician of the Year and the Spectator's Award for Parliamentarian of the Year; recognises the contribution made by the hon. Member for Beaconsfield to the high standard of debate in this House; and, while acknowledging the calibre of all those short-listed for these awards, further recognises that it is a remarkable achievement to have won all of these prestigious awards in one year.


1599GM CONTAMINATION OF ORGANIC PRODUCTS7:2:06
Alan Simpson
Chris McCafferty
David Taylor
Mr Alan Meale
Jeremy Corbyn
Glenda Jackson
* 157
 Mr Brian JenkinsSteve McCabeJohn Battle
 Mr Michael MeacherAnn McKechinMr Mark Francois
 Mr Richard BaconMr Andrew PellingMr Angus MacNeil
 Mr Brian BinleyTim Farron
   That this House notes the proposal by the European Commission to revise the EU Organic Regulation and impose on organic products a threshold of 0.9 per cent. for contamination by genetically modified (GM) organisms; further notes the expansion of organic farming in the last decade and its positive contribution to the farming economy and the environment; further notes the wishes of the majority of European consumers to avoid any GM content in food; recognises that most organic certification bodies operate to the practical detection limit of 0.1 per cent.; is concerned that the imposition of a GM threshold for organic food above the detectable level will damage the reputation of organic produce and lead to increasing GM contamination over time; and calls upon the Secretary of State to support non-GM food production and farmer and consumer choice by opposing the use of a 0.9 per cent. threshold as a reference in co-existence measures or in the EU Organic Regulation, ensuring that strict liability rules put the cost of GM contamination on the polluters and not on taxpayers or the non-GM sector, recognising the importance of independent organic certification and the need to protect this system by ensuring that organic means no GMOs, and ensuring that the threshold for all non-GM seed is set at the practical limit of detection.


1604ABUSES OF HONOURS8:2:06
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Paul Flynn
Mr Martin Caton
Lynne Jones
Jeremy Corbyn
* 21
 Mr Mike Weir
   That this House notes that since the Honours (Prevention of Abuses) Act 1925 was put on the Statute Book there has been only one prosecution, in 1933; and believes with the passage of such a long time without prosecutions, organisations such as the Specialist Schools and Academies Trust should be reminded of its existence.


1606GUIDANCE ON PRE-MOVEMENT TESTING8:2:06
Mr James Paice
Bill Wiggin
Mr David Curry
Mr Peter Atkinson
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Gregory Barker
* 71
 Mark Pritchard
   That this House recognises the importance of livestock markets to rural communities; further recognises the role of such markets in enabling a farmer to obtain a fair price for his or her stock at auction; notes the coming into force later this month of the Tuberculosis (England) Order 2005; further notes the introduction by the order of a requirement for pre-movement testing of cattle for bovine TB; welcomes measures to combat the urgent problem of TB in cattle; further recognises that livestock markets are ideally placed to monitor compliance by farmers with the provisions of the order; further notes the Government's failure to provide any guidance to livestock markets on the practical operation of the order or the conditions for being granted the status necessary to continue offering an open market for both finished and unfinished cattle; calls on the Government to provide such guidance as a matter of urgency; and urges the Government to work with the Livestock Auctioneers' Association to ensure that the order is implemented in a manner which is administratively workable and which enables all farmers to continue to achieve a fair price for their cattle within the context of an open auction.


1608BRITISH MEDICAL ASSOCIATION REPORT ON THE STAFF AND ASSOCIATE SPECIALISTS GROUP OF DOCTORS9:2:06
Dr Howard Stoate
Mr Andrew Lansley
Steve Webb
Michael Connarty
Lady Hermon
Hywel Williams
* 114
 Joan RuddockMr David Jones
   That this House welcomes the publication of the British Medical Association's recent report, The Hidden Heroes of the NHS; notes the significant contribution that the Staff and Associate Specialists group of doctors play in providing patient care in the NHS; further notes that their contribution in delivering patient care has been largely unacknowledged; believes that recognition of and investment in this group of 12,500 or so senior doctors is much needed as they are an untapped resource and essential to the modernisation of the NHS; and calls on the Government to invest in this group of doctors to enable them to help deliver improvements across the NHS.


1614TRIDENT AND THE NON-PROLIFERATION TREATY9:2:06
Mr Neil Gerrard
Richard Younger-Ross
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr David Drew
Jim Cousins
Mr Michael Clapham
* 34
 Dr Gavin StrangSir Peter Soulsby
   That this House notes that the Government when elected in 1997 committed itself to working for multilateral nuclear disarmament; further notes that the Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) commits nuclear weapon states to negotiate the elimination of their nuclear arsenals and that the advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice on the use or threatened use of nuclear weapons affirms an obligation `to negotiate in good faith and bring to a conclusion negotiations leading to nuclear disarmament'; further notes that any programme to replace Trident nuclear weapons systems would pre-empt and undermine the effectiveness of such negotiations; and calls upon the Government to support the international rule of law by implementing the obligations of the NPT which would preclude a replacement of Trident.


1616SLAVERY AND TRANS-ATLANTIC SLAVE TRADE9:2:06
Jeremy Corbyn
Ms Diane Abbott
Andrew George
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Hancock
* 41
 Mr Adam Holloway
   That this House welcomes the unanimous decision of the Church of England Synod to acknowledge and apologise for the complicity of the Church in the slave trade; pays tribute to the decade-long campaign led by African countries and representatives of the African diaspora to gain international recognition for the injustices perpetrated in the era of slave trade and to address the lasting legacy of poverty and discrimination; recognises the inspiration derived from Pope John Paul II in his 1991 apology for the `sins of Christian Europe against Africa'; believes that, on the eve of the 2007 bicentenary anniversary of abolition, it is no longer sufficient merely to express regret that slavery occurred; urges the Government to prepare a declaration that recognises slavery and the trans-Atlantic slave trade as a crime against humanity; and calls upon the Home Office Bicentenary Advisory Group to identify a suitable opportunity for an apology to be made on behalf of the nation.


1621PRESERVATION OF ORANG-UTANS AND THEIR HABITATS9:2:06
Andrew Rosindell
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Sammy Wilson
Bob Russell
Mr David Amess
Mr Robert Marshall-Andrews
* 77
 Michael Jabez FosterAngela WatkinsonMark Pritchard
   That this House notes the distressing plight of the orang-utan in Borneo whose numbers are so disturbingly low as to make their extinction a possibility within 12 years; further notes the effects of mass deforestation for logging and palm-oil plantations, illegal hunting, the notorious pet trade and forest fires as grave threats to this primate's existence; acknowledges the outstanding efforts of the World Wildlife Fund in attempting to save this intelligent species from extinction through education of the public and creating sanctuaries for orang-utans; urges supermarkets and other suppliers to act responsibly when considering the purchase of palm-oil-based products from areas that have been deforested; and calls on the Government to do everything possible to support the preservation of the orang-utan's natural habitat and safety so that these magnificent creatures may continue to thrive and survive.


1622OFFENSIVE MATERIALS IN NEWSAGENTS9:2:06
Ms Diane Abbott
Peter Bottomley
Annette Brooke
Jeremy Corbyn
Andrew George
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 99
 Tom BrakeLinda GilroyMr William Cash
 Liz BlackmanMike WoodMr Barry Sheerman
 John BattleAnn WintertonMr Nigel Evans
 Dr Ashok KumarFrank CookMr Andrew Pelling
 Chris HuhneMike PenningJames Brokenshire
 Emily ThornberryNia GriffithAlison Seabeck
 Anne Main
   That this House notes that there is still no legislation in place to ensure that adult titles, including so called lads mags, newspapers and tabloids containing disturbing pornographic material, are kept out of reach and sight of children; acknowledges that most newsagents adhere to the voluntary Code of Practice as set out by the National Federation of Retail Newsagents; welcomes local campaigners all over the UK who are putting pressure on WH Smith to recognise certain tabloid titles as pornography; and calls on the Government once again to consider introducing legislation to ensure offensive material is kept well out of reach and sight of children.

As an Amendment to Ms Diane Abbott's proposed Motion (Offensive Materials in Newsagents):

Mr Gerald Howarth
Mr Julian Brazier
Mark Hunter
Mr David Burrowes
* 4
Line 2, after `tabloids' add `; and magazines such as More which treat sexual matters in an entirely mechanical fashion, virtually devoid of any moral content and are therefore detrimental to the well-being of young people to whom they are marketed by unscrupulous adults'.
8:3:06(a1)


1625ANIMAL WELFARE LABELLING SCHEME13:2:06
Mr James Paice
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Bill Wiggin
Andrew Rosindell
Gregory Barker
Mr Tim Boswell
* 85
 Mark Pritchard
   That this House welcomes the European Commission proposal to create an animal welfare label for meat and fish products which would differentiate between food produced to basic welfare standards and that obtained with higher standards; believes this would improve the protection and welfare of farmed animals, would enable consumers to make more informed choices, and would help British farmers, with their high standards of production to compete against low quality imports which can be passed off as British under current rules; and calls on the Government to give active support to and to promote this scheme for the benefit of consumers, animal welfare and the British agriculture industry.


1626ANIMAL WELFARE (No. 2)13:2:06
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Russell
Mr Alan Meale
Mr John Leech
Harry Cohen
* 105
 Mr David AmessLinda GilroyRichard Burden
 Mr David CrausbyJanet AndersonMr Martyn Jones
 Dr Hywel FrancisHywel WilliamsMr David Hamilton
 Rob MarrisMr David AndersonKerry McCarthy
 Danny AlexanderMark PritchardMs Katy Clark
   That this House commends the work of Animal Defenders International in collecting video evidence of the abnormal behaviour and suffering of animals in travelling circuses, and notes this shows that travelling circuses cannot adequately provide for the basic welfare needs of their animals and as such fail the welfare test of the Animal Welfare Bill; notes that circus animals spend excessive periods of time shut in transporters, whether travelling or not, are forced to live in temporary facilities lacking appropriate space and environmental enrichment, and often in inappropriate groupings of animals; further notes that violence is commonplace and part of the circus culture, and no other working animals spend such a long time, normally at least eight months, in temporary mobile accommodation, thus making animal transport regulations difficult to police and enforce, and that the arrangements for circus animals are entirely different from the higher quality accommodation and transport arrangements of animals being transported for racing, horse shows, dog shows and similar events; and therefore urges that the Animal Welfare Bill is used to end the use of animals in travelling circuses and to take measures to protect performing animals in permanent facilities through regulation and to end the currently legal use of violence to train animals for the purposes of entertainment.

As an Amendment to Mr Mike Hancock's proposed Motion (Animal Welfare (No. 2)):

Peter Luff
Mr Edward Vaizey
* 2
Line 1, leave out from `House' to end and insert `deplores the use of misleading film footage by Animal Defenders International to make false claims about animal cruelty in circuses in the UK, noting that the vast bulk of the footage was filmed abroad, and that the footage showing abuses in the UK was extremely old and does not reflect current practices; acknowledges that only three touring circuses in the UK use wild animals; regrets the deliberate failure by campaigners to distinguish between wild and domestic animals in circuses; notes the scientific evidence in the Kiley-Worthington Report, commissioned by the RSPCA and written by a respected animal behaviourist, which found that, rather than being intrinsically harmful to captive animals, circuses can provide them with a beneficial mixture of exercise, stimulation and human contact; recognises that circuses' transport records show that the times and conditions for animals in transit exceed the legal requirements; supports the independent inspections that are conducted by local authorities with the full cooperation of circuses; praises the leading circuses for adopting an independent code of conduct and the wider industry for working together with the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs in order to formulate the proposed regulations for the use of animals in circuses; and vigorously defends the right of touring circuses to continue to use domestic animals such as horses, dogs and budgerigars in full compliance with the welfare test of the Animal Welfare Bill'.
1:3:06(a1)


1627ANNIVERSARY OF HUNTING ACT 200413:2:06
Paul Flynn
Tony Lloyd
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Eric Martlew
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr John Leech
* 79
 Mr Clive Betts
   That this House celebrates the first anniversary of the implementation of the Hunting Act 2004 and the end of the gratuitous cruelty of traditional hare-coursing, stag hunting and foxhunting; congratulates the hunts who changed to drag hunting, eliminating the prolonged pursuit and barbaric deaths of defenceless animals; is delighted that the Act did not destroy 35,000 jobs or the economy of the countryside nor lead to the putting down of thousands of hounds and horses; regrets that some compassionate concessions in the Act have been exploited to continue some blood sport activity; understands the cautious approach of the police in the past year but now calls for rigorous vigilance and prosecutions of breaches of the Act; and anticipates further advances in the welfare of game birds and circus animals and is confident that no future legislators will bring back the cruelty inherent in traditional hare-coursing, stag hunting and foxhunting.


1632ROYAL MAIL AND PRESSTREAM13:2:06
Miss Julie Kirkbride
Mr Gregory Campbell
Derek Conway
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
Stephen Williams
Mr Nigel Dodds
* 65
 Graham Stringer
   That this House notes with concern the recommendation of Postcomm to remove the second-class magazine delivery service, Presstream 2, from price control from April 2006; believes that this is abdicating its responsibility to control prices chargeable by a dominant supplier, Royal Mail, whose de facto monopoly has been granted by Postcomm; fears that magazine publishers will be exposed to significant price increases due to lack of regulatory controls and no notable competitive option for at least the next five years to the ultimate detriment of consumers; and urges the Government to suggest to Postcomm that it looks again at this recommendation following, as it does, so soon after the introduction of size-based pricing and the changes that Royal Mail have introduced in the move from weight to size-based delivery.


1633HIV TREATMENT AND NHS PRESCRIPTION CHARGES13:2:06
Mr Paul Burstow
Mr Neil Gerrard
Mr Alan Meale
Mr John Leech
Mr Gregory Campbell
Peter Bottomley
* 65
 Ms Sally KeebleMr Andrew Pelling
   That this House notes that the regulations specifying conditions which qualify for prescription charge exemptions have not changed since 1968, and remain a significant barrier to the health care and quality of life of patients living with HIV; recognises that living with HIV, an infection first diagnosed 14 years after this legislation was introduced, can cause considerable physical and financial hardship; and calls on the Government to fulfil the commitment it made whilst in Opposition finally to review the list of conditions currently exempt from prescription charges with a view to adding HIV to the list.


1635INDEPENDENT PRESCRIBING13:2:06
Laura Moffatt
Dr Doug Naysmith
Dr Andrew Murrison
Sandra Gidley
Mr Alan Meale
Mr John Leech
* 116
 Graham Stringer
   That this House welcomes the Government's recent announcement on independent prescribing powers for pharmacists and nurses; recognises that pharmacy and nursing professionals will have to undergo significant training to be granted these extended powers and will operate within an agreed range of competencies; notes that this new way of working will relieve pressure on general practitioners and vastly improve the speed at which patients will be able to access treatment and medicines; and urges the Government to ensure that these proposals are implemented in full through regulations as soon as possible.


1640INTERNATIONAL CHILDHOOD CANCER DAY 200614:2:06
Mr Andrew Lansley
Mr John Baron
Mr Crispin Blunt
Tim Loughton
Dr Andrew Murrison
Mr Stephen O'Brien
* 68
 Angela Watkinson
   That this House notes that Wednesday 15th February is International Childhood Cancer Day 2006; further notes that cancer and leukaemia are the biggest killer diseases of children in the UK and that five new cancer cases in children and young people are diagnosed every day; recognises that cancers in children develop in different parts of the body and impact upon health in different ways compared to those which emerge in adults; believes that children living with cancer benefit when they receive rapid treatment at specialist centres; applauds the invaluable work of the UK's 22 child cancer units, including the one at Barts and the Royal London Hospital; further notes that a number of events are taking place in the UK and worldwide to mark International Childhood Cancer Day, including a continuation of the Through My Eyes: A Day in the Life of Children with Cancer Around the World project, through which children living with cancer tell their own story by taking photographs of their school and hospital; and calls on the Government to raise public awareness of cancers in children and promote research into effective treatment of these cancers and leukaemia.


1648COLLIERY SURFACE WORKERS CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE SCHEME14:2:06
Mr Michael Clapham
Mr David Hamilton
Mr Kevan Jones
Mr David Anderson
Mr Denis Murphy
Mr Dennis Skinner
* 72
 Ms Katy Clark
   That this House notes that the Department of Trade and Industry laid a minute before Parliament on 10th July 2000 accepting liability for surface workers who worked in dusty jobs; welcomes the fact that 84,000 mixed cases have been settled, but points out that many were exposed to more dust on the surface; considers it unjust that a surface worker with underground service who contracts the disease from a dusty surface job receives compensation but a man with surface-only service does not; is aware that on two occasions, in the debate on 7th February 2006, the Minister of Energy stated that the Department of Trade and Industry did not deny liability in all such cases; is concerned that many firms of solicitors have received hundreds of denial letters for such claims; and calls on the Minister to end this injustice by negotiating with the mining unions a no-fault liability scheme for surface workers.


1652NOMINATION OF JEFF HALPER AND GHASSAN ANDONI FOR THE NOBEL PEACE PRIZE15:2:06
Richard Burden
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Mr David Hamilton
Mrs Ann Cryer
Richard Younger-Ross
* 27
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House congratulates Jeff Halper from Israel, and Ghassan Andoni from Palestine, on being nominated for the 2006 Nobel Peace Prize; recognises the important contribution that they have made as grassroots peace activists against the Israeli Occupation of the West Bank and Gaza; notes their work to increase co-operation and understanding and their determination to strive for equality between their peoples within the framework of sovereign and democratic states; and welcomes their nomination by the American Friends Service Committee (Quakers).


1653PRESCRIPTION PRICING AUTHORITY AND THE CAPACITY IMPROVEMENT PROGRAMME15:2:06
Mr John Leech
Paul Holmes
Mark Hunter
David Howarth
Andrew George
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 25
 Helen Goodman
   That this House recognises that the Prescription Pricing Authority (PPA) is an efficient, cost-effective public service run by public sector staff with the interests of patients and the NHS at heart; notes that the Capacity Improvement Programme (CIP), first announced in December 2003, aimed to increase the PPA's prescription processing capacity to deal with the increased workload without the need significantly to increase staff numbers; recognises that it was assumed that roll-out of the CIP would not be completed until March 2008; notes with concern that this roll-out is now to be phased in over one year between April 2006 and March 2007 and that it is designed significantly to reduce staff numbers to meet the Business Services Agency (BSA) targets for savings; further notes that the CIP is, as yet, untested and that there is a real concern among staff that rushing in a new system poses risks to service delivery; and therefore urges the BSA to extend the roll-out of CIP to ensure the smooth and effective transfer of service delivery and to rule out compulsory redundancies.


1656TREATMENT OF SANJAR UMAROV IN UZBEKISTAN15:2:06
Keith Vaz
Mark Durkan
Peter Bottomley
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Greg Pope
Jeremy Corbyn
* 24
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House notes with regret the detention of Sanjar Umarov, leader of the Sunshine Coalition, by Uzbekistan authorities in October 2005; further notes the appalling treatment he has suffered in detention; calls on the Government and others to make the strongest representations to the Uzbekistan government to ensure respect for human rights including the right to a fair trial for all of those in detention; and urges the Uzbekistan government to provide proper medical care and access to independent legal representation to Mr Umarov as soon as possible.


1664NATIONAL SCIENCE WEEK15:2:06
Colin Challen
Mr Nick Hurd
John Battle
David Howarth
Emily Thornberry
Joan Walley
* 106
 Mr Christopher Fraser
   That this House welcomes the thirteenth National Science Week from 10th to 19th March 2006, which is coordinated by the British Association for the Advancement of Science (BA) and funded by the Department of Trade and Industry and incorporates ESRC Social Science Week; supports the aim of National Science Week to celebrate the role of science in the UK; notes that over half a million people are expected to take part in around 1,500 events across the UK; welcomes the BA's `Click for the Climate' campaign with its focus on personal responsibility towards tackling climate change; encourages all hon. Members to pledge to take their own individual steps to reduce their personal energy consumption during the week; and supports the BA's invitation to supermarkets to reduce the price of their energy-saving light bulbs.


1667SEVERN BEACH RAILWAY LINE16:2:06
Stephen Williams
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
Peter Bottomley
Mr John Leech
Andrew George
* 19
 Steve Webb
   That this House notes that 6th March marks 141 years since the opening of the Severn Beach railway line in Bristol; further notes that this line served a vital purpose during the First World War in carrying munitions and today carries thousands of commuters per week; acknowledges that Thomas Cook has listed this line as one of the most scenic routes in Europe; and calls on the Government to ensure that this valuable line is maintained for the benefit and enjoyment of the local community and visitors.


1669PRICE FOR MILK PAID BY BRITISH SUPERMARKETS16:2:06
Daniel Kawczynski
Richard Younger-Ross
Mrs Ann Cryer
Sandra Osborne
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Gregory Campbell
* 44
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House notes with concern and disdain the way in which British supermarkets treat British dairy farmers; and urges the setting up of an all-parliamentary group of hon. Members who feel passionately about British agriculture and who will collectively seek to lobby supermarket bosses to ensure that they pay a fair price for the milk they buy domestically.


1678ENVIRONMENTAL CASE FOR RAIL16:2:06
John McDonnell
Dr Gavin Strang
Joan Walley
Mr David Drew
Graham Stringer
Ms Katy Clark
* 69
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House notes that transport accounts for more than a third of total UK carbon dioxide emissions; is concerned that carbon dioxide emissions from transport are predicted to rise by almost 10 per cent. between 2000 and 2010; supports an integrated transport system in which different transport modes complement rather than compete with each other; further notes that the railways produce substantially less carbon dioxide emissions than cars, road freight or aviation; and therefore urges the Government to ensure that the protection and expansion of the rail network is central to its policy of reducing carbon emissions.


1679JOB CUTS IN LOCAL NEWSPAPERS16:2:06
Mr Austin Mitchell
John McDonnell
Tony Lloyd
Angus Robertson
Mr David Drew
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 64
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House expresses its grave concern at the hundreds of jobs, including those of many journalists, which have been cut at local newspapers in recent weeks, including more than one in five journalists at the Manchester Evening News; notes that profit levels are up to 37 per cent. in some parts of the newspaper industry and that all local newspaper groups are making substantial profits; is concerned that coverage of local news, local and national politics, sport, arts and other events will suffer as a result of the cuts and mergers; and therefore urges newspaper proprietors to put investment in quality journalism at the heart of their future strategies.


1680DELIVERING SAFER RAIL STATIONS16:2:06
Kelvin Hopkins [R]
John McDonnell
Mr Ian Davidson
Ms Katy Clark
Mrs Linda Riordan
Alan Simpson
* 50
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House notes the Public Accounts Committee Report `Maintaining and Improving Britain's Railway Stations'; welcomes the Committee's findings that passengers would like stations to be safe and secure with staff and good quality information available; further notes that research for the Department for Transport found that improvements in station safety would increase rail use by up to 11 per cent.; further notes the need for safer stations has been demonstrated by the British Transport Police report that violent crime on trains has risen by 43 per cent. in the last five years; therefore welcomes the RMT study which concluded that the £200 million saved by bringing train operating companies back into public ownership would pay for more than 1,600 extra station staff and double the stations' improvements budget; and therefore calls on the Government to return the train operating companies to public ownership to help finance properly staffed, safer stations.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1681RAIL WORKERS' PENSIONS16:2:06
John McDonnell
Alan Simpson
Ms Katy Clark
Mrs Linda Riordan
Jeremy Corbyn
Kelvin Hopkins [R]
* 31
 Mr Neil GerrardMr David Hamilton
   That this House is deeply alarmed at the attempts by railways employers substantially to increase employee pension contributions; notes this will not only be detrimental to rail workers' earnings but will threaten the future viability of the Railways Pension Scheme by forcing existing members to opt out, and deterring new members from joining; is concerned that rail employers are considering closing scheme sections, raising retirement ages and reducing benefits; believes the threat to rail workers' pensions is a direct result of the fragmentation of the Railways Pension Scheme and of employers taking pension holidays; strongly supports the rail unions' campaign to cap employees' contributions, maintain existing benefit rates, simplify the Railways Pension Scheme's structure and open the Scheme to all staff; and therefore urges the Government to do all within its power to protect the pensions of rail workers.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1682PUBLIC HEALTH AND MENTAL HEALTH16:2:06
Lynne Jones
Tim Loughton
Sandra Gidley
Kelvin Hopkins
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr Paul Burstow
* 98
 Ms Sally KeebleMark Pritchard
   That this House believes that mental health should form a central part of mainstream public health reforms; is appalled that people with severe mental illness can expect to live 10 years less than other people; congratulates Rethink, the charity for people affected by severe mental illness, for campaigning to ensure that people with severe mental illness should be a top priority for programmes on obesity, exercise and smoking cessation because of the high levels of physical health problems among this group; urges the Government to fulfill its commitment to tackling health inequalities through the Public Health White Paper, Choosing Health, and the White Paper, Our Health, Our Care, Our Say; and calls on the Government to reassert its commitment to keep mental health as one of its three health priorities.


1683VICTIM SUPPORT WEEK 200616:2:06
Mr Edward Davey
Richard Younger-Ross
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
Mike Penning
Mr Mike Hancock
* 80
 John BercowMr Iain Wright
   That this House welcomes Victim Support Week, running from 20th to 24th February; congratulates the charity Victim Support on reaching its 32nd year of providing support to witnesses, victims, their families and friends in the community and when they go to court; notes that since 2003 Victim Support has had a witness service in every criminal court in England and Wales; and commends the work of Victim Support in raising awareness of victims' and witnesses' rights and in providing support for all people affected by crime.


1686HOME OXYGEN SUPPLIES27:2:06
Mrs Linda Riordan [R]
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Jim Dobbin
* 59
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House expresses serious concern at the decision to transfer the delivery of oxygen away from local pharmacies to private companies; regrets that this means the provision will not be made by these pharmacies, who were community-based and aware of patients' needs; is concerned that the 60,000 people across the country who rely on oxygen will now have to wait longer to receive their supplies; and calls on the Government to think again about this decision, as well as resisting any future plans to move away from localised provision of key health services such as these.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1688CAMPAIGN TO BAN DIVING IN FOOTBALL27:2:06
Keith Vaz
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mr Mike Hancock
* 26
 Mr Brian Binley
   That this House supports the efforts of the Supporters Say No To Diving campaign; applauds the Football Association, Professional Footballers' Association and the League Managers' Association for supporting the campaign; hopes that the message will be spread so that the World Cup is not overshadowed by diving controversies; calls on professionals to remember their responsibilities as role models for the young; and hopes the campaign will be successful in eradicating diving from football.


1689IRAQI TRADE UNIONS27:2:06
Mr David Anderson
Joan Ruddock
Mr Dai Havard
Rob Marris
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Peter Bottomley
* 65
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House supports the independent and democratic Iraqi trade union movement, mainly centred around the newly merged Iraqi Workers' Federation (IWF) and the Kurdish trade unions, which play an important role in the re-building of Iraq's devastated national economy and consolidating the current political process in order to create a democratic, united and federal state after years of repression and hardship at the hands of the deposed dictatorship of Saddam Hussein; is, therefore, deeply disturbed that on 8th August 2005 the Iraqi Council of Ministers issued decree 8750 which declared that union finances would be taken over by the government and that a new law on trade unionism would be developed by the government, without mentioning freedom of association, which is a basic human right and one of the fundamental conventions of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), or the involvement of the Iraqi trade union movement; is further disturbed at recent reports that the Iraqi government has replaced the leadership of the independent engineers' union with its own appointeees in a prima facie breach of freedom of association; welcomes the decision of Iraqi professional organisations to create jointly with the IWF an umbrella organisation to oppose decree 8750; congratulates the TUC for initiating global protests against decree 8750 and the International Confederation of Free Trade Unions for supporting the IWF's complaint formally requesting that the ILO intervene directly with the Iraqi government; and supports the IWF and others in all available democratic means to stop this undemocratic practice against Iraqi workers.


1691BRITISH TROOPS AND THE INTERNATIONAL CRIMINAL COURT27:2:06
Harry Cohen
Lynne Jones
Mr Martin Caton
Mark Durkan
Jeremy Corbyn
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 10
 Mr Robert Marshall-Andrews
   That this House disagrees with the Secretary of State for Defence that the International Criminal Court should have no role in cases where British soldiers are alleged to have committed war crimes; and considers that such immunity if granted to British troops would be damaging to the operation and legitimacy of the court.


1694JAMIL EL-BANNA AND BRITISH RESIDENTS IN GUANTANAMO BAY27:2:06
Sarah Teather
Sandra Gidley
Mr Jeremy Browne
Norman Lamb
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
* 35
 Mr Andrew Love
   That this House applauds the Times Series Newspapers on their `Justice for Dad' campaign with its call to the British Government and US Administration to bring justice to Jamil el-Banna, a British resident held in Guantanamo Bay for over three years without charge or trial; regrets the Prime Minister's use of the word `anomaly' to describe the camp at Guantanamo Bay and suggests that he uses the term `international disgrace' in the future; and calls on the British Government to acknowledge its moral duty towards British residents held in Guantanamo Bay, particularly those such as Jamil el-Banna who have British children, and to make immediate representations to the US Administration calling for Jamil el-Banna and other British residents either to be given a fair trial or to be released without further delay.


1695VAT ON DOMESTIC BUILDING WORK27:2:06
Gordon Banks [R]
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Gordon Prentice
Mr Mike Hancock
* 52
 Mr Don FosterMr Paul KeetchMr David Hamilton
   That this House notes that the Government has the right until 31st March to propose a reduced rate of VAT for domestic building work; supports the Government in its drive to improve the quality of domestic building work through the TrustMark initiative; and urges the Government to support the TrustMark by reducing the rate of VAT on domestic building work to five per cent., thereby depriving rogue builders of their commercial advantage.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1696ACTION MESOTHELIOMA DAY27:2:06
Mr Michael Clapham
John Battle
Jim Sheridan
Mrs Ann Cryer
Nia Griffith
Mrs Madeleine Moon
* 97
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonDanny Alexander
 Ms Katy Clark
   That this House welcomes the first Action Mesothelioma Day on 27th February and the campaign, led by the British Lung Foundation, which aims to raise awareness of mesothelioma, the asbestos cancer; regrets that one person in the UK dies from mesothelioma every five hours, in most cases 20 to 40 years after their exposure to asbestos; further regrets that incidence of the disease is rising and is not expected to peak until 2015; supports the 15 point Mesothelioma Charter which calls for faster diagnosis, better treatment and care services, more funding for research and prevention of future asbestos exposure; and urges the Government and the Cancer Tsar to make mesothelioma a national priority.


1700ARCHIVES FOR AFRICA INITIATIVE27:2:06
Dr Brian Iddon [R]
Mr Mark Lancaster [R]
Willie Rennie
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Jim Dobbin
* 50
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House congratulates the Royal Society of Chemistry (RSC) on the launch in the House on Tuesday 28th February of its excellent Archives for Africa initiative; applauds the free access that the Society is proposing to give in African countries to the RSC's extensive collection of historical scientific journals which stretches back to 1841; notes that this launch is being supported by right hon. and hon. Members on all sides of the House, including the right hon. Hilary Benn MP, Secretary of State for International Development, Mr Andrew Mitchell MP, Shadow Secretary of State for International Development and Mr Andrew George MP, Shadow International Development Secretary for the Liberal Democrat Party; and believes that Archives for Africa will play a significant part in building scientific capacity in African countries by fostering scientific knowledge and research.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1702CUTS IN LOCAL RAIL FUNDING FOR THE SEVERN BEACH LINE27:2:06
Kerry McCarthy
Dan Norris
Roger Berry
Kelvin Hopkins
Alison Seabeck
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 21
   That this House condemns the decision by Liberal Democrat councillors on Bristol City Council to recommend ending financial support for local rail services on the Severn Beach railway line in Bristol by cutting the entire £138,000 rail support grant from the local authority transport budget; believes that this decision puts the future of existing local rail services into doubt at a time when rail users are calling for an expansion of local rail services; notes that from December 2006 it is proposed to substitute a bus service for an existing through-train service along the line; supports the campaign to save Bristol's rail services; and calls on Bristol City Council to reverse this decision.

As an Amendment to Kerry McCarthy's proposed Motion (Cuts in Local Rail Funding for the Severn Beach Line):

Stephen Williams
Mr John Leech
Andrew Stunell
John Hemming
Steve Webb
* 5
Line 1, leave out from` House' to end and insert `notes that the terms of the new rail franchise for the West of England require the maintenance of existing services without any need for subsidy from local authorities and that the new franchise holder, First Great Western, has indicated that current services on the Severn Beach line will continue; and further notes that at Bristol City Council's budget meeting on 28th February the opposition Labour group did not table any amendments to the controlling Liberal Democrat group's budget.'.
1:3:06(a1)


1703RIGHT TO READ CHARTER FOR PRINT DISABLED PEOPLE28:2:06
Annette Brooke
Mr David Heath
John Battle
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
Bob Spink
* 61
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House expresses its concern that one year after the Right to Read Charter was handed in to Number 10 Downing Street with over 32,000 signatures, no Government funding has been made available to increase the amount of books available in large print, audio and Braille; notes that each year less than five per cent. of books become available in formats accessible to people with a visual impairment, dyslexia or other reading-related disability; further notes that this figure has not changed in the last year; and therefore calls on the Government to take urgent steps to end the exclusion of print disabled people from being able to gain access to books, magazines and newspapers.


1704USE OF PRIMATES IN SCIENTIFIC PROCEDURES28:2:06
Mr David Drew
Mr Alan Meale
David Taylor
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Mike Weir
David Lepper
* 50
 Mr Paul KeetchMr Austin MitchellMr Martin Caton
 Mr David HamiltonMrs Linda RiordanMr Nick Clegg
   That this House notes the use of thousands of non-human primates each year in scientific procedures in the United Kingdom and across the EU; further notes that their level of sentience and highly developed social instincts make it extremely difficult to meet their behavioural needs in a laboratory setting; further notes that physical differences between human beings and other primates may make it impossible to predict reliably human outcomes from primate procedures; further notes public opposition to the use of primates; calls upon the Government to extend the current ban on the use of great apes to all primates as a matter of urgency; and further calls on the Government to press for an EU-wide ban on primate experiments as part of the impending review of European Union Directive 86/609/EEC.


1705SQUARE ROUTE GROUP28:2:06
Mr Fraser Kemp
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Martin Caton
* 15
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House notes that the Square Route Group, a group of women on Wearside, have transformed their community in New Herrington by the creation of a doorstep green in the centre of their community; further notes that they have just completed the funding of road markings and new art features including four trees fired in metal, to be officially launched in May; and congratulates them for the achievement of true people power and for raising more than half a million pounds to reach their outstanding goal.


1706TRADE UNION RECOGNITION28:2:06
Mr Fraser Kemp
Mark Durkan
Mr Alan Meale
Jim Dobbin
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 138
 Dr Howard StoateDr Doug NaysmithMr John Grogan
 Mr David CrausbyMs Dari TaylorJohn Robertson
 Mr David HamiltonKitty UssherMs Katy Clark
   That this House notes that Asda Wal-Mart has been fined £850,000 in the United Kingdom for offering employees a pay rise to give up union rights at their depot in Washington Tyne and Wear; congratulates the GMB union on its successful campaign on the legal right to maintain union recognition which is fundamental to society; expresses concern over the role of the Portland public relations company in its attempts to discredit the GMB; and further notes that trade unions play a constructive role in the United Kingdom for employees and employers.


1707TOURETTE SYNDROME28:2:06
Robert Key
Vera Baird
Mr David Heath
Sir Nicholas Winterton
David T. C. Davies
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 85
 Mr David HamiltonLynne FeatherstoneEmily Thornberry
   That this House notes that Tourette syndrome can affect one school child in a hundred; is aware that people with this syndrome may have obsessive-compulsive disorders and attention deficit hyperactivity disorders that can be more important for their school and social functioning than the involuntary movements (tics) and occasional involuntary vocalisations including swearing (vocal tics) that cause great distress; believes it is probably inappropriate to serve Tourette syndrome patients with anti-social behaviour orders; acknowledges the national shortage of specialists for diagnosis and treatment; is concerned that requests for a statement of educational needs are frequently turned down by schools and by local education authorities; calls on the Government to improve inter-departmental co-operation for Tourette syndrome patients across health, education, employment and social services; and recommends a review of relevant research funding in the United Kingdom.


1708ABUSE OF NHS STAFF28:2:06
Mr Paul Murphy
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Mr David Heath
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
* 84
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonMr Jamie Reed
   That this House notes with concern the results of a recent Royal College of Nursing survey that shows that 40 per cent. of nurses have been attacked or harassed at work in the past year; recognises the distress that such threats, verbal abuse and physical attacks on nursing staff can cause to nurses already facing the pressures of a challenging profession; commends nurses and other healthcare professionals on the tremendous contribution that they make to the NHS; and supports measures to deal with those who harass, abuse or attack hospital staff using the full available force of the law.


1709COMMONWEALTH DAY, MONDAY 13th MARCH28:2:06
Mr David Marshall
Sir Nicholas Winterton
John Austin
Sir John Butterfill
Jenny Willott
Mr George Mudie
* 71
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonMr Brian Binley
   That this House, in common with all parliaments of the Commonwealth, gladly observes Commonwealth Day on Monday 13th March; sincerely supports this year's theme of Health and Vitality - The Commonwealth Challenge, emphasising the Commonwealth's commitment to health and fitness to bring hope to the world; and recognises the excellent work done by the United Kingdom branch of the Commonwealth Parliamentary Association in partnership with its sister branches in the advancement of parliamentary democracy and good governance throughout the Commonwealth.


1710DRUGSLINE CHABAD28:2:06
Mr Lee Scott
Mr John Hayes
Daniel Kawczynski
Mr Richard Benyon
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
* 37
 Mark Pritchard
   That this House welcomes the work done by London charity Drugsline Chabad to tackle the problems caused by drug and alcohol addiction; welcomes the progress made by Drugsline Chabad to reach people from all parts of society; notes that the charity hopes to see a significant increase in the number of individuals accessing support via its helpline in 2006 and to reach an additional 50,000 schoolchildren through its education programme; calls on the Government to provide encouragement to privately-funded charities providing drugs education through specialist workers; and notes that information and education at an early age help to prevent the damage caused by drug addiction in later life.


1711STAND UP FOR SOCIAL CARE CAMPAIGN28:2:06
Mr Paul Burstow
Mrs Joan Humble
Lorely Burt
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Mr David Heath
* 83
 Mr Alan BeithMr David Hamilton
   That this House believes that the social care elements of the Health and Social Care White Paper, Our Health, Our Care, Our Say, must be properly resourced as highlighted by the Community Care magazine's Stand Up For Social Care campaign; further notes the risk of cost-shunting between the NHS and social care where the costs of continuing care are pushed on to local authorities; and believes that these budget issues must be resolved first if service users are to be supported to make the most of their lives in the way that the White Paper suggests.


1712BEST PRACTICE IN LANDSCAPE AND HORTICULTURE AT THE OLYMPICS28:2:06
Mr Brian H. Donohoe
Mr David Marshall
Mr Christopher Fraser
Mr Brian Jenkins
Bob Russell
Andrew George
* 58
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House welcomes the efforts of the UK landscape and horticulture industry to seek a partnership with the Olympic Delivery Authority (ODA) to provide an environmentally sustainable Olympic park that demonstrates the very best in United Kingdom best practice in green landscaping and planting; and calls upon the ODA to ringfence the money for green landscaping and horticulture early in the development process and to ensure that plants are sourced early and in an environmentally sustainable manner.


1713MANUFACTURE OF TARTAN FOR THE ARMED FORCES28:2:06
Mr Jim McGovern
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Mike Weir
Peter Bottomley
* 19
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House is deeply concerned about the Ministry of Defence's decision to remove the stipulation that the bulk purchase of tartan material required for the new super-regiment should be produced by traditional and quality methods; believes that value for money should not be simply about price but should also take note of quality; further believes that no decision should be made that jeopardises the quality of ceremonial kilts for the armed forces; congratulates the previous suppliers, Robert Noble, who have done a fantastic job supplying the armed forces for the last 150 years; and urges the Ministry of Defence to reverse its decision.


1717ROYAL MAIL FINE28:2:06
Mr Roger Godsiff
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Martin Caton
Jeremy Corbyn
* 25
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House notes that the Royal Mail has recently been fined £11.7 million for allowing millions of letters and parcels to be lost or stolen through lack of managerial supervision; further notes that the industry's regulator, Postcomm, who levied the fine, believed that the fault lay overwhelmingly with the management and was not a reflection on the dedication and commitment of postmen and postwomen; and agrees with consumer groups, including Postwatch, that customers will welcome the penalty as it will send a clear message to the Royal Mail that the service continues to be far from satisfactory.


1719CARDIAC RISK IN THE YOUNG (No. 2)28:2:06
Tim Loughton
Ms Dari Taylor
Mr Kevin Barron
Dr Vincent Cable
Mr Simon Burns
Mr John Baron
* 94
 Dr Hywel FrancisMark Pritchard
   That this House congratulates Cardiac Risk in the Young (CRY) on its work to raise awareness of the 1st anniversary of the new Chapter 8 in the National Service Framework on Arrhythmias and Sudden Cardiac Death published on 4th March 2005, which aims to reduce the average eight cardiac-related deaths of fit young people a week; welcomes the launch on 1st March of the results of a recent survey of primary care trusts, general practitioners and the public addressing issues pertinent to the new Chapter 8; recognises the work of CRY's cardiac specialists and CRY's sports and schools screening programmes, the donation of over £400,000 of cardiac equipment to general practitioners surgeries and hospitals and the development of a network of bereavement supporters; and looks forward to the next CRY Raising Awareness Week from 3rd to 8th July.


1722ENERGY PRICES AND WINTER DEATHS28:2:06
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Gregory Campbell
Ms Diane Abbott
Mark Durkan
Mr Nigel Dodds
* 33
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House notes with concern the immoral increases in energy, and in particular gas, prices recently announced; believes that such substantial price rises are indefensible; notes Age Concern's estimate that 150,000 pensioners died from cold-related illnesses during the last five winters, and that more than 20,000 pensioners could die this winter; further notes that due to the rising cost of energy, notwithstanding agreements against disconnection and the Government's winter fuel allowance scheme, many pensioners and other vulnerable groups will be fearful of adequately heating their homes; believes that it is completely immoral that in an energy-producing nation such a situation should be allowed to develop; and calls upon the Government to look again at both the adequacy of the existing schemes and the actions of the energy companies.


1724DC STEPHEN OAKE AND THE GEORGE CROSS28:2:06
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Andrew Mackay
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Gregory Campbell
Bob Spink
* 66
 Mr George HowarthMs Katy Clark
   That this House pays tribute to Detective Constable Stephen Oake of Poynton in the Macclesfield constituency, who was fatally stabbed whilst on operational duty with Greater Manchester Police during an anti-terrorist raid on a flat in Manchester on 14th January 2003; deeply regrets that the Cabinet Office's George Cross Committee has decided not to recommend DC Stephen Oake posthumously to receive the George Cross in recognition of his bravery whilst protecting fellow officers during the incident; notes that the George Cross is the highest award for acts of conspicuous gallantry performed by men or women when not in the face of the enemy; and recognises that this decision will have been received with disappointment and sadness by DC Stephen Oake's family and his many police colleagues and friends in the village where he lived.


1726WATER SPRINKLERS IN SCHOOLS1:3:06
Ms Celia Barlow
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Lynne Jones
Mr Alan Meale
David Taylor
* 80
 Michael Jabez FosterJohn McDonnellMr Richard Shepherd
 Richard BurdenMr Austin MitchellMr Robert N. Wareing
   That this House notes that more than 2,000 schools are damaged by fire each year at an estimated cost of £100 million to local education authorities; further notes that the National Governors' Association has been working with the West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority to raise awareness of fire risk assessment among head teachers and governors; looks forward to their joint publication of a guide for governors on fire risk; and calls upon the Government to broaden its recommendations to make the installation of sprinklers in all new build and major refurbishments of maintained schools mandatory.


1727CHILDREN IN PRISON1:3:06
Dr Rudi Vis
Mark Durkan
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
David Taylor
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 45
 Lynne FeatherstoneMs Katy Clark
   That this House welcomes the investigation commissioned by the Howard League for Penal Reform, conducted by Lord Carlile, into the use of physical restraint, solitary confinement and strip searching of children in prisons and privately run child jails; and calls on the Government to implement all 45 recommendations in order to protect children, end the use of pain and isolation as methods of control and punishment, and to improve the care of children in custody in order to reduce the 90 per cent. reconviction rate.


1728EXECUTION OF POLITICAL PRISONER, HOJJAT ZAMANI, BY THE IRANIAN REGIME1:3:06
Dr Rudi Vis
Bob Spink
Mr Alan Meale
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 23
 Mr Brian Binley
   That this House notes with great concern the ever worsening state of human rights in Iran and the intensification of repression in that country since President Ahmadinejad took office in August 2005; further notes reports by the United Nations, the European Union and international human rights organisations condemning the widespread abuse of human rights in Iran including systematic discrimination against and abuse of women and religious and ethnic minorities, limitations on freedom of expression, the use of inhumane punishments and widespread executions including those of minors; observes the recent exertion of yet further pressure on political prisoners in Iran; condemns in the strongest possible terms, the execution by the Iranian regime on 7th February 2006 of Hojjat Zamani, a member of the People's Mojahedin Organisation of Iran, who had endured physical and psychological torture since his imprisonment in the summer of 2001, because he remained steadfast in his political beliefs; calls on the Government to abandon its failed policy of engagement with the Iranian regime and instead to adopt a firm policy beginning with referral of the Iranian regime's human rights abuses to the UN Security Council; and urges the Government and the United Nations unequivocally to condemn the Iranian regime and to take concrete steps to save the lives of other political prisoners in Iran who are on death row.


1730BRITISH RESIDENTS IN GUANTANAMO BAY (No. 2)1:3:06
Clare Short
Mr Michael Ancram
Sarah Teather
Peter Bottomley
Dr Desmond Turner
Mr Edward Davey
* 54
 Mr Andrew LoveKeith VazMs Katy Clark
   That this House is deeply concerned that the UK Government is failing to represent the interests of the British residents who remain in detention without trial in Guantanamo Bay, many of whom are on hunger strike; believes that people who have sought asylum in the UK and have their families here cannot possibly be represented by the governments from whom they fled or safely return to their countries of origin; and calls on the Government to take action to demand that the eight individuals concerned are brought to trial or returned to live with their families in the UK.


1731ENERGY PRICES AND FUEL POVERTY1:3:06
Mrs Linda Riordan
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Nigel Dodds
Jeff Ennis
Dr Rudi Vis
Dr Ian Gibson
* 38
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonMs Katy Clark
   That this House is concerned that the large rise in energy prices will force many people into fuel poverty; and calls on the Government to set up a statutory scheme with energy companies and relevant charities to put in place energy audits and fuel payments for those most in need.


1732RESOURCING THE WORKSTEP PROGRAMME FOR DISABLED PEOPLE1:3:06
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
David Taylor
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jeff Ennis
Peter Bottomley
* 44
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House supports the Government objective of helping disabled people into employment; applauds the success of the Workstep programme in enabling people with one or more disabilities facing complex barriers to work to develop the confidence and skills they need to secure useful employment; recognises that the people this programme can assist need support that is ongoing, flexible, long-term and focused on the individual; notes that this might take the form of training, specialist equipment or hands-on assistance from a helper; is concerned, however, that Workstep provides for around 23,555 people across the UK, whilst it is estimated that more than 300,000 disabled people could benefit from the programme; and calls on the Government therefore to increase resources for this work so that the real demand for Workstep can be met.


1733WORKSTEP PROGRAMME FOR DISABLED PEOPLE1:3:06
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jeff Ennis
Peter Bottomley
Dr Rudi Vis
* 38
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House welcomes the publication of the Department for Work and Pensions research report, Desirable Outcomes of Workstep, which reports the views of disabled people who have used Workstep, including positive comments on its role in developing higher self-esteem and confidence levels, facilitating greater independence and progression to open employment; notes the recommendations in the report for improving the service provided by Workstep, including introducing more flexibility in the way disabled people join the programme and better information distribution, both to disabled people and providers; and urges the Government to act on the proposals as soon as possible.


1734ST PATRICK'S DAY AND ANTI-RACISM1:3:06
Jeremy Corbyn
John McDonnell
Ms Diane Abbott
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 37
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House warmly welcomes the initiative taken by the Battersea and Wandsworth TUC, Amicus and the Left Field at Glastonbury Festival to bring an anti-racist theme to this year's St Patrick's Day celebrations through the release of a single `Everybody's Welcome to the Hooley!' by north London band Neck; notes that the song draws on an image from a London guest house in the 1950s with a sign in the window saying `No Irish, No Blacks, No Dogs' and so is a rallying call for the continuing campaign against all forms of racial discrimination and intolerance; further notes that all profits from the record will be donated to the Love Music Hate Racism (LMHR) campaign and will assist LMHR in their important work in taking the anti-racist message out to young people through music.


1739EQUAL PAY2:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Alan Meale
Bob Russell
Glenda Jackson
Mr Colin Breed
* 71
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonMs Katy Clark
   That this House notes with concern the findings of the report by the Women and Work Commission which highlighted the fact that women in full-time work are earning on average 17 per cent. less than men; believes that unequal pay based on sex discrimination is completely unacceptable; recognises that following the Equal Pay Act over 30 years ago more needs to be done to address this pay differential; and calls on the Government to introduce mandatory pay audits which would require employers to track and correct gender wage discrepancies as one important measure to correct the unacceptable wage imbalance between men and women.


1740PAPUA NEW GUINEA RAINFOREST2:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Alan Meale
Andrew George
Bob Russell
Glenda Jackson
* 56
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House notes with concern the amount of illegal logging which is threatening to wipe out the natural forests in Papua New Guinea according to a report conducted by Forest Trends; further notes that logging companies are violating laws intended to protect the rainforest with most of the timber being exported to China and often turned into products for the West; recognises that presently the Papua New Guineans are not getting an acceptable return for the logging while one of the country's precious natural resources is dwindling; and calls for present laws, which are sufficient, to be enforced so that the Papua New Guinea rainforest is not wiped out and the country receives the correct return for any logging which takes place.


1742WELFARE OF GREYHOUNDS2:3:06
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Philip Hollobone
Bob Russell
Mr Henry Bellingham
Dr Rudi Vis
Andrew Stunell
* 101
 Mr David AmessDr Evan HarrisMr Joe Benton
 Mr Alan BeithMr David HamiltonMark Pritchard
   That this House calls on the Government to address animal welfare concerns within greyhound racing; notes that 10,000 greyhounds retire from racing each year, only 2,000 of which are known to be re-homed; welcomes provisions for improving racing greyhound welfare in the Animal Welfare Bill; and calls on the Government to bring forward measures, including the possible introduction of compulsory levies, to ensure that proper levels of funding are made available from within the industry towards the cost of greyhound welfare.

As an Amendment to Mr Alan Meale's proposed Motion (Welfare of Greyhounds):

Derek Conway
* 1
Line 7, at end add `and congratulates The Dogs Trust and the Kennel Club for their work in extending care and welfare for greyhounds retired from racing.'.
9:3:06(a1)


1744ROYAL COLLEGE OF NURSING STATISTICS ON VIOLENCE AGAINST STAFF2:3:06
Vera Baird
Mr Kevin Barron
Mrs Nadine Dorries
Mike Penning
Julia Goldsworthy
Sandra Gidley
* 79
 Mr Austin MitchellFrank Cook
   That this House notes with alarm the Royal College of Nursing's statistics showing that four out of 10 nurses have suffered a physical or verbal assault in the last 12 months; further notes that this increase in incidence is having an adverse effect on staff morale and retention within the profession; and urges the Government to address the issues with nursing staff representatives.


1747FUTURE OF THE GROCERY MARKET2:3:06
Mr John Grogan
Keith Vaz
Mr Nigel Evans [R]
Dr John Pugh
Andrew George
Mrs Janet Dean
* 68
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House welcomes the independent report published by the All-Party Parliamentary Group on Small Shops; acknowledges the importance of consumer choice and diversity in the grocery market; recognises the high level of concern in the retail industry and many communities about an unbalanced trading environment; calls on the Government to respond fully to the recommendations made in the report; and urges the Office of Fair Trading to allow a full review of the grocery market in the light of these threats to local shops.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1749MERGER OF GRAMPIAN AND SCOTTISH TELEVISION STATIONS2:3:06
Pete Wishart
Lynne Jones
Alan Simpson
Mr Jim Devine
Willie Rennie
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 10
 Mr Mike Weir
   That this House notes that Scottish Media Group are to merge their two stations in Scotland, Scottish Television and Grampian, into one rebranded channel called STV; believes the rebranding of the new station as STV signifies that this is less of a merger and more of a takeover since Scottish Television was previously known as STV; notes that since the takeover of Grampian Scottish Media Group in 1998 there has been a dramatic reduction in the number of local programmes being produced in or about the north of Scotland; further notes that Ulster TV are strengthening their regional identity and achieving a 50 per cent. lead in audience share over the BBC; expresses concern about these developments, their impact on regional programming and the trend towards centralisation in broadcasting in the UK; and calls on Scottish Media Group to explain in detail how it will strengthen its regional broadcasting throughout the North of Scotland.


1750NATIONAL FAIRTRADE FORTNIGHT6:3:06
John Barrett
Peter Bottomley
David Taylor
Andrew George
Mr Alan Meale
Alan Simpson
* 96
 Mr David HamiltonMr Iain Wright
   That this House welcomes the start of the Fairtrade Fortnight on 6th March with its theme `Make Fairtrade Your Habit'; acknowledges the unique significance of Fairtrade in providing disadvantaged farmers and workers with a better deal from trade and in raising awareness of trade issues amongst UK consumers and citizens; further welcomes continued growth in the awareness of Fairtrade products; notes that in 2005 the UK was the world's leading market for Fairtrade goods; further welcomes the fact that there are now 150 Fairtrade towns, cities, boroughs and villages across the UK; congratulates those towns who will achieve Fairtrade status during the fortnight; and calls on the Government to encourage actively schools, local authorities and retailers to adopt fair trade principles.


1751COMMERCIAL MINICAB SIGNAGE6:3:06
Mr Lee Scott
Mr Mike Hancock
Graham Stringer
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mrs Ann Cryer
Ann Winterton
* 24
 Mr John HoramMr Mark Field
   That this House notes with concern that a large number of women are sexually assaulted every year in London by illegal minicab drivers; further notes that the Public Carriage Office is considering permitting commercial signage on the exterior of licensed minicabs; is concerned that this will lead to the public being deceived by `imitation' unlicensed minicabs using bogus signage as a badge of respectability; believes that commercial signage will increase illegal touting in London and threaten to reverse the downward trend in sexual assaults against women; acknowledges that the Metropolitan Police Cab Enforcement Unit is already overstretched; is alarmed that the Public Carriage Office consultation only proposes one option for consideration and not the status quo; and calls on the Mayor of London and Transport for London to rule out the introduction of commercial signage for minicabs.


1753AGRICULTURE (S.I., 2006, No. 225)6:3:06
Mr David Cameron
Mr Peter Ainsworth
Gregory Barker
Mr James Paice [R]
Bill Wiggin
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 32
 Mr Philip Dunne [R]
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Hill Farm Allowance Regulations 2006 (S.I., 2006, No. 225), dated 1st February 2006, a copy of which was laid before this House on 6th February, be annulled.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1756BEARSKIN HATS6:3:06
Mr Chris Mullin
Alan Simpson
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Ken Purchase
Mr Jim Devine
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
* 79
 Dr Ian GibsonMr Andrew LoveSimon Hughes
 Roger BerryMiss Julie KirkbrideMr Bill Olner
 Mr Dennis SkinnerMike WoodMr David Clelland
 Mr David MarshallMr Mike WeirAnnette Brooke
 Paul FarrellyDr John PughKerry McCarthy
 Mr Shahid MalikJo SwinsonChris Huhne
 Ms Katy Clark
   That this House recognises that the bearskin hats worn by the five guards regiments have no military significance and involve unnecessary cruelty; and invites the Government to end their use and substitute hats made from fake fur.

As an Amendment to Mr Chris Mullin's proposed Motion (Bearskin Hats):

Mr Ben Wallace
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
Mike Penning
Mr Crispin Blunt
Mr Tobias Ellwood
Dr Julian Lewis
* 21
Mr Desmond SwaynePeter BottomleyMr Tim Yeo
Mr James GrayDavid MacleanDerek Conway
Adam PriceMr Dan RogersonLynne Featherstone
Mr Robert GoodwillStephen Hammond
Line 1, leave out from `bearskin' to end and add `cap worn by the five Regiments of Footguards plays an important part in highlighting the regiments' glorious military traditions and service to the Sovereign throughout the centuries; further notes that the bearskin pelts used for them are sourced from a necessary cull of Canadian bears carried out by the indigenous Inuit people every year; further notes that previous trials of artificial fur have failed to find an appropriate replacement and that many bearskins last for many decades especially after the grooming that guardsmen are required to administer to them; further notes with concern that any attempt to remove the bearskin from the Footguards would mean a loss of one of the British Army's trademark images that identifies them across the world; and uges the Government to commit itself to using genuine bearskin in any future manufacture of the bearskin cap.'.
9:3:06(a1)


1757GENDER PAY GAP IN THE CIVIL SERVICE6:3:06
Julie Morgan
Mrs Ann Cryer
John McDonnell
Mrs Joan Humble
Sandra Gidley
Helen Goodman
* 89
 Mr David HamiltonMs Katy Clark
   That this House notes with concern that women in the Civil Service earn on average 25 per cent. less than men, meaning that Government employees suffer greater pay inequality than the national average; believes that to address this the Government must consider introducing department-wide equal pay audits to identify pay inequality, and a national pay framework to provide equal pay for work of equal value; further believes that the Government should make available better flexible working options, and pay and promotion systems that do not discriminate against those who choose to work flexibly; notes that the Treasury's stricter pay regime for the Civil Service has jeopardised many of the pay systems put in place to address structural equal pay problems; and therefore calls on the Treasury actively to encourage departments to include business cases to address equal pay problems as part of their pay remit submissions, and to provide additional funding to support departmental action.


1758FAIRTRADE DRINKS ON VIRGIN TRAINS7:3:06
Mr John Leech
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Peter Bottomley
Dr Brian Iddon
* 60
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House congratulates Virgin Trains on becoming the first train operator in the UK to replace its entire range of hot drinks with produce from Fairtrade suppliers; and encourages all other train operators to follow suit.


1759ENDOMETRIOSIS AWARENESS WEEK7:3:06
Annette Brooke
John McDonnell
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
David Taylor
Peter Bottomley
* 68
 Lynne Featherstone
   That this House welcomes Endometriosis Awareness Week, on 6th to 12th March; congratulates the National Endometriosis Society and the SHE Trust on their success at putting endometriosis as a medical condition on the political agenda; recognises that endometriosis can severely impact on a woman's quality of life due to chronic pain, infertility, the inability to complete an education or sustain a career; notes that there is a significant financial implication to the individual and the state with an estimated £2.8 billion cost just from days lost at work due to delayed and incorrect diagnosis as well as ineffective hit-and-miss treatments; is concerned that endometriosis, which takes an average of eight years to diagnose, is still a relatively unknown disease despite an estimated two million sufferers in the UK; fears that endometriosis is not a current national or primary care trust priority; encourages the scientific community to bring forward high quality research applications on endometriosis to the Medical Research Council; and urges the Secretary of State for Health to accord this the utmost importance to ensure that women in the UK with endometriosis receive earlier diagnosis and the specialist care they need but which many are presently not receiving.


1760INHERITANCE TAX7:3:06
Mike Penning
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr Douglas Carswell
Daniel Kawczynski
James Brokenshire
Mr Peter Bone
* 28
 Mr David AmessMr David BurrowesMark Pritchard
   That this House notes the phenomenal response to the campaign organised by the Daily Express newspaper to abolish inheritance tax, culminating in a 200,000 signature petition to the Treasury; believes that the failure of inheritance tax thresholds to keep pace with house price inflation has meant that millions of ordinary households are now liable for death duty and that inheritance tax is an inefficient and an immoral tax for the recently bereaved; and urges the Government urgently to consider abolishing inheritance tax.


1763ACADEMIC SALARIES7:3:06
Mr Boris Johnson
Peter Bottomley
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr David Drew
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mike Penning
* 37
 Mr Christopher Fraser
   That this House applauds the success of the university sector; recognises the vital contribution universities make to economic, cultural and intellectual well-being; believes that the expansion of higher education has been generally a good thing for individuals and for society; notes, however, that resources per student have shrunk as a result of this expansion; recognises that over the last 20 years, many in the public sector have seen their salaries rise by a greater amount than those of academics; and, while regretting that students will be unfairly penalised by the current strike action, congratulates the Association of University Teachers and the National Association of Teachers of Further and Higher Education for their belated recognition that the best long-term hope for sustainable funding of higher education is some form of co-payment mechanism.


1764INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY AND MICROFINANCE7:3:06
Annette Brooke
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Mr Gregory Campbell
Paul Holmes
* 45
   That this House acknowledges the significant impact that microfinance loans have on women and their families in the developing world; congratulates the vital work of Opportunity International and other organisations in their commitment to supporting microfinance facilities and business training for poor but entrepreneurial women; recognises that over 37 million women have already gained access to finance due to microfinance projects but that many more remain financially excluded; notes that women are highly motivated savers and where microfinance programmes exist, especially within the credit union framework, they repay their loans at a very high rate as well as re-investing their income on their families, particularly children; especially welcomes the importance of microfinance in meeting the Millennium Development Goals; further notes that microfinance reduces hunger and poverty, has been shown to widen access to education as women invest in their children's education and improves the health and nutrition of women and children; welcomes the fact that microfinance empowers women to be more involved in family and community decisions; and on International Women's Day wishes to promote microfinance as a tool to improve gender equality and increase sustainable development.

As an Amendment to Annette Brooke's proposed Motion (International Women's Day and Microfinance):

David Taylor
Mrs Betty Williams
Bob Russell
Helen Goodman
Mrs Janet Dean
Lynne Featherstone
* 6
Line 7, after `exist', insert `especially within the credit union framework'.
8:3:06(a1)


1766PROTECTION OF HARES7:3:06
Dr William McCrea
David Simpson
Sammy Wilson
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
* 45
 Bob Russell
   That this House welcomes the announcement by the Department of Environment Northern Ireland that it will establish a temporary protection order to prevent the killing, taking and trade in Irish hares; is concerned that the results of the 2005 Irish Hare Survey show a 40 per cent. reduction in the population from 2004 figures; notes that this raises concerns about the long-term viability of the hare population; recognises the role that legal and illegal coursing have played in the decline of the hare population; and calls on the Government to introduce legislation as soon as possible to ensure permanent protection for the Irish hare to help secure the long-term survival of the species.


1767FORCE-FEEDING AT GUANTANAMO BAY DETENTION CAMP7:3:06
Nick Harvey
Clare Short
Peter Bottomley
John Penrose
Sarah Teather
Mr Roger Godsiff
* 57
 Mr Andrew LoveKeith VazMr David Hamilton
 Ms Katy Clark
   That this House notes with concern allegations made by Guantįnamo Bay detainee Fawzi al-Odah in a BBC interview that hunger strikers were strapped to a chair and force-fed through a tube three times a day at the detention camp; further notes that Mr Odah was one of 84 hunger strikers at Guantįnamo in December 2005; further notes that fellow inmate Mohammed Bawazir has launched a legal challenge against the force-feeding policy under the US McCain Torture Law; further notes that the US administration has since suggested that this law may not apply to Cuba; and calls upon the Government to restate publicly its opposition to the use of torture in all its forms and to express its support for Mr Bawazir's court challenge.


1770BROWNFIELD FIRST APPROACH FOR NEW HOUSING8:3:06
Mr David Drew
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Jeff Ennis
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
David Taylor
* 35
 Mr Simon Burns
   That this House welcomes the progress made on recycling brownfield land and increasing the supply of housing with house building reaching its highest level for 16 years and 72 per cent. of homes now built on brownfield sites; notes the positive role played by planning policy in housing provision, especially the sequential brownfield first approach in PPG3; and, in the light of this achievement, is concerned and perplexed by the emphasis the Government's draft planning policy on housing places on meeting market demand where it arises, rather than where capacity for development exists; further notes the lack of a clear sequential approach which ensures urban brownfield development takes priority over greenfield development and the lack of measures and resources to secure more affordable housing and encourage urban regeneration; and calls on the Government to retain a strong emphasis on the sequential brownfield first approach when it publishes its new planning policy on housing later this year.

As an Amendment to Mr David Drew's proposed Motion (Brownfield First Approach for New Housing):

Bob Spink
* 1
Line 1, leave out from `land' to end and add `but deplores the over development of small sites and the replacement of small homes by massive blocks of flats which is putting too much pressure on the infrastructure'.
14:3:06(a1)


1771SECTION 106 PLANNING POWERS8:3:06
Mr David Drew
Mr Adrian Sanders
Margaret Moran
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Jeff Ennis
* 45
 Ms Diane AbbottSteve McCabe
   That this House welcomes the Government's intention to retain section 106 planning powers, which allow local authorities to secure affordable housing as part of private housing developments; notes that this is the primary mechanism by which local authorities can ensure that new developments contain an appropriate mix of property types, from luxury houses to affordable rented homes; recognises that the new Planning Gain Supplement can provide funding but not land for affordable housing; is concerned that without the ability to secure land, affordable homes will be pushed to the outskirts and unpopular areas of developing towns; is further concerned that many villages will lose any opportunity to secure land for much-needed affordable homes; and calls on the Deputy Prime Minister and his team to ensure that proposals for a scaled-back, statutory section 106 to deliver affordable housing are not lost during the consultation and subsequent legislation.


1772FUEL POVERTY AND DOMESTIC ENERGY EFFICIENCY8:3:06
Alan Simpson
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
Jeff Ennis
* 52
 Mr David AmessMr David HamiltonMs Katy Clark
   That this House is deeply concerned that recent gas and electricity price increases will make the Government's fuel poverty objectives impossible to attain given current levels of investment and existing programmes; recognises that, whilst cost-effective energy efficiency improvements represent the most rational and sustainable solution to fuel poverty, many households will remain fuel poor after heating and insulation improvements provided under existing fuel poverty programmes; calls on the Government to increase the range and extent of energy saving measures for vulnerable households; and urges the Government to undertake discussions with energy supply companies, fuel poverty campaigning organisations and consumer agencies to develop a national strategy to address escalating fuel costs.


1773DEMOCRACY IN BELARUS8:3:06
Mr Gary Streeter
Mr Geoffrey Clifton-Brown
Mr Andrew Mackay
Mr Martin Caton
Mr David Drew
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 75
 Dr Evan HarrisSimon HughesMr Shailesh Vara
 Mike PenningMr Christopher Fraser
   That this House deplores the recent arrests of opposition activists in Belarus who were campaigning for the Presidential elections on 19th March 2006, including the leaders of reputable political parties; notes that this forms part of a wide scale pattern of arrest, intimidation and oppression by forces loyal to President Lukashenko; believes that the international community should apply more pressure on the government of Belarus to ensure that these elections are free and fair; and looks forward to the day when the 10 million people of this European country can enjoy the freedoms that British people take for granted.


1774CARTOONS8:3:06
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
Glenda Jackson
* 35
 Dr Gavin Strang
   That this House deeply regrets that a leading Iranian newspaper has launched a competition asking people to submit cartoons about the Holocaust; and views this development as a bad reaction to a bad action from a Danish newspaper.


1775BRITISH BEEF8:3:06
Mr Paul Keetch
Andrew Mackinlay
Daniel Kawczynski
Richard Younger-Ross
Mr Greg Pope
Mark Pritchard
* 54
 Norman BakerDr Evan HarrisMr Don Foster
 Lembit ÖpikMr David LawsMike Penning
 Lynne Featherstone
   That this House welcomes the lifting of the 10 year ban on the export of British beef to the EU; urges the Government to work with the industry to promote British beef throughout Europe; encourages British tourists in Europe to ask for British beef at shops and restaurants; and calls upon British embassies and military bases in Europe to begin serving British beef with pride.


1776WORLD KIDNEY DAY 20068:3:06
Mr Stewart Jackson
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
Jeff Ennis
* 55
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House supports World Kidney Day on 9th March 2006, held to raise awareness of the significant increase in the incidence of kidney disease; recognises the importance of early detection and prevention in tackling chronic kidney disease, particularly among at risk groups such as those with diabetes and cardiovascular disease, and those from ethnic minorities; congratulates the Peterborough-based Kidney Research UK's ABLE programme, which targets South Asian and Afro-Caribbean communities by working with them to identify and prevent kidney disease through better awareness and education; notes that more funding is required for renal research; and calls on the Government to make sure effective assessment, education and treatment programmes are in place to promote early detection and prevention, as set out in the markers of good practice for Part II of the Renal National Service Framework, which could reduce kidney failure by up to 50 per cent.


1777NEWSPAPER AND MAGAZINE DISTRIBUTION8:3:06
James Brokenshire
Mr Martin Caton
Mr David Drew
Lynne Jones
Alan Simpson
Mr Stewart Jackson
* 38
 Mr Austin MitchellMr John GreenwayMr David Hamilton
   That this House believes that universal access to newpapers and magazines as provided through widespread national distribution is an essential part of protecting freedom of speech; and accordingly urges the Department of Trade and Industry to take all appropriate steps within its powers to protect this freedom and support moves to create a new industry code of practice to promote more effective distribution as has been agreed by independent retailers, magazine publishers, newspaper publishers and wholesalers.


1779WITHDRAWAL OF LEGAL SERVICES COMMISSION SPECIALIST SUPPORT SERVICES8:3:06
Mr Jonathan Djanogly
Mr Oliver Heald
Mr Dominic Grieve
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Keith Vaz
Mr Stewart Jackson
* 49
 Mr Keith SimpsonMr Christopher Fraser
   That this House believes that the Legal Services Commission's decision to end its specialist support services from July is an incomprehensible error; further believes it will impact heavily on the poorer and most vulnerable members of the community and create an even larger shortfall in provision than already exists; deplores the axing of the telephone specialist support service which provides back-up support for solicitors from expert lawyers, involving free telephone advice, help with casework and external supervision and training for legal advisers; notes the severe effect it will have on high street solicitor firms on the frontline dealing with complex legal issues in the areas of housing, employment, immigration, human rights, mental health, welfare benefits, community care and debt that are covered by the service; and further believes that this proposal will not save money for the Government and will only lead to the same sums being spent in a less efficient way on an alternative and less effective scheme.


1781FEDERATION OF YORKSHIRE AND THE HUMBER POLICE FORCES8:3:06
Mr John Grogan
Mr David Curry
Mrs Linda Riordan
Philip Davies
Jeff Ennis
Alan Simpson
* 13
 Mr John GreenwayMr Barry SheermanMr Robert Goodwill
   That this House supports the formation of a federation of the four police authorities in Yorkshire and the Humber; believes this option would allow greater collaboration between forces on protective services whilst maintaining their independence and existing well supported structures of accountability to local people; recognises that the four different forces in Yorkshire and the Humber face very different challenges; and therefore believes that the federal option rather than a forced merger is the one which is likely to command most support across the region and ensure high quality policing in both urban and rural areas.


1782TELEVISION LICENCE FEE SCHEME FOR DOMESTIC ABUSE REFUGES8:3:06
Jo Swinson
Mr Don Foster
Sandra Gidley
Natascha Engel
Mary Creagh
Peter Bottomley
* 69
 Lembit ÖpikMs Katy Clark
   That this House is deeply concerned that women who have fled to refuge centres due to domestic abuse are responsible for purchasing a television licence immediately should they have a television in their room; notes that many women in such a distressed and displaced position are particularly reliant upon television, especially to entertain their children; is aware that women are at the greatest risk of homicide when they have fled their abuser; further notes that violent men who stalk their ex-partners often pose as officials to gain access to properties when seeking the women; believes that women who have fled a violent partner should not feel threatened by an enforcement officer arriving unannounced at the refuge; further notes that the Government's own targets for local authorities is one refuge bed space per 10,000 population, totalling 6,000 across the UK; further notes that women often do not know how long they will need to stay in a refuge; expresses concern that funds from charities and organisations which run refuge centres are being diverted to pay for television licences for the rooms available to sheltered women; recognises that the hospitality sector already benefits from television licence concessions; further recognises that it is the Government's stated policy to assist the vulnerable in accessing television services; and therefore calls for women's refuge centres to be included in the same television licence fee scheme as hotels and guesthouses.


1783FRANCHISING OF POST OFFICES8:3:06
Clive Efford
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Alan Meale
Mr David Drew
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 27
 Mr David HamiltonMs Katy Clark
   That this House calls on the Post Office to stop its programme of privatisation of post offices; demands that it review all current contracts to determine whether contractual obligations are being complied with by franchise operators; further demands that where these contractual obligations are not being met that post offices are brought back under direct management of the Post Office; notes that the privatisation of Eltham post office has resulted in the deterioration of the level of service to the point where there is no service at all; is appalled that staff at this post office are relying on customers to tell them how to carry out routine transactions; believes that the Post Office has failed to carry out any reasonable checks to determine whether the franchise operator of Eltham post office is capable of delivering any form of basic service; and calls on the Government to halt the privatisation of post offices forthwith.


1784RESUMPTION OF THE EXPORT OF LIVE CALVES8:3:06
Gwyn Prosser
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr Martin Caton
David Taylor
Lynne Jones
Alan Simpson
* 47
 Mr David Drew
   That this House regrets that the lifting of the beef ban will result in an escalation of live animal exports out of Dover and allow the resumption of the cruel practice of transporting young calves to veal farms in continental Europe; notes that scientific research shows that young calves are not well adapted to cope with transport and so suffer considerably during sea crossings and long journeys; further notes that once they reach the continent, many of the calves will be kept in veal crates, which remain lawful in the European Union until the end of 2006, or in barren units in which they are kept on concrete or slatted floors without any straw or other bedding; further notes that such barren systems are illegal under UK legislation which requires calves to be provided with bedding until the age of six months; urges dairy farmers not to resume the export of calves to continental veal farms; further notes that the Government wants to see a trade in meat rather than live animals; and urges the Government to discourage dairy farmers from returning to this inhumane trade and to help them find welfare-friendly and economically viable uses for male dairy calves.


1785END OF EUROPEAN UNION EMBARGO ON BRITISH BEEF9:3:06
Keith Vaz
Andrew George
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr John Leech
* 34
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House welcomes the announcement of the end of the European Union's embargo on British beef; notes that due to especially vigorous testing and vetting procedures British beef is now of the best quality and safest in the world; applauds the efforts and commitment of the British farming community in overcoming this difficult period; and calls upon other countries, including the United States, to repeal their ban on European beef imports.


1787UNION OF CONSTRUCTION ALLIED TRADES AND TECHNICIANS POLITICAL FUND BALLOT9:3:06
Mr Michael Clapham
Harry Cohen
Joan Walley
Mr Stephen Hepburn
Mr Ian Davidson
Mr David Hamilton
* 39
 Mr David AndersonMs Katy Clark
   That this House congratulates the members of the Union of Construction Allied Trades and Technicians for delivering a resounding 93.3 per cent. yes vote in the union's political fund ballot; considers that the current legislation is punitive towards democratic and accountable trade unions; and calls for the abolition of trade union political fund ballots.

As an Amendment to Mr Michael Clapham's proposed Motion (Union of Construction Allied Trades and Technicians Political Fund Ballot):

Bob Russell
* 1
Line 3, after `ballot', insert `believes that members should have the individual choice as to which political party should receive their political fund levy;'.
13:3:06(a1)


1789CHILD TRUST FUNDS AND FRIENDLY SOCIETIES9:3:06
Mr Adrian Bailey
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
Mr David Drew
Mr Martin Caton
* 44
 Dr Evan HarrisMr Andrew LoveAlan Keen
 Linda GilroyCharlotte AtkinsMr Bill Olner
 Steve McCabeMr David HamiltonMr David Anderson
 Mr Ian AustinSarah McCarthy-Fry
   That this House notes that of the 1,305,000 Child Trust Fund accounts reported by the Inland Revenue as opened at 5th January 2006, 567,000 have been lodged with friendly societies; recognises that this represents nearly 44 per cent. of all child trust funds to date; further notes that friendly societies are mutual organisations that offer investment and financial protection to people in all walks of life; commends their strong contribution to the delivery of this key policy to develop a regular savings habit among United Kingdom citizens; and calls upon the Government fully to appreciate the important contribution that friendly societies make when targeting tax incentives to encourage savings.


1792CYPRUS9:3:06
Mr Edward O'Hara [R]
Mr Alan Meale [R]
Dr Rudi Vis [R]
David Lepper [R]
Mrs Ann Cryer
Bob Spink
* 14
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
   That this House takes note of the set of proposals on Cyprus submitted by the Turkish government to the Secretary General of the United Nations on 20th January 2006; shares the stated wish of the Turkish Minister of Foreign Affairs for priority to be given to achieving a comprehensive, just and lasting settlement in Cyprus, and his gratification at the continued engagement of the Secretary-General with the matter; notes with concern however the proposals for a quadripartite meeting between Turkey, Greece, the Greek-Cypriot side and the Turkish-Cypriot side, the outcome of which would subsequently be endorsed by the Security Council of the UN; regards this as an attempt to elevate the secessionist Turkish Cypriot administration to the same status as the legitimate Government of the Republic of Cyprus, and as an attempt to involve the UN in what is properly a matter of Turkey's responsibilities to the EU as an applicant member; further notes with concern the proposal to render legitimacy to the secessionist entity by granting it governmental functions in contravention of international legality and successive UN resolutions; regretfully concludes that the purpose of these proposals is to evade Turkey's legal obligations towards the EU in respect of the extension of the additional Protocol of its Customs Union Agreement to the 10 new EU members including Cyprus; and calls upon Turkey to commit itself to a comprehensive, just and lasting settlement in Cyprus in accordance with UN resolutions, the founding principles of the EU and its obligations to the EU as an applicant member.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1793GURKHA VETERANS10:3:06
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr Adam Holloway
Mr Mark Lancaster
Mr Paul Keetch
Mr Colin Breed
Ms Diane Abbott
* 68
 Mr David HamiltonMr David AndersonMr Brian Binley
   That this House welcomes the Government's overdue steps towards producing Gurkhas' terms and conditions of service which are equitable and fair and which begin to remedy the injustice caused by discriminatory conditions of service; but believes that the Gurkha veterans who served the British Army from the Second World War to 1997 are no less affected by the injustice caused to Gurkhas by the discriminatory terms of service; and therefore urges the Government to take steps to remedy the impact of those discriminatory terms before it is too late for the veterans affected.


1794NATIONAL FIREARMS REGISTER10:3:06
Danny Alexander
Mark Durkan
Mr John Leech
Mr Mike Weir
Mrs Ann Cryer
Lynne Jones
* 36
 Mark FisherMr David Hamilton
   That this House recalls that the establishment of a National Firearms Register was one of the principal recommendations of the Cullen Inquiry that followed the tragic massacre at Dunblane on 13th March 1996; notes that the establishment of the National Firearms Register was subsequently agreed by Parliament in the Firearms Amendment Act 1997; is concerned that, 10 years after the Dunblane tragedy, such a register is still not in place; further notes reports that resources within the Home Office have been directed away from the establishment of the Firearms Register to the national identity card project; and calls on the Government to complete the introduction of the Register without any further prevarication and to provide a full report to the House on the reasons for its delay.


1796NATIONAL ASYLUM SUPPORT SERVICE VOUCHER SYSTEM13:3:06
Ms Diane Abbott
John Bercow
Mr Alan Meale
Bob Russell
Dr Rudi Vis
Lynne Jones
* 63
 Dr Desmond TurnerNorman BakerSimon Hughes
 Mr Paul BurstowMr Colin BreedMr Phil Willis
 Mr Alan BeithLembit ÖpikJulie Morgan
 Mr Michael MooreColin ChallenMr David Laws
 Mr David AndersonJenny WillottMartin Horwood
 Mr Dan RogersonJo SwinsonLorely Burt
 Tim FarronWillie Rennie
   That this House notes that the National Asylum Support Service voucher system for asylum claimants was scrapped in 2001 after a campaign by trade unions, non-governmental organisations and refugee organisations; believes that vouchers are costly, fail to meet asylum seekers' needs, stigmatise this most vulnerable group and leave them open to hostility and abuse; further believes that vouchers should not be used as a method of support for asylum seekers or failed asylum seekers at any stage of the process; and calls on the Government to provide for those on section 4 support in cash rather than vouchers.


1798DEFENCE EXPORT SERVICES ORGANISATION13:3:06
Mr Charles Kennedy
Andrew George
David Taylor
Mr John Leech
Rob Marris
Paul Holmes
* 21
 Mr David DrewClare Short
   That this House notes that the Defence Export Services Organisation (DESO) is the unit of the UK Ministry of Defence which helps UK companies sell their military equipment and services overseas; further notes that through DESO, the UK taxpayer subsidises the export of arms into areas of conflict and to governments that abuse human rights; further notes that the trade in military equipment damages economic development at global, regional and local economic levels; and calls on the Government to close the DESO, not to transfer its functions elsewhere in the public sector nor to allocate public funds to enable them to be undertaken in the private sector.


1799SEX EQUALITY AND COMMISSION FOR EQUALITY AND HUMAN RIGHTS13:3:06
Vera Baird
Julie Morgan
Miss Anne Begg
Joan Ruddock
Tony Lloyd
Stephen Hesford
* 97
 Martin SalterJohn AustinDr Brian Iddon
 Mrs Claire Curtis-ThomasAnnette BrookeMeg Hillier
   That this House notes the 30th anniversary of the Sex Discrimination Act; commends the work of the Equal Opportunities Commission (EOC) and its contribution to progressing action on sex equality over the last 30 years; recognises that over the coming year the EOC will be required to take the lead in promoting the new gender equality duty on public bodies, due to come into force in April 2007; further recognises that the EOC has been a strong supporter of the proposed Commission for Equality and Human Rights (CEHR), sharing the Government's vision for that new body; further recognises that the EOC has played a pivotal role in fostering cross-party consensus around the CEHR and also across a range of sex equality stakeholders as well as a leading role within the Equality and Diversity Forum; values that contribution as fundamental to a successful transition to the CEHR in 2007; and urges the Government to ensure that this contribution is not undermined by a lack of funding for the EOC in 2006-07 and 2007-08.


1802CONTROL ORDERS AND MENTAL ILL HEALTH13:3:06
Harry Cohen
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Mr Alan Meale
Peter Bottomley
Mr John Leech
* 27
 Paul HolmesAnnette Brooke
   That this House believes that the Government should bring forward proposals for better arrangements in relation to people with mental ill-health who are affected by control orders.


1803BETHLEHEM AND RACHEL'S TOMB13:3:06
Roger Berry
Mr Crispin Blunt
Mr Colin Breed
Angus Robertson
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Dr Phyllis Starkey
* 78
 Dr Ian GibsonMr Brian JenkinsMr David Anderson
 Dr Roberta Blackman-WoodsMr Jamie ReedDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House calls attention to the completion of the section of the 8-metre high concrete wall separating Bethlehem from Jerusalem; notes that around 40 Bethlehem families will be cut off from schools and medical facilities; recalls the ruling of the International Court of Justice in July 2004 that the building of the wall on occupied Palestinian territory is unlawful; further notes that the shrine of Rachel's Tomb, sacred to the three major religions, has been purposefully enveloped by the route of the walls and is therefore barred to Palestinians, whether Christian or Muslim; takes heed of widespread anxiety that new Israeli settlement building on the confiscated land around the Tomb may be about to begin with the consequence that Bethlehem may follow the example of Hebron, where recent Israeli settlements are embedded in the midst of the local Palestinian population, causing great provocation; and further notes the warning of Bethlehem's mayor, Dr Victor Batarseh, that `the ghettoization of Bethlehem is not only destroying ancient communities, but is destroying the prospects of peace in the Middle East and the whole concept of international law'.


1806SENTENCING GUIDELINES COUNCIL RECOMMENDATIONS ON RAPE SENTENCES13:3:06
Greg Mulholland
Mike Penning
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 44
 Mr Brian JenkinsTim Farron
   That this House is deeply concerned by the Sentencing Guidelines Council recommendation that future sentences for rape be cut by 15 per cent.; rejects the conclusion that any reduction could be justified because the prison regime is now more demanding; agrees with Rape Crisis's reaction that to reduce sentences sends out the wrong message to future offenders and to victims who are trying to decide whether to give evidence in court; notes Refuge's views that this would be a backward step and believes that sex crimes should be treated more seriously in this country, not less; strongly believes that these proposals risk damaging public confidence in the legal system; and calls on the Government not to implement these recommendations which come at a time when the number of reported rapes is rising each year but conviction rates are falling.


1807JIMMY JOHNSTONE13:3:06
Mr Jim Devine
Mr Jim McGovern
Steve McCabe
Mr Wayne David
Mrs Louise Ellman
Dr Gavin Strang
* 131
 Mr Brian JenkinsMr David Hamilton
   That this House notes with sadness the passing of Celtic and Scotland legend Jimmy Johnstone and offers his family its condolences at this difficult time.


1808POST OFFICE CARD ACCOUNT13:3:06
Mr Alan Meale
Dr Rudi Vis
Bill Etherington
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Bob Spink
Bob Russell
* 76
 John AustinMr Brian JenkinsJeff Ennis
 Mr David HamiltonMr David AndersonMr Brian Binley
 Mark PritchardTim Farron
   That this House is aware that the Department for Work and Pensions has recently announced its intention to close the Post Office Card Account in 2010; believes such a strategy to be both wrong and shortsighted as it will inevitably lead to difficulties for the most vulnerable in their communities through the loss of much of the Post Office network; and calls upon the Government to cease its seemingly endless pursuit of tactics highly favourable to high street banks and instead to recognise the real value and worth of post and sub-post offices whose activities are central to local community life.


1809DEEPCUT INQUIRY13:3:06
Pete Wishart
Mrs Joan Humble
Sandra Osborne
Lembit Öpik
Mark Durkan
Michael Jabez Foster
* 47
 Tim Farron
   That this House notes that, having heard evidence given at the inquest into the death of 17 year-old Private James Collinson on 23rd March 2002, the jury has ruled out suicide and returned an open verdict; further notes that in order to prevent the recurrence of fatalities, Her Majesty's Coroner has exercised his duty to report matters raised at the inquest to the Secretary of State for Defence and urged him to `take whatever steps are necessary to restore public confidence in the recruitment and training of young soldiers whether at Deepcut or elsewhere'; further notes the Coroner's belief that matters brought to his attention `need further examination or at least balanced public exposure', his suggestion that the Minister `should have nothing to fear from an inquiry held in public where the issues can be explored in greater depth' and that the armed forces `deserve these matters to be addressed thoroughly and independently so that rumour and speculation can be met head on'; and urges the Secretary of State to respond to the Coroner without delay and announce a judicial public inquiry with sufficiently broad terms of reference to address public concern over non-combat deaths and ill-treatment issues raised at Deepcut and elsewhere.


1811FUTURE OF PATIENT AND PUBLIC INVOLVEMENT FORUMS14:3:06
Mr John Leech
Mr Gregory Campbell
Derek Conway
David Taylor
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Stephen Williams
* 29
 Mr Don FosterMr David DrewMr Brian Jenkins
 Frank CookSammy Wilson
   That this House welcomes the work of Patient and Public Involvement (PPI) forums to secure improvements in health services in many constituencies; notes that the Government is still reviewing the future of patient and public involvement in health and is concerned at suggestions that local authority overview and scrutiny committees could take on the work of PPI forums; believes the overview and scrutiny process is often highly politicised and can be used as a rubber stamp of executive decision-making, and that committees are already overstretched; further believes that the strength of PPI forums is that they are people-focused and work outside the party political arena; and therefore urges the Government not to retreat from supporting independent patient and public involvement bodies.

As an Amendment to Mr John Leech's proposed Motion (Future of Patient and Public Involvement Forums):

Peter Bottomley
Dr Vincent Cable
Dr Rudi Vis
* 3
Line 9, at end add `and recommends the recreation of community health councils in England.'.
15:3:06(a1)


1812ST. PATRICK'S DAY14:3:06
Mr Eddie McGrady
Mr Alan Meale
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
Mr Ronnie Campbell
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 28
 Simon HughesMr Brian JenkinsClare Short
 Frank CookMr David Anderson
   That this House calls on the Government to provide for St. Patrick's Day, 17th March, to become an annual public holiday in Northern Ireland in recognition of the feast day of Ireland's Patron Saint and the celebrations that are organised by local government authorities and community groups across the communities, and as a measure to assist reconciliation, as Saint Patrick is espoused by all traditions.


1813BATTLE OF THE SOMME REMEMBRANCE14:3:06
Tim Farron
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Greg Hands
Mike Penning
Andrew George
Bob Russell
* 77
 Mr Brian JenkinsJeff EnnisMr David Anderson
 Mark PritchardSammy Wilson
   That this House commemorates the 90th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme on 1st July 1916 and remembers the 420,000 casualties suffered by the British Army during the battle, which lasted until 18th November; praises the Royal British Legion for its continuing work to raise funds to support ex-service men and women, with events including a four day cycle ride from 14th to 18th June to the key locations of the battle; and recognises the vital importance of this work in helping to ensure that the sacrifice, efforts and the interest of past and present service personnel will never be forgotten.


1814BRITISH COUNCIL OFFICES IN GAZA AND RAMALLAH14:3:06
Derek Wyatt
Mr Alan Meale
Derek Conway
Mr Ken Purchase
Peter Bottomley
Sir Nicholas Winterton
* 41
 Richard BurdenJeff EnnisMr David Anderson
   That this House recognises the outstanding work done by the British Council overseas; notes the critical part it plays in the UK's public diplomacy; expresses its thanks that no staff have been hurt by the fires that have occurred in their offices in Gaza and Ramallah; and looks forward to them being re-opened as soon as is practical.


1815GLASGOW AWARD OF FAIRTRADE CITY STATUS14:3:06
Ann McKechin
Mr Ian Davidson
John Robertson
Mr Tom Harris
Mr Mohammad Sarwar
Mr David Marshall
* 47
 Mr Brian JenkinsJeff EnnisAnnette Brooke
 Mr David HamiltonMr David AndersonJo Swinson
 Sammy Wilson
   That this House congratulates the city of Glasgow in achieving Fairtrade City status in March; notes that Glasgow is the largest retail centre in the United Kingdom to date to achieve such status; welcomes the firm commitment by Glasgow City Council together with numerous local organisations, retailers, schools, universities, churches, faith groups and charities in supporting the extension of Fairtrade products and outlets throughout the city; and urges the Government to continue to assist the Fairtrade campaign in Glasgow and throughout the UK in encouraging consumers to provide practical help to poor producers in the developing world and in continuing to call for fairer trade terms for the world's poorest nations.


1816LOCAL GOVERNMENT PENSIONS15:3:06
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Mike Hancock
Mr Andrew Dismore
Alan Simpson
Mr Mike Weir
* 29
 Mr David DrewMr Brian JenkinsJeff Ennis
 Mr David HamiltonMr David AndersonSammy Wilson
 Dr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House is aware that the Government is bringing forward new arrangements to alter the minimum retirement age and early retirement provision in the Local Government Pension Scheme which will alter the present position, especially in relation to its 85 year rule criteria and other established early retirement formulae; believes such an approach to be misguided; and calls upon the Government not to follow such a path, but to guarantee previously negotiated schemes with all public sector workers affected.


1817FOOD SUPPLEMENTS DIRECTIVE AND CONSUMER CHOICE15:3:06
Mr Stephen O'Brien
Mr Andrew Lansley
Kate Hoey
Tim Loughton
Mr Austin Mitchell
Mr John Baron
* 79
 Mrs Cheryl GillanMr David AmessDr Julian Lewis
 Mr Adrian SandersMr Brian JenkinsAndrew Selous
 Anne MiltonMr Christopher FraserMark Pritchard
 Sammy Wilson
   That this House notes the continuing concern about the potential impact of the Food Supplements Directive upon consumer choice in vitamin and mineral supplements; further notes that Ministers have accepted the recommendation of the Board of the Food Standards Agency that their approach to the interpretation of the key provisions of this legislation should be to work in Europe for maximum permitted levels for nutrients in supplements to be set on the basis of safety, whilst securing an enduring flexibility to permit onto the United Kingdom market safe and popular products which lie outside the otherwise restrictive provisions of this legislation; understands that the European Commission will shortly be consulting about the setting of such maximum permitted levels for nutrients under the provisions of Article 5 of the Food Supplements Directive; urges the Government immediately to adopt and implement a co-ordinated strategy for the achievement of their stated objectives for this process; and invites Ministers to keep this House fully informed of the progress that they are making in securing the support of the European Commission and other member states for the principle that consumers should not be denied access to safe supplements of their choice.


1818MARKET HARBOROUGH'S ACHIEVEMENT OF FAIRTRADE STATUS15:3:06
Mr Edward Garnier
Bob Spink
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Mike Hancock
Andrew Rosindell
Peter Bottomley
* 19
 Jeff EnnisSammy Wilson
   That this House congratulates Market Harborough on becoming the first Leicestershire town to achieve Fairtrade status; notes the tremendous amount of hard work done by the Fairtrade Status Steering Group to enrol the support of local business, local schools, local retailers and the local council to encourage people to use Fairtrade products in their daily lives; and supports Market Harborough in its future efforts to increase the awareness of the Fairtrade Foundation and use of its products.


1819TRAIN SERVICES BETWEEN DIDCOT AND LONDON15:3:06
Mr Edward Vaizey
Mr Gregory Campbell
Derek Conway
Lynne Jones
Mr Mark Lancaster
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 7
 Sammy Wilson
   That this House condemns the Government's proposal to reduce early morning and evening mainline train services between Didcot Parkway and London Paddington; notes that the withdrawal of the 05.46 and 06.12 service in particular would significantly lengthen journey times for early morning commuters; further notes that there will now be two 40-minute gaps in service for evening commuters; believes that if such changes are made, there will be a significant increase in overcrowding; brings to the Government's attention the increase in population in the surrounding area which is likely to lead to an increase in the number of rail users in the coming years; and calls on the Secretary of State for Transport to reverse his decision.


1820COMMONWEALTH GAMES15:3:06
Hugh Robertson
Mr Hugo Swire
Mr Malcolm Moss
Mr Mark Field
Andrew George
Bob Spink
* 38
 Mr Brian JenkinsMr David HamiltonJo Swinson
 Sammy Wilson
   That this House welcomes the opening of the Commonwealth Games by Her Majesty The Queen in Melbourne; wishes the very best of luck to all competitors but particularly to those representing the home nations; and thanks Australia for hosting this unique and enjoyable event.


1821TAXPAYERS' CHARTER15:3:06
Stephen Williams [R]
Mr Quentin Davies
Rob Marris
Mr Gregory Campbell
Peter Bottomley
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 31
 Mr Mike HancockMr Brian JenkinsMr David Hamilton
 Lorely BurtSammy Wilson
   That this House believes that the fair and effective financing of public services in today's world requires a clear understanding by taxpayers and tax administration alike of their respective rights and responsibilities and is concerned that the clear vision of these may be obscured by the complexity of much tax management legislation; notes that, prior to the merger into HM Revenue and Customs, both the Inland Revenue and Customs and Excise had Taxpayers' Charters but that with the merger the status of these is unclear and that they have not been reviewed for many years, meaning less protection for the taxpayer; further notes that in the meantime the use of Charters and Bills of Rights to confirm and codify taxpayers' rights and responsibilities and build support for a co-operative relationship between taxpayers and tax administration has developed extensively in many countries; and calls for a set of principles expressed in legislation or a Taxpayers' Charter to set down the rights and obligations of the taxpayer and the tax administration under the Finance Act requiring the Commissioner of Revenue and Customs to bring forward a proposed Charter for ratification by the House.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1822NUFFIELD SPEECH AND LANGUAGE UNIT15:3:06
Mr Edward Davey
Mr Alan Meale
Mr Gregory Campbell
Bob Spink
Derek Wyatt
Dr John Pugh
* 31
 Mr Mike HancockMr Brian JenkinsSusan Kramer
 Sammy WilsonDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House notes that the Nuffield Speech and Language Unit at the Royal Free Hospital is a national centre of excellence, providing diagnosis and treatment of hearing, speech and language disorders in children with needs that cannot be properly met by local provision; further notes that the Unit requires only 14 children to remain financially viable; expresses extreme concern that the distinct lack of referrals for the 2006-07 academic year may lead to the Unit's closure; believes that local NHS and neighbouring education authorities have failed to take enough proactive action to ensure the Unit is known about by parents, doctors and speech therapists; and urges the Government to do all it can to support the Unit and promote sufficient awareness to guarantee that the UK does not lose this important national resource.


1823COVENT GARDEN THEATRE MUSEUM15:3:06
John McDonnell
Peter Luff
Pete Wishart
Adam Price
Glenda Jackson
Alan Keen
* 36
 Dr Desmond TurnerMs Diane AbbottMr David Drew
 Mr Brian JenkinsSammy Wilson
   That this House pays tribute to the Theatre Museum in Covent Garden, which is London's only gallery devoted to the performing arts and which hosts one of the best theatre collections in the world; notes that the Heritage Lottery Fund has rejected its £2.5 million bid for funding for the second time; is gravely concerned at reports that the trustees of the museum are planning to close the collection; and calls upon the Government to intervene to save this valuable cultural asset.

As an Amendment to John McDonnell's proposed Motion (Covent Garden Theatre Museum):

Mr William Cash
Sir Michael Spicer [R]
* 2
Line 5, after collection, insert "calls upon the Trustees to defer their decision until the matter has been debated in Parliament and considered by the Select Committee on Culture Media and Sport"
21:3:06(a1)

[R] Relevant interest declared


1824FAIRTRADE FORTNIGHT15:3:06
Mr Andrew Mitchell
Mark Simmonds
Mr Francis Maude
Mr George Osborne
Mr William Hague
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 103
 Mrs Cheryl GillanMr David AmessDr Julian Lewis
 Mr Adrian SandersMr Brian JenkinsJeff Ennis
 Annette BrookeAndrew SelousMr David Anderson
 Mark WilliamsJo SwinsonAnne Milton
 Mr Christopher FraserMr Robert GoodwillMark Pritchard
   That this House congratulates the organisers of Fairtrade Fortnight on their success in raising awareness of Fairtrade products; celebrates Fairtrade as an example of how voluntary consumer choice in the developed world can generate real improvements in the lives of poor people; believes it is important that the momentum generated by Fairtrade Fortnight is carried forward and reflected in British government policy; and calls on the Government to push hard for the EU to table an ambitious offer on agriculture at the World Trade Organisation so as to break the deadlock in the Doha Round of trade talks and to secure a comprehensive deal on freeing up global trade.


1825KEPIER TRUST16:3:06
Mr Fraser Kemp
Bob Spink
Derek Conway
Jeremy Corbyn
John Cummings
Mr Martin Caton
* 11
 Mr Brian JenkinsMr David Anderson
   That this House welcomes plans to renovate and extend the Kepier, which was founded by Royal Charter in 1574 as the first school in Houghton-le-Spring, Tyne and Wear, and remained an educational establishment until after the First World War; notes that it is currently used by many local community groups and organisations especially to offer education to all, in keeping with the founders' wishes; further notes that a preliminary report recommends that work should commence on urgent repairs, renovations and to extend amenities; calls upon all hon. Members of the House and the local community in Houghton to back this worthwhile scheme being overseen by the Kepier Trust; and hopes that the Kepier will serve the community for another 432 years.


1826JOB LOSSES IN DUNDEE WEST16:3:06
Mr Jim McGovern
Mr Jim Devine
Anne Moffat
Jim Sheridan
Michael Connarty
Mr Mike Weir
* 59
 Dr Desmond TurnerMr Brian JenkinsClare Short
 Jeff EnnisHelen JonesMr Joe Benton
 Mr Martyn JonesPaul FlynnMrs Betty Williams
 Mr Frank DoranAnn McKechinMr David Hamilton
 Colin ChallenMr David AndersonKerry McCarthy
 Jo SwinsonMs Celia BarlowNia Griffith
 Mr John LeechJessica MordenWillie Rennie
   That this House is extremely concerned at the decision of Tesco to cut over 400 jobs in Dundee and to close its Dundee depot; notes that this was a unilateral decision taken without consultation with the trade unions, Scottish Enterprise Tayside, representatives from Dundee City Council, Dundee Chamber of Commerce nor the local politicians in Dundee; condemns this action as showing lack of respect to the city of Dundee; believes that the workers who are losing their jobs should either be relocated with the same terms and conditions of employment or offered an equitable redundancy package; supports the Union of Shop, Distributive and Allied Workers in its efforts to ensure this happens; and calls on Tesco to engage constructively with the unions and local politicians in order to salvage some positive outcome from this announcement.


1827PIPE ORGANS16:3:06
Tony Baldry
Bob Spink
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Derek Conway
Mr Michael Ancram
* 48
 Mr Bernard JenkinMr Mike HancockMr Humfrey Malins
 Richard OttawayMr Andrew LoveSteve Webb
 Mr Adrian SandersMr Robert WalterMr David Drew
 Mr Brian JenkinsMrs Betty WilliamsSir Robert Smith
 Paul HolmesAndrew SelousMr Shailesh Vara
 Mr Jim McGovernMr Adam HollowayMr Brian Binley
 Susan KramerAnne MainMr Edward Vaizey
   That this House is concerned at the threat to church pipe organs from the EU Directive on the Restriction of Hazardous Substances which will ban the use of lead in pipe organs and as from July will make it illegal to build new organ pipes or to move old ones from one church to another unless they are blown by hand; believes that such a ban will have a serious impact on England's cultural and liturgical life and will mean an end to English organ building; and calls on the Government to negotiate with the European Commission to find a way to protect traditional pipe organs for cathedrals, concert halls, colleges and churches.


1828LOANS TO POLITICAL PARTIES AND HONOURS16:3:06
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Lynne Jones
Glenda Jackson
Jeremy Corbyn
David Taylor
* 14
 Dr Vincent CableMr David DrewPaul Holmes
   That this House calls for the Electoral Commission to bring forward recommendations to provide for the declaration of loans to political parties, whether or not they are intended to be repaid, on the same basis as donations, including proposals for amendment of the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 if necessary; further calls for the Department for Constitutional Affairs to establish an inquiry to determine whether the recommendation of Mr Chai Patel for a peerage was linked to his provision of finance for the Labour Party and at what stage the Prime Minister, and other senior members of the Labour Party, were first informed of the loan from Mr Patel to the party; and urges the Committee for Standards in Public Life to consider both the status of loans to political parties and the relationship between political party funding and honours.


1829PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENTS FOR DEPRESSION16:3:06
Dr Evan Harris
Andrew George
Mike Penning
Mr Andrew Dismore
Peter Bottomley
Derek Conway
* 37
 Mr David DrewMr Brian JenkinsAndrew Stunell
 Paul HolmesMr John LeechDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House is concerned by the results of Pulse magazine's investigation into services for managing depression which revealed that patients are waiting many months for assessment and treatment; notes the acute shortage of therapists to deliver psychological interventions which are supported by good evidence of effectiveness, and that this shortage has been acknowledged by the National Director for Mental Health; urges the Government to instigate a concerted programme of training and recruitment to meet demand; and requests that GPs are provided with interim guidance on how to manage depression in the absence of access to interventions recommended by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.


1830INSTITUTE OF GRASSLAND AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH STATION AT GOGERDDAN16:3:06
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Adam Price
Hywel Williams
Pete Wishart
Stewart Hosie
Mr Angus MacNeil
* 19
 Mrs Betty WilliamsDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House notes the vital importance of the Institute of Grassland and Environmental Research (IGER) station at Gogerddan near Aberystwyth for the economy and research base of the area; recognises the station's international reputation and the historic and continuing excellence of its work in plant-breeding, animal science and nutrition and other agri-environmental research, and its importance in enabling farmers in Wales and elsewhere to meet the challenge of adaptation and diversification; further notes the unique status of IGER Gogerddan as the only research council-funded science research station in Wales; expresses its concern at the effect of the recently-announced reduction of £3 million per annum in funding by the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Areas (DEFRA) and the resultant loss of 40 jobs; is concerned at the potential threat to the station resulting from the possible merging of IGER with Rothamsted Research; and calls upon DEFRA and the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council, working with the Welsh Assembly Government, to ensure that the crucial role of IGER Gogerddan is maintained.


1831UNIVERSITY OF LEEDS FAIRTRADE STATUS16:3:06
Greg Mulholland
Andrew George
Mr Andrew Dismore
Mr Mike Weir
Peter Bottomley
Derek Conway
* 31
 Mr Brian JenkinsJeff EnnisAnnette Brooke
 Mr David AndersonJo SwinsonMr John Leech
   That this House congratulates the University of Leeds on achieving Fairtrade University status; praises the University, the Student Union and pays tribute to the efforts of both staff and students at the University for promoting and selling goods which ensure a fair deal for Fairtrade producers; further congratulates other organisations in Leeds for their commitment to the Leeds Fairtrade City initiative, including Leeds Metropolitan University who secured Fairtrade status in 2005; encourages other universities and colleges to achieve Fairtrade status; and recognises the important role this can play in improving the lives of producers in developing countries by promoting Fairtrade products.


1832PRESCRIPTION FOR CHANGE CAMPAIGN16:3:06
Steve Webb
Colin Challen
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Andrew George
Mike Penning
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 56
 Miss Ann WiddecombeMr Edward DaveyMr Adrian Sanders
 Mr David DrewMr Brian JenkinsClare Short
 Mr Austin MitchellMr Paul TruswellMrs Betty Williams
 Lembit ÖpikPaul HolmesAnnette Brooke
 Mr David AndersonJo SwinsonMr John Leech
 Tim Farron
   That this House supports Breast Cancer Care's `Prescription for change' campaign to raise awareness about the impact of prescription charges on cancer patients; is concerned at the campaign's findings that many breast cancer patients experience financial difficulty as a result of paying prescription charges; is further concerned that some breast cancer patients cannot afford to get their prescriptions dispensed and are therefore not taking the drugs they have been prescribed; and calls for an urgent review of the list of conditions that are exempt from prescription charges.


1833VICTORIA THEATRE, HALIFAX16:3:06
Mrs Linda Riordan
Lynne Jones
Bob Spink
Jeremy Corbyn
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 16
 Mr Brian Jenkins
   That this House supports the continued prosperity of traditional local theatres like the Victoria Theatre in Halifax; and welcomes the recent investment at the theatre which has enabled the venue to attract top name acts such as former Smiths front man Morrissey.


1834CRAIG ALDEN16:3:06
Tim Loughton
Mr Michael Fallon
Peter Bottomley
Derek Conway
Bob Spink
Mr Greg Hands
* 13
 Mr Mike HancockMr Brian JenkinsMr Shailesh Vara
   That this House notes with concern the case of Craig Alden, a British national detained in Brazil since July 2002; supports the ongoing efforts of Mr Alden's family and supporters to raise the profile of his case; and calls on the Government to give its fullest attention to his welfare.


1835CLOSURE OF SUSSEX UNIVERSITY'S CHEMISTRY DEPARTMENT16:3:06
Tim Loughton
Hon Nicholas Soames
Nick Herbert
Gregory Barker
Mr Nigel Waterson
Charles Hendry
* 31
 Mr Brian JenkinsMr Peter KilfoyleMs Celia Barlow
 Mr John Leech
   That this House expresses regret at Sussex University's decision to close its successful chemistry department despite being awarded a grade 5 rating under the Research Assessment Exercise (RAE) which monitors university standards and attracting academic staff of world renown, including two Nobel prize winners; notes the discrepancy between this closure and applications to the Sussex University chemistry course being 34 per cent. higher than the average increase in applications for university places; is alarmed that this closure is part of a worrying general trend in closure of chemistry departments nationally; is concerned that not enough is being done to reverse the decline in the number of applicants accepting places to study chemistry; and further notes that this decline in teaching physical sciences will have major detrimental effects on the future success of the UK's economy, its international competitiveness and on future scientific developments.


1836PURBECK ICE CREAM TASTING DAY16:3:06
Annette Brooke
Mr Robert Syms
Mr Tobias Ellwood
Mr Oliver Letwin
Mr Robert Walter
Mr Mike Weir
* 19
 Mr Brian JenkinsMark WilliamsJo Swinson
   That this House welcomes the decision of the House of Commons Refreshment Department to invite Purbeck Ice Cream to hold a tasting day in Portcullis House on 22nd March 2006; congratulates Purbeck Ice Cream on its award-winning innovative products; recognises the company's success in using local small-scale production based in Dorset; further welcomes the company's use of natural, GM-free ingredients without artificial or added colours; and encourages hon. Members and parliamentary staff to visit the tasting stand and try the distinctly different flavours and exceptional quality of this fresh, natural and wholesome Dorset made ice cream.


1837RACIAL SEGREGATION IN BARNSLEY16:3:06
Mr Eric Illsley
Jeff Ennis
Mr Michael Clapham
Mr Mike Hancock
* 4
   That this House rejects the findings of the State of the English Cities report commissioned by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister which labels the town of Barnsley the most racially segregated place in England; notes that the ethnic minority population of Barnsley is less than two per cent., about 4,000 people, the vast majority of whom live in the same area as the hon. Member for Barnsley Central in close proximity to Barnsley District General Hospital where many work; and calls upon the Government to reject this sensationalist, over-simplistic and statistically-flawed piece of work as an insult to the people of Barnsley and, in particular, to those there who work tirelessly to oppose racism and racial segregation.


1838STOP THE WAR CAMPAIGN16:3:06
Jeremy Corbyn
Adam Price
John McDonnell
Kelvin Hopkins
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Mr Michael Clapham
* 13
 Mr John Leech
   That this House welcomes the continued hard work of those dedicated to stopping all wars from within and without parliament via their efforts toward reversing the aggressive international policies initiated by the United States of America with British support and in particular to promote the demand to bring UK troops home from Iraq, as urged by many of the families of soldiers who have died in this unnecessary conflict; notes that on 18th March, the third anniversary of the attack on Iraq, another large anti-war demonstration organised by the Stop the War Coalition and supported by the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and the Muslim Association of Britain will take place in London while similar protests will take place on the streets of major cities thoughout the world, including Baghdad and Basra, in protest at the crisis in Iraq which is now on the verge of a civil war; calls for support for these protests; and further expresses grave concern at the plans to deploy thousands of British troops to Afghanistan in 2006 in support of another US-led occupation facing increasing resistance.


1839TELEPHONE BOXES16:3:06
Mr Nigel Evans
Derek Conway
Kate Hoey
Mr Eric Pickles
Mr Martyn Jones
Mr Philip Dunne
* 82
 Mr David AmessMr Mike HancockMr John Horam
 Mr David DrewMr Brian JenkinsJeff Ennis
 Frank CookMrs Betty WilliamsMr David Hamilton
 Angela WatkinsonHelen GoodmanDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House is greatly concerned about the new rules announced by Ofcom that could allow British Telecom to axe 6,000 telephone boxes without public consultation; calls on Ofcom to rescind the regulation that allows BT to remove phone boxes without consultation if there is another telephone box within 400 metres; notes that telephone boxes provide a vital service, especially in rural areas and during emergencies, and where there are often mobile phone coverage black spots; and recognises that not everyone has a mobile phone.


1840EUROPEAN UNION'S WATER INITIATIVE17:3:06
Mr David Burrowes
Emily Thornberry
Mr Don Foster
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Mrs Joan Humble
* 60
 Dr Desmond TurnerJoan RuddockRoger Berry
 Joan WalleyMr Brian JenkinsClare Short
 Richard BurdenLynne JonesJeff Ennis
 Mike WoodMrs Betty WilliamsLembit Öpik
 Mr Frank DoranMr Alex SalmondMichael Connarty
 Malcolm BruceAnn McKechinAnnette Brooke
 Mr David HamiltonPeter LawMr David Anderson
 Kerry McCarthyJo SwinsonRosie Cooper
 Sarah McCarthy-FryMr Edward VaizeyDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House notes with concern that 1.1 billion people do not have access to safe water and 2.6 billion people do not have access to adequate sanitation; further notes that the European Union's Water Initiative (EUWI), established in 2002 as the EU's main contribution to meeting the water and sanitation millennium development goals, has not yet made any of the policy or practice changes which would have helped extra people to receive access to water or sanitation; further notes that clear commitments to increase aid effectiveness generally have been made in the donors' Paris Declaration; and urges the Government to work with its European counterparts to push for a radical overhaul of the EUWI by incorporating into it the Paris Declaration agenda, setting measurable targets for better donor co-ordination in each country where the Initiative operates and by providing regular reports of progress at country level to ensure that more people really are gaining access to safe water and sanitation.


1841LEICESTER'S CARIBBEAN CARNIVAL17:3:06
Keith Vaz
Bob Spink
Jeremy Corbyn
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Martin Caton
* 17
 Ms Diane AbbottMr Brian JenkinsLynne Jones
 Mrs Betty WilliamsMr John Leech
   That this House notes with surprise and disappointment that Leicester's Caribbean Carnival, which has been running for 22 years and attracts over 100,000 visitors to Leicester each year, has been cancelled; further notes that it has been the biggest carnival of its kind outside London; recognises the part the carnival has played in making Leicester one of the leading multi-cultural cities in Europe; and hopes that the carnival will be able to return to Leicester in 2007.


1842PROSTATE CANCER AWARENESS WEEK17:3:06
Mr John Baron
Dr Howard Stoate
Tim Loughton
James Brokenshire
Peter Bottomley
Mr Nigel Waterson
* 66
 Dr Vincent CableMr Adrian SandersMr David Drew
 Mr Brian JenkinsLynne JonesJeff Ennis
 Andrew StunellMrs Betty WilliamsMr David Hamilton
 Jo SwinsonLynne FeatherstoneMr John Leech
 Tim FarronDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House congratulates The Prostate Cancer Charity, the largest UK voluntary organisation focused on prostate health, for organising Prostate Cancer Awareness Week which is running from 20th to 26th March; notes with concern new ICM research showing continued public uncertainty about the main risk factors for prostate cancer, particularly that one in four people over the age of 55 fail to identify increasing age as a key risk; welcomes the wide range of initiatives being taken during Prostate Cancer Awareness Week to focus public attention on the disease, including the distribution of three quarters of a million information leaflets and drinks mats, internet-based competitions and extensive community events; is encouraged by the planned public awareness pilot being jointly funded by the Department of Health and the Prostate Cancer Charter for Action, an influential voluntary sector campaigning group; and calls on the Government to roll out a national awareness campaign if the pilot proves successful.


1843SCOTTISH COMMONWEALTH GAMES MEDALLISTS17:3:06
Mr Angus MacNeil
Mr Alex Salmond
Mr Mike Weir
Angus Robertson
Stewart Hosie
Pete Wishart
* 26
 Mr Brian JenkinsLynne JonesMrs Betty Williams
 Dr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House congratulates Scottish gold medallists Caitlin McLatchey and David Carry on their achievement in the swimming events and bronze medallist Chris Hoy on his success in the one kilometre cycling time trial at the Melbourne Commonwealth Games; notes the positive effects this can have on domestic sport and the enhanced international profile of Scotland as a result of the participation of a Scottish representative team; commends all members of the Scotland team for the remainder of the Games; and recognises the efforts of all athletes from throughout the Commonwealth to make the Games a success.


1844JASON QUEALLY17:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Bob Laxton
Peter Bottomley
Mr Nigel Evans
Bob Spink
* 20
 David LepperMr Brian JenkinsLynne Jones
 Mrs Betty Williams
   That this House congratulates Jason Queally on winning a silver medal in the men's one kilometre time trial at the Commonwealth Games in Melbourne; pays tribute to his efforts in winning his third successive Commonwealth silver in the one kilometre cycling pursuit; expresses delight at the early successes of British athletes representing England, Scotland and Wales; and wishes them every success for the duration of the Games.


1845CHILDREN IN DETENTION17:3:06
Mr Neil Gerrard
Peter Bottomley
Andrew George
Glenda Jackson
Harry Cohen
Jeremy Corbyn
* 47
 Ms Diane AbbottJoan RuddockDr Vincent Cable
 Mr Colin BreedMr David DrewJoan Walley
 Lynne JonesMr Austin MitchellMr Paul Truswell
 Andrew StunellFrank CookMrs Betty Williams
 Malcolm BrucePaul HolmesMr Mark Field
 Annette BrookeHelen GoodmanMark Williams
 Jo SwinsonLynne FeatherstoneMr John Leech
 Tim FarronDr Alasdair McDonnell
   That this House is concerned by the detention of children in UK immigration detention centres as part of the standard immigration procedure; recognises the negative impact on children's mental and physical health and the disruption of their education; welcomes the work conducted by Save the Children, the Refugee Council, Bail for Immigration Detainees, the Scottish Refugee Council and the Welsh Refugee Council to bring an end to this unjust policy; supports their recommendations that children should be treated as children first and foremost and their needs and rights protected; calls for alternatives to detention to be piloted; and urges the Government to make detailed statistics available on an ongoing basis regarding the ages of, and numbers of, children held in detention and the length of time each is held in detention.


1846STAFFORDSHIRE AMBULANCE SERVICE No. 217:3:06
Charlotte Atkins
Dr Tony Wright
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr David Kidney
Mr Brian Jenkins
Mr Robert Flello
* 18
 Mr David Drew
   That this House recognises that Staffordshire Ambulance Service is the best performing ambulance service in the country with outstanding response times; believes that it should be seen as an exemplar of innovative public service; and further believes that there should be no question of it losing its operational independence or entering a merger with a regional ambulance service unless and until its performance is matched by others.


1847JOE CALZAGHE AND THE 2012 OLYMPICS20:3:06
Peter Law
Bob Spink
Mr Nigel Evans
Derek Conway
Mr Jim McGovern
Peter Bottomley
* 15
 Paul FlynnMr David Hamilton
   That this House congratulates Joe Calzaghe on winning his fight against Jeff Lacy on 5th March and thus unifying the WBO and IBF super-middleweight titles; believes his victory has brought pleasure to many boxing fans across the nation, and particularly in Newbridge in Blaenau Gwent, his home town; believes that if the United Kingdom is to continue to provide world sporting champions, particularly in the run up to the 2012 Olympic Games, then the sporting facilities for young people need to be improved through significant sporting infrastructure and training investment across the country; and looks forward to further world sporting champions coming from Wales.


184830th ANNIVERSARY OF SPORTSAID20:3:06
Mr Mark Lancaster
Mr Clive Betts
Mr Don Foster
Rosie Cooper
Dr Desmond Turner
Miss Ann Widdecombe
* 111
 Mr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet DeanJeff Ennis
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates SportsAid, the charity for sports people, on its 30th anniversary in 2006; acknowledges the £20 million distributed by the charity in this time; welcomes its relaunch in the regions through the roadshows taking place this year aiming to raise awareness of its mission and objectives; recognises the vital role it plays in funding future sports stars between the ages of 11 to 16 years when other forms of funding are unavailable; notes SportsAid's active role in the Government-backed Talented Athlete Scholarship Scheme providing the critical link between participation and excellence without which many emerging stars such as Shelley Rudman would have had to give up on their ambitions; understands the assistance that SportsAid gave to sporting legends such as Sir Steve Redgrave, Dame Kelly Holmes and Dame Tanni Grey-Thompson; acknowledges that SportsAid helped 15 of the 17 British Gold Medallists and over half the British Team at Athens 2004; believes that it is vital for the success of UK athletes at London 2012 and beyond to continue to receive financial assistance from SportsAid through public and private sector donations and associations; supports the role of SportsAid as a critical conduit for private sector funding to complement Government funding; and calls on all possible partners to support SportsAid in its work allowing young people to reach their full sporting potential.


1849SMALL SHOPS20:3:06
Dr Vincent Cable
Susan Kramer
Mr John Grogan
Mr Nigel Evans [R]
Jim Dowd
Mr Richard Shepherd
* 69
 Mr Andrew DismoreMr John HoramMrs Janet Dean
 Mr Ken PurchaseJeff EnnisSir Malcolm Rifkind
 Jo Swinson
   That this House values the diversity and choice offered by small independent and local shops in the face of the growing dominance of national chains; recognises the increasing difficulties that small independent and local shops are facing with large rent rises in town centres and high streets; applauds the Evening Standard's Save our Small Shops campaign; encourages the public to make use of small, independent, local shops; condemns those landlords who raise rent excessively, letting only to chain stores; urges consideration of new business conservation areas that cap the number of chain stores; supports the proposal for small shop loyalty card schemes for every borough; and urges simplification of the regulation to which small shops are obliged to adhere.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1850ANIMALS IN MEDICAL RESEARCH20:3:06
Dr Evan Harris
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr Jonathan Djanogly
Lynne Jones
Mr Alan Duncan
Bob Spink
* 33
 Laura MoffattJo Swinson
   That this House notes that UK regulation of animal research is among the tightest in the world, that animal research is only permitted where there is no better alternative and that pain and suffering are minimised and balanced against the potential benefit to humans and animals; recognises that good facilities enable scientists to conduct world-class research, potentially leading to new treatments for a number of life-threatening diseases, including leukaemia, heart disease, stroke, arthritis, cancer, diabetes and Parkinson's disease and that such research has already produced many lifesaving drugs including penicillin and other antibiotics, insulin for diabetes, chemotherapy for childhood leukaemia, and medicines for asthma, high blood pressure and ulcers; therefore supports the building of the new state of the art biomedical research laboratory at Oxford University, which will improve the facilities currently used to house research animals and so enhance animal welfare; applauds the Pro-Test movement in Oxford for their support of scientific research including animal based research; condemns unlawful animal rights extremism, including any violence, harassment or intimidation of those associated with lawful animal research; and supports the well-regulated use of animals in medical research.


1851SOCIAL SECURITY (S.I., 2006, No. 712)20:3:06
Sir Menzies Campbell
Mr David Laws
Danny Alexander
Jenny Willott
Sir Robert Smith
Andrew Stunell
* 24
 Mr Mark OatenMr Colin BreedMr Robert Walter
 Mr Peter KilfoyleMr Alan BeithJohn Thurso
 Dr John PughJo SwinsonLynne Featherstone
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Social Security Benefits Up-rating Regulations 2006 (S.I., 2006, No. 712), dated 9th March 2006, a copy of which was laid before this House on 16th March, be annulled.


1852NATIONAL OBESITY AWARENESS WEEK AND THE OBESITY AWARENESS AND SOLUTIONS TRUST20:3:06
Mr David Amess
Mr Kevin Barron
Jim Dowd
Dr Evan Harris
Mr David Burrowes
Dr Richard Taylor
* 43
 Laura MoffattMr Andrew DismoreDr Hywel Francis
   That this House notes that the annual Parliamentary Reception of The Obesity Awareness and Solutions Trust (TOAST) was held in the Terrace Marquee of the House on 15th March and attended by Right honourable and honourable Members from both Houses and all political parties, as well as by healthcare professionals, charities and various other organisations and stakeholders in this field; welcomes the annual National Obesity Awareness Week 2006 which began on 12th March designed to raise awareness of the multifaceted nature of obesity; congratulates TOAST on the valuable contribution it has made to the fight against obesity through its work, including running the National Help and Information line to support those living with obesity and their families and offering training courses to enable workers in public, private and volunteering sectors to develop the skills to recognise the issues relating to obesity and to provide the tools to manage them; invites the Department of Health to reconsider its decision not to assist TOAST with funding for such initiatives; and extends to TOAST its best wishes for continuing success in highlighting the scale and causes of obesity and in providing practical support for those who are overweight and obese.


1853FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION IN TURKEY20:3:06
Mr Martin Caton
Bob Spink
Rob Marris
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr Jim Devine
Peter Bottomley
* 29
 Mr Andrew DismoreMr Ken PurchasePaul Flynn
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates Amnesty International on its Turkey-Freedom of Expression campaign; recognises that the new Turkish penal code which came into force on 1st June 2005 includes many positive changes, including the removal of provisions that discriminated against women; is concerned however, that it has retained restrictions on freedom of expression, especially in Articles 301 and 305, that breach the European Convention on Human Rights; commends those Turkish writers, academics and human rights activists who continue to make the case for free speech; and urges the Turkish authorities to abolish those sections of the penal code that may lead to people being prosecuted for peacefully exercising their right to freedom of expression, as recognised in international law, and to release all prisoners arrested solely for the non-violent expression of their opinions.


1854F-35 JOINT STRIKE FIGHTER20:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Mr Bob Laxton
Jim Dobbin
Mr Nigel Evans
Mr Ben Wallace
* 21
 Mr Andrew DismoreDr Hywel Francis
   That this House notes with concern the decision taken by the Bush Administration to withhold from the UK access to top-secret stealth technology in the new F-35 joint strike fighter; further notes the decision taken by George Bush to cancel plans for a second engine which was to be jointly built by Rolls-Royce and GE; supports the statement made by Lord Drayson, Minister for Defence Procurement, that the UK would not buy the 150 aircraft it currently plans to order unless technology transfer takes place; and calls on the Government to ensure that it continues to place the interests of the UK aerospace sector at the forefront of its negotiations with the US Administration.

As an Amendment to Mr Lindsay Hoyle's proposed Motion (F-35 Joint Strike Fighter):

Nick Harvey
* 1
Line 7, leave out 'aerospace sector' and insert 'armed forces'.
21:3:06(a1)


1856TAIWAN AND THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANISATION21:3:06
Sir Nicholas Winterton
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Derek Conway
Derek Wyatt
* 14
 Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas
   That this House notes with regret that the World Health Organisation (WHO), at its World Health Assembly (WHA) meetings in Geneva in recent years, opposed including on the agenda Taiwan's participation in the WHA as an observer; believes that it is fully justifiable to invite Taiwan to participate in the WHA as an observer; welcomes the support given by the United States of America and Japan in recent years to Taiwan's participation in the WHA as an observer; further notes that the Government strongly supports the principle enshrined in the WHO constitution that the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of health is one of the fundamental rights of every human being; is disappointed that the Government has not supported Taiwan's participation in the WHA as an observer by arguing that there are difficulties over Taiwanese involvement in a United Nations forum, where statehood is a prerequisite for full membership, while ignoring the precedents that The Holy See, Palestine and the Sovereign Order of Malta have been granted observer status at WHA meetings; further welcomes the Explanation of Vote by the European Union at the WHA meeting in Geneva in May 2004; and strongly encourages the Government to support the request being made by Taiwan for observer status at the WHA and to ensure Taiwan's meaningful participation in the WHO.


1857COMMONWEALTH GAMES GOLD MEDAL FOR DEAN MACEY21:3:06
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Keith Vaz
Dr William McCrea
* 21
 Mr Nigel EvansPaul FlynnDavid Simpson
   That this House congratulates Castle Point's Dean Macey on winning an historic gold medal in the Commonwealth Games gruelling decathlon competition; recognises the strength of character and determination, over many years of training, that is necessary to deliver the ultimate success of a gold medal; and urges young athletes across the UK to follow in Dean's sporting tradition.


1858ESTATE AGENTS' VALUATIONS21:3:06
Mr Gregory Campbell
David Simpson
Mark Durkan
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Dr Rudi Vis
* 26
 Mrs Janet DeanJeff EnnisMr Nigel Evans
 Paul Flynn
   That this House notes that many estate agents across the UK carry out their business in a legal, justifiable and exemplary fashion; is concerned at the number of reported incidents involving a small number of estate agents who appear to be able to invent offers for properties and falsely inflate estimated valuations to enhance possible commissions; recognises the lack of regulation which exists in the industry; commends those reputable journalists who have helped expose some practices; and calls upon the Government to ascertain the extent of this activity and to implement such legislation as is necessary to prevent abuses of this type.


1859SAFE MOTHERHOOD CAMPAIGN21:3:06
Ms Sally Keeble
Chris McCafferty
Joan Ruddock
Andrew George
Mr David Kidney
Ann Winterton
* 75
 Mr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet DeanMr Ken Purchase
 Mr Paul TruswellMr Nigel EvansPaul Flynn
 Dr Hywel FrancisJo SwinsonMark Durkan
   That this House notes that 600,000 women die needlessly in childbirth every year, almost all of them in developing countries; supports the call to action by the World Health Organisation and Commonwealth Secretariat to improve maternity services worldwide; and calls on the UK Government to press for securely funded health systems worldwide with universal coverage of critical health interventions for women and girls, an end to financial barriers in accessing healthcare and respect for women's decisions in all matters relating to their health and well-being.


1860EARLY RELEASE OF PRISONERS21:3:06
David T. C. Davies
Mr John Hayes
Mr Peter Bone
Bob Spink
Philip Davies
Mr Stewart Jackson
* 13
 Mr Nigel Evans
   That this House notes with grave concern that numerous violent offences are committed by prisoners who have been released under early release schemes; recognises that there is little public awareness that most prisoners in the UK serve half or less of the sentence that was passed down to them by the Court; further notes that press reports of crimes committed by prisoners on early release have undermined confidence in the justice system; congratulates newspapers such as The Sun which have campaigned to bring this issue to the wider attention of the public; and calls on the Government to end all forms of early release on licence and to give assurances that all sentences will be served in full.


1861NATURAL HEALTH WEEK21:3:06
Dr Brian Iddon
Mr Mark Todd
Richard Younger-Ross
David Taylor
Jim Dobbin
Ann Winterton
* 44
 Laura MoffattMr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet Dean
 Jeff EnnisMr Nigel EvansPaul Flynn
 Dr Hywel FrancisJo Swinson
   That this House notes the launch of Natural Health Week that will be held from 27th March to promote awareness of the contribution that natural health products can make in helping people to achieve and maintain optimum health; further notes that the project has the active support of the National Association of Health Stores, Consumers for Health Choice and the publishers of Health Food Business Magazine; and urges the Department of Health and the Food Standards Agency to continue their dialogue with the natural health sector in order further to improve public health, enhance quality of life, and reduce burdens on the National Health Service.


1862WITHDRAWAL OF ERYTHROPOIETIN AS A TREATMENT FOR CANCER THERAPY INDUCED ANAEMIA21:3:06
Mr Dai Havard
Dr Brian Iddon
David T. C. Davies
Andrew Mackinlay
Andrew George
Mr Stephen Crabb
* 35
 Mr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet DeanMr Nigel Evans
   That this House is dismayed at the final recommendation, subject to appeal, from the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) to withdraw erythropoietin (EPOs) as an approved treatment for cancer induced anaemia; notes that this decision will have a hugely detrimental effect on the quality of life of UK cancer sufferers, interfering with courses of cancer treatment and undermining the National Cancer Plan; understands that blood transfusions are the only suitable alternative for treatment; is concerned that this decision is in direct contravention of the Chief Medical Officer's advice that alternatives to blood transfusions should be sought due to the UK's already restricted blood supply; and calls upon the Secretary of State for Health and NICE to consider the wider implications of how supportive care drugs and therapies should be reviewed to give UK patients access to a treatment that is an accepted standard of care across Europe.


1864INSTITUTE FOR GRASSLAND AND ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH21:3:06
Mark Williams
Mr Roger Williams
Lembit Öpik
Jenny Willott
Peter Bottomley
Mr Martin Caton
* 20
 Dr Hywel FrancisJo Swinson
   That this House salutes the importance of the vision of the Institute for Grassland and Environmental Research (IGER) in its work to develop economically viable and sustainable dairy and beef systems based on high forage diets, minimising the impact of livestock farming systems on the environment, protecting and enhancing biodiversity, and helping to contribute important health benefits to the United Kingdom consumer; pays tribute also to the work of IGER in researching the potential of crops for energy, and recognises the significant contribution that manipulating animal diets and obtaining energy from biomass could make to reducing methane and carbon dioxide emissions; is therefore concerned to learn that 40 posts could soon be cut at the IGER which will have a significant impact on the ability of IGER to deliver much needed environmental research across the entire grassland-based, land-use sector; and calls on the Government to reconsider its decision to withdraw funding from IGER leaving a £2 million shortfall for the financial year 2006-07.


1865WEST LOTHIAN DISTRICT COUNCIL21:3:06
Mr Jim Devine
Michael Connarty
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Martin Caton
Alan Simpson
Lynne Jones
* 13
 Mr Ken PurchaseJeff EnnisPaul Flynn
 Mr David Hamilton
   That this House congratulates West Lothian District Council for being voted Great Britain's best performing council; and further congratulates Grahame Morrice, the council leader, and fellow councillors, Alex Linkston, Chief Executive, and staff for this magnificent achievement.


1866CHELMSFORD AWARD OF FAIRTRADE STATUS21:3:06
Mr Simon Burns
Mr Mark Francois
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr Mike Weir
Dr Rudi Vis
* 20
 Mr Ken PurchaseJeff EnnisMr Nigel Evans
 Jo Swinson
   That this House congratulates the town of Chelmsford in achieving Fairtrade status; notes that Chelmsford was the first town in Essex and only the third in the Eastern region to be awarded Fairtrade status, and that recently this status was renewed for a second year; welcomes the firm commitment by Chelmsford Borough Council together with numerous local organisations, retailers, schools, universities, churches, faith groups and charities in supporting the extension of Fairtrade products and outlets throughout the town; further congratulates Chelmsford High Street, Anglia Ruskin University, Chelmsford Cathedral, Writtle College and Essex County Council offices for their work and dedication in hosting Fairtrade events; and urges the Government to assist Fairtrade campaigns throughout the UK to encourage consumers to provide practical help to poor producers in the developing world and in continuing to call for fairer trade terms for the world's poorest nations.


1867NEWSFAX AND THE LONDON DEVELOPMENT AGENCY21:3:06
Derek Wyatt
Peter Bottomley
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Martin Caton
Keith Vaz
Jim Dowd
* 14
 Jeremy CorbynMr Austin Mitchell
   That this House understands that the London Development Agency (LDA) has so far failed to reach agreement over compensation with Newsfax, the largest manufacturing employer in the area with 450 staff, nearly half of whom come from ethnic minorities and a further 1,000 among suppliers reliant upon the company; notes that the company is subject to a compulsory purchase order as a result of the successful London 2012 Olympic and Paralympic bid; is concerned by the fact that unless the LDA advances funds to the company before 31st March 2006, Newsfax will be unable to transfer its business to a new site by July 2007, the date by which the LDA requires vacant possession; is further concerned that the LDA is suggesting closure of part of the business with the loss of 200 staff, rather than relocation of the whole operation; and strongly urges the LDA to reach an agreement with Newsfax as soon as possible.


1868PENSION SHORTFALLS21:3:06
Sandra Osborne
Mr Frank Field
Rosemary McKenna
Jim Sheridan
Mr David Crausby
Mr Brian H. Donohoe
* 52
 Mr Mark OatenMr Peter LilleyJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Ken PurchaseJeff EnnisPaul Flynn
 Dr William McCreaMr David HamiltonMark Durkan
   That this House believes that the first call on the unclaimed assets of banks and building societies should be to make good the pensions shortfall of those workers not covered by the Pensions Protection Fund.


1870HIGHER EDUCATION IN LONDON21:3:06
Jim Dowd
Bob Spink
Dr Rudi Vis
Harry Cohen
Keith Vaz
Stephen Williams
* 13
 Paul Flynn
   That this House believes that London enjoys a first class higher education sector which generates four per cent. of London's gross domestic product and is well placed to be the knowledge capital of the world; notes that London attracts 65,000 international students from over 200 countries who study and live in the capital; further notes that London provides first class education for over 350,000 students, producing over 66,000 highly qualified employees each year; recognises that these employees generate as much as £11.7 billion during their working lives; further notes that higher education institutions in London employ 58,000 staff and that each of these jobs generates another elsewhere in the UK economy; acknowledges the role played by London's higher education institutions in helping to secure London's 2012 Olympic bid; welcomes the work undertaken by organisations such as London Higher in promoting higher education in London; and calls on hon. Members to support London Higher and London's higher education institutions in their work for the capital and England.


1871MEDALS FOR SCOTTISH ATHLETES IN THE COMMONWEALTH GAMES22:3:06
Mr Angus MacNeil
Mr Alex Salmond
Angus Robertson
Pete Wishart
Mr Mike Weir
Stewart Hosie
* 19
 Dr Rudi VisDr Hywel FrancisDavid Simpson
   That this House congratulates Scotland swimmers David Carry, Gregor Tait, Caitlin McLatchey, Euan Dale, Kirsty Balfour, Craig Houston, Todd Cooper, Robbie Renwick and Kris Gilchrist on their achievements in the swimming events, Chris Hoy, Ross Edgar, Craig Maclean, James McCallum and Kate Cullen on their success in the veledrome and Sheena Smart, Susan Jackson, Neil Stirton and Martin Sinclair on their prowess in the shooting events at the Melbourne Commonwealth Games; notes the positive effects such success can have on domestic sport and the enhanced international profile of Scotland as a result of the participation of a Scottish representative team; commends all members of the Scotland team for the remainder of the Games; and recognises the efforts of all athletes from throughout the Commonwealth to make the Games a success.


1872CHRIS BAILLIE'S MEDAL FOR SCOTLAND IN THE COMMONWEALTH GAMES22:3:06
Mr Angus MacNeil
Mr Alex Salmond
Angus Robertson
Pete Wishart
Mr Mike Weir
Stewart Hosie
* 16
 Dr Rudi Vis
   That this House congratulates Chris Baillie on winning the silver medal in the 110 metre hurdles at the Melbourne Commonwealth Games, noting in particular his achievement in the heats of breaking the Scottish national record in the event, previously held by his late brother, Ross; and looks forward to further success in track and field events for Scottish athletes before a home crowd when Glasgow secures the 2014 Games.


1873PROTOCOL 5 OF THE CONVENTION ON CONVENTIONAL WEAPONS22:3:06
Frank Cook
Andrew George
Harry Cohen
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Weir
Alan Simpson
* 26
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMrs Janet DeanPaul Flynn
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House recognises the serious post-conflict humanitarian problems caused by explosive remnants of war (ERW) and is conscious of the need to minimise the risks and effects of ERW; notes the significant contribution made by the UK to date in post-conflict clearance of ERW but is deeply concerned that despite an assurance made by the Minister of State for the Armed Forces in April 2004 that the UK would aim to ratify Protocol 5 of the Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW) by the end of 2004, the Protocol has still not been ratified; believes that the UK should be one of the first 20 nations to ratify Protocol 5 of the CCW to set an example to other state parties; and therefore calls upon the Government to ratify the Protocol at the earliest opportunity.


1874TEST MATCH VICTORY22:3:06
Mr Sadiq Khan
Andrew George
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Derek Conway
Peter Bottomley
Tim Loughton
* 24
 Dr Rudi VisJeremy CorbynMr Colin Breed
 Mr Nigel EvansMr Jim Devine
   That this House congratulates the England cricket team on its superb performance in the Third Test Match against India, achieving its first victory in the country since 1984-85; recognises that this result ensures that England remains second in the International Cricket Council Test rankings, which will act as an additional boost to the popularity of cricket in this country; and commends both teams involved in a thoroughly competitive series.


1875ENERGY PRICES22:3:06
Jim Dobbin
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Andrew George
Derek Conway
Peter Bottomley
* 38
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMrs Janet DeanJeff Ennis
 Mr Paul TruswellDr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House notes that all major domestic energy suppliers have implemented significant consumer price increases in response to rising wholesale gas costs; further notes the recent European Commission report which found that anti-competitive practices by continental energy companies are keeping UK wholesale prices artificially high; welcomes the Government's commitment to ensure market abuses on the continent are tackled in order to bring prices down; further notes with concern that vulnerable people will be most affected by rising energy prices; and calls on all energy suppliers in the UK to follow the lead set by British Gas and EDF Energy to introduce social tariffs for their most vulnerable customers to mitigate the worst effects of recent rises.


1876SEVERN TIDAL BARRAGE22:3:06
Stephen Williams
Martin Horwood
Andrew George
Peter Bottomley
Alan Simpson
Mr Martin Caton
* 19
 Dr Rudi VisMr Colin BreedMrs Janet Dean
 Mr Ken PurchaseJeff EnnisPaul Flynn
   That this House notes that the problem of global warming is the greatest environmental threat the world has ever seen; further notes that the long proposed Severn Tidal Barrage would generate an estimated six per cent. of the UK's current energy needs, leaving the UK less dependent on nuclear power, coal or foreign oil for energy production; further notes that the barrage would generate 2,000 MW of renewable, green energy per year, equivalent to three nuclear power stations, or 10 million tonnes of coal; further notes that the proposed barrage was blocked in previous decades primarily by environmental concerns in the estuary, but that those concerns pre-dated the realisation of the numerous and consequential environmental problems now faced from global warming, many of which would be countered by the barrage; and urges the Government to include a serious reappraisal of the barrage, including an environmental impact study, as part of its Energy Review.


1877UK SWIMMERS AT THE COMMONWEALTH GAMES22:3:06
Alison Seabeck
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Derek Conway
Peter Bottomley
Laura Moffatt
Derek Wyatt
* 36
 John AustinDr Rudi VisMr Don Foster
 Mr Nigel EvansMs Dari TaylorPaul Flynn
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr David HamiltonJulia Goldsworthy
 Meg HillierMs Celia BarlowMs Diana R. Johnson
 Stephen Hammond
   That this House congratulates the swimming teams from the countries of the United Kingdom on their brilliant success, medal winning performances and personal best times at the Commonwealth Games in Melbourne, Australia; and acknowledges the progress being made by swimmers, their clubs and coaches, as the 2012 Olympics approach.


1878PENSIONER TRAVEL22:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David S. Borrow
Geraldine Smith
Mr Mark Hendrick
Rosie Cooper
Alan Simpson
* 18
 Dr Rudi VisJeremy CorbynKitty Ussher
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House notes with concern the inability of the 12 district authorities in Lancashire to reach an agreement so that pensioners can travel free on buses during off peak hours throughout Lancashire following the Government's scheme for free off peak bus travel within borough boundaries due to start this year; further notes the failure of Stagecoach to ensure that all buses are equipped with the necessary machinery for the new swipe card system by April, resulting in a delay in the implementation of free local bus travel for pensioners in Lancashire; pays tribute to the Chancellor of the Exchequer for announcing free off-peak national bus travel for all pensioners from 2008; and calls on the Government to work with the district authorities in Lancashire to ensure that reciprocal agreements are entered into and pensioners travel free across the county so that pensioners are not penalised for the next two years until the Chancellor's new national scheme is introduced.


1879COUNCIL TAX ASSISTANCE FOR PENSIONERS22:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Harry Cohen
Alan Simpson
Mr Martin Caton
Mr David Drew
* 15
 Jeremy CorbynJeff Ennis
   That this House warmly welcomes the Chancellor's Budget, which includes an extra £585 million for schools, free national bus travel for pensioners and increases in Child Tax Credit; calls on the Chancellor to look again at his decision not to provide assistance to pensioners to pay council tax bills, many of whom struggle on fixed incomes to pay the increases in their council tax; and calls on the Chancellor to re-introduce the £100 payment to all pensioners to assist them in paying their council tax.

As an Amendment to Mr Lindsay Hoyle's proposed Motion (Council Tax Assistance for Pensioners):

David Taylor
Jim Dobbin
Mark Durkan
Paul Flynn
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 7
Mrs Janet Dean
Line 5, leave out `£100' and insert `£200'.
23:3:06(a1)


1880SUPPORT FOR SHORT SEA AND WATERWAY SHIPPING22:3:06
Gwyn Prosser
Mr Michael Howard
Paul Rowen
Derek Conway
Peter Bottomley
Alan Simpson
* 32
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMrs Janet DeanMr Ken Purchase
 Mr Bob LaxtonMrs Gwyneth DunwoodyPaul Flynn
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the publication of the Case for Water report by Sea and Water; acknowledges that Sea and Water call not for long-term subsidy for the water freight sector but a level playing field for all transport modes; recognises that the water freight industry makes a major contribution to the UK's economy, employs more than 200,000 people and has the potential to boost the employment of British seafarers and shore staff; notes that moving freight by water is environmentally sustainable and takes lorries off the congested road network; believes that, with proper political encouragement, the water freight sector can meet growing demand; acknowledges that the Government's proposed system of road pricing will enable the true cost of road freight transport to be paid, but that until this is instituted water freight should be supported and helped by easing the tortuous planning procedures; and calls on the Government to back the water freight industry with policies to develop and maintain the inland waterway network and allow the appropriate expansion of UK ports.


1881PRIVATISATION OF INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY IN THE MINISTRY OF DEFENCE22:3:06
John McDonnell
Mr Mike Hancock
Mrs Betty Williams
Mr Neil Gerrard
Harry Cohen
Mr Mike Weir
* 31
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMr Ken PurchaseJeff Ennis
 Chris McCaffertyPaul FlynnMr Jim Devine
   That this House expresses its concern at the proposals of the Defence Information Initiative to award the bulk of a £1 billion contract for the provision of IT support and infrastructure in the Ministry of Defence (MoD) without going through a full competitive tendering process or consideration of an in-house bid; notes that the major company within the ATLAS consortium is EDS, a company with a long history of failure in delivering public sector IT projects; believes that as the current MoD contract involves battlefield deployed and secret military IT systems any failure with these systems could have a devastating effect on UK military operations; and therefore calls on the Secretary of State to ensure that the rest of the contract specifically dealing with IT support is subject to a full risk analysis and full competitive tendering process, including consideration of an in-house option.


1882ATTACKS ON MEMBERS OF CONGRESS IN THE PHILIPPINES22:3:06
Mr Neil Gerrard
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Peter Bottomley
Alan Simpson
Mr Martin Caton
Dr John Pugh
* 39
 Alan KeenDr Rudi VisJohn McDonnell
 Mr Andrew DismoreJeremy CorbynMr John Grogan
 Chris McCaffertyColin BurgonJon Trickett
 Mr Nigel EvansPaul FlynnMichael Connarty
 Dr Hywel FrancisMr John MacDougallJon Cruddas
 Anne MoffatMr Dai HavardJim Sheridan
 Rosie CooperMs Katy ClarkMr Jim Devine
   That this House notes with serious concern the detention of opposition politicians and trade union and community leaders during the recent State of Emergency declared by President Arroyo in the Philippines (Presidential Proclamation 1017); notes that many of those arrested remain in detention despite the lifting of the State of Emergency, and in particular Congress member Crispin Beltran, who is 73 years old and a long-time trade union leader and representative of workers and farmers in the Philippine Congress; notes with concern that five other members of the House of Representatives (Satur Ocampo, Teodor Casino, Joel Virador, Liza Maza and Rafael Mariano) are unable to leave the Congress building, which is surrounded by police under orders to arrest them, despite the fact that no judge has issued any arrest warrant; notes the rising number of disappearances and killings of trade union and community leaders in the Philippines, including Napoleon Pornasdoro, Secretary of the Teachers' Alliance in Southern Luzon, who was gunned down on 28th February, immediately after he criticised the government's proclamation of a State of Emergency; and urges the Government to express to President Arroyo and the government of the Philippines its deep concern at the ongoing attacks on human rights in the Philippines, the continued detention of Congressman Crispin Beltran, and the current harassment of senior opposition politicians.


1883OFFSHORING OF GOVERNMENT CONTRACT JOBS IN NATIONAL SAVINGS AND INVESTMENTS22:3:06
John McDonnell
Jim Cousins
Mrs Joan Humble
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Dr Gavin Strang
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
* 36
 Dr Rudi VisJeremy CorbynMr Colin Breed
 Mrs Janet DeanJeff EnnisPaul Flynn
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House is gravely concerned by the proposal by Siemens to offshore 240 Government contract jobs in National Savings and Investments (NS&I) to India; notes that this is the second proposal by Siemens to offshore NS&I work and that when the Government agreed the offshoring of 240 NS&I jobs in 2004 it did so on the basis that there would be no redundancies amongst the UK workforce, and on the agreement that the Minister retained his right to exercise a veto on any future proposals; further notes that the proposal would result in one-third of NS&I work being delivered from overseas and that the only rationale for the proposal is the far cheaper labour costs in India; believes that there will be no benefit to the Government or taxpayer; is concerned that if the Government agrees to this proposal it will be setting a dangerous precedent for public services for other Government contractors to offshore work; believes that this will have serious consequences for the service and the workforce; and therefore strongly urges the Government to veto this proposal.


1884SALE OF FINANCIAL PRODUCTS22:3:06
Lorely Burt
Mr John Greenway
Mr Andrew Love
Derek Conway
Peter Bottomley
Mr Mike Weir
* 32
 Dr Rudi VisJeremy CorbynMr Colin Breed
 Mrs Janet DeanPaul FlynnStephen Williams
 Lynne Featherstone
   That this House recognises the importance of life insurance and protection products in helping families to cope financially with the loss of income following bereavement, ill-health or unemployment; acknowledges the need to ensure that when purchasing such products providers take into consideration the consumer's personal circumstances and the suitability of the product being sold; notes with growing concern the dramatic increase in recent years in the sale of life insurance and other protection products on a non-advised basis and the subsequent potential for large scale mis-buying; is concerned by the general lack of consumer awareness that purchasing such products without advice may restrict their ability to seek redress where products are later found to be unsuitable; and therefore calls on the Government to take action to require those selling without advice to act responsibly by making clear the possible limitations of their product in the context of the other options available, and posting clearer consumer warnings prior to the purchase of protection products highlighting the impact of non-advised sales on the level of consumer protection offered.


1885ST GEORGE'S DAY23:3:06
Rob Marris
Bob Spink
Mr John Leech
David Taylor
Derek Wyatt
Mr Greg Knight
* 14
 Mr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet DeanMr Martin Caton
 Stephen WilliamsPhilip Davies
   That this House believes that St. George's Day, 23rd April, should henceforth each year be a bank holiday in England.


1886Mr ABDUL RAHMAN23:3:06
Andrew Selous
Mr Tom Harris
Dr John Pugh
Mr Desmond Swayne
Mr Nigel Dodds
Andrew Miller
* 35
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMr David DrewMrs Janet Dean
 Mr Martin CatonJo SwinsonMr David Burrowes
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House expresses its profound concern that Mr Abdul Rahman is facing the death penalty in Afghanistan after being charged with converting from Islam to Christianity; calls on the Afghan government to respect both its own constitution which guarantees its citizens' rights to choose their own faith and the international human rights treaties, which also guarantee this right which Afghanistan has signed; and calls on the Government to make immediate representation to the Afghan government on this matter, given the UK's significant financial and military support for Afghanistan.


1887DEATH OF MARGARET EWING, MSP23:3:06
Mr Alex Salmond
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Mr Tom Clarke
Mrs Eleanor Laing
Jo Swinson
Angus Robertson
* 62
 Jeremy CorbynMr Colin BreedJeff Ennis
 Paul FlynnMr Martin CatonMiss Anne Begg
 Michael ConnartyDr Hywel FrancisDavid Simpson
   That this House celebrates the lifetime achievements of Margaret Ewing, MSP for Moray and former Parliamentary Leader of the Scottish National Party; recognises her substantial contribution to parliamentary and public life; and expresses heartfelt condolences to her family and many friends.


1888CARE OF OLDER PEOPLE23:3:06
Joan Walley
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Roger Berry
Mr Edward O'Hara
Dr John Pugh
* 39
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMr David DrewMrs Janet Dean
 Jeff EnnisChris McCaffertyPaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonDr William McCrea
 Dr Hywel FrancisStephen WilliamsDavid Simpson
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the Channel 4 documentary series The Trouble with Old People, to be screened in the week of 27th March 2006, which tackles the issue of care for older people; is deeply concerned about the lack of community-based support to enable older people to stay at home; notes that two thirds of people living in care homes have dementia; calls on the Government to develop strategies for supporting vulnerable older people with dementia to live at home and to improve access to primary care services for people in long-term care; welcomes the White Paper, Our Health, Our Care, Our Say on health and social care and its commitment to provide training for staff looking after people at the end of their lives; urges the Government to ensure that this commitment extends to training for those in care homes; further welcomes the Government's commitment in the White Paper to emergency respite for carers; and further calls on the Government to commit itself to a timetable for implementation of these policies as soon as possible and to ensure adequate funding.


1889WORLD STOP TUBERCULOSIS DAY AND TUBERCULOSIS ALERT CAMPAIGN23:3:06
Keith Vaz
John Barrett
Tony Baldry
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
* 38
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mrs Janet DeanChris McCaffertyMr Paul Truswell
 Sir Nicholas WintertonPaul FlynnMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin CatonMichael ConnartyDr William McCrea
 Dr Hywel FrancisAnn McKechinJo Swinson
 David SimpsonMr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes World Stop TB Day on 24th March 2006; congratulates TB Alert, on its campaigns to raise awareness of TB; further congratulates all other groups working to tackle this serious disease; notes that TB leads to 1.75 million deaths worldwide every year from a curable disease; welcomes the launch of the Global Ten Year Plan to Stop TB and endorses its aim to save 14 million lives by 2015; looks forward to major British contributions to achieving this aim; regrets that despite continuing developments in the diagnosis and treatment of TB, annual incidence in the UK has increased by 33 per cent. over the past decade; looks forward to the forthcoming guidelines from the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence on clinical diagnosis and management of tuberculosis in the United Kingdom; and hopes that this document will provide accurate and comprehensive guidance, detailing the most advanced testing regimes available to health professionals.


1890SCOTLAND'S AIRPORTS23:3:06
John Barrett
Mr Frank Doran
Mr Ian Davidson
Mrs Ann Cryer
Jim Sheridan
Ann McKechin
* 9
 Dr Rudi VisJo SwinsonMr Jim Devine
   That this House recognises the efforts being made to increase the number of international visitors to Scotland and acknowledges the importance of Scottish business in an increasingly global and competitive market; believes a key factor in achieving these aims is the provision of direct international flights to and from Scotland; and believes the effective branding and marketing of Scotland's international image is critical in attracting new international routes and new foreign visitors and that this work is supported by keeping Scotland's main airports named after the cities they serve, each of which has proud individual brands in its own right, brands that are recognised throughout the world.


1891WORLD TB DAY AND THE GLOBAL PLAN TO STOP TB CAMPAIGN23:3:06
John Barrett
Mr Andrew Mitchell
Keith Vaz
Nick Herbert
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
* 41
 Kelvin HopkinsDr Rudi VisMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynMr Colin BreedMr David Drew
 Mrs Janet DeanJeff EnnisChris McCafferty
 Sir Nicholas WintertonPaul FlynnMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin CatonAnn McKechinStephen Williams
 Jo SwinsonMr Stewart JacksonLorely Burt
 Stephen Hammond
   That this House acknowledges in the run up to World TB day that each year nearly two million people die and nine million become sick with TB despite the disease being both preventable and curable; recognises that TB is a global pandemic and an emergency in Africa and Eastern Europe; further notes that TB is the biggest killer of people with HIV/AIDS; welcomes the launch of the Global Plan to Stop TB 2006 to 2015 which if implemented will lead to 14 million more lives being saved over the next decade and Millennium Development Goal targets on TB being met; and calls upon the UK Government to contribute to the development and financing of the Global Plan.


1892FAIRTRADE CAMPAIGN IN UNIVERSITIES23:3:06
John Barrett
Mark Lazarowicz
Bob Russell
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Dr Brian Iddon
* 41
 Kelvin HopkinsLaura MoffattDr Rudi Vis
 Mr Andrew DismoreJeremy CorbynMr Colin Breed
 Mr David DrewMrs Janet DeanMr Ken Purchase
 Jeff EnnisChris McCaffertyMr Paul Truswell
 Mr Nigel EvansPaul FlynnMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin CatonDr Hywel FrancisMr David Hamilton
 Stephen WilliamsJo SwinsonLynne Featherstone
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House congratulates the National Union of Students Services Limited (NUSSL), the buying consortium for NUS affiliated students' unions, on its decision to become 100 per cent. Fairtrade for hot beverages subject to approval at the forthcoming NUSSL Annual General Meeting; supports moves by the National Union of Students (NUS) to encourage its entire membership to opt-in to Fairtrade status; recognises that Edinburgh University Students' Association along with others has submitted a motion to NUS Annual Conference supporting this move; notes that the motion will allow the NUS to encourage all student unions to embrace Fairtrade and ensure that the millions of students across the UK will drink Fairtrade products as the default in their unions; further recognises the importance of Fairtrade products for securing a fair deal for farmers in developing countries; and calls on the Government to continue to do all it can to support the continued growth of the Fairtrade market in the UK.


1893PARLIAMENTARY OMBUDSMAN'S REPORT ON OCCUPATIONAL PENSIONS23:3:06
Mr David Laws
Danny Alexander
Sandra Gidley
Jenny Willott
Dr Vincent Cable
Bob Spink
* 36
 Dr Evan HarrisMr Don FosterMr Colin Breed
 Mr Alan BeithPaul FlynnMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Dr William McCreaMr Mike WeirStephen Williams
 Jo SwinsonLynne FeatherstoneTim Farron
 David SimpsonWillie Rennie
   That this House notes the Parliamentary Ombudsman's recent report on occupational pensions; further notes the Ombudsman's conclusion that Government information on occupational pensions was `inaccurate, incomplete, unclear and inconsistent'; expresses its concern for all those who have lost their hard-earned pensions; and calls upon the Government to respond to the Ombudsman's clear recommendations and bring forward urgently proposals to offer reasonable compensation to those who have lost out.


1894UNIVERSITY PARTICIPATION23:3:06
Ms Dari Taylor
Dr Doug Naysmith
Rob Marris
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr David Anderson
Vera Baird
* 38
 Kelvin HopkinsDr Rudi VisMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynMrs Janet DeanJeff Ennis
 Chris McCaffertyAndrew MillerHelen Jones
 Paul FlynnMrs Betty WilliamsJulie Morgan
 Mr Martin CatonDr Hywel FrancisMr Dai Havard
 Mr Kevan JonesChris BryantStephen Williams
 Mr Jamie ReedMs Diana R. JohnsonAlison Seabeck
 Mr Robert Flello
   That this House applauds the success of the university sector; recognises the vital contribution universities make to economic, cultural and intellectual well-being; believes that the expansion of higher education has been generally a good thing for individuals and for society; supports the principle that all those who have the ability should have the right to access higher education; regrets that the opportunities and advantages arising from a university education are still not accessed equitably by students from poorer and less traditional backgrounds; rejects the proposition that growing numbers of those entering higher education are not, or will not, benefit from it; notes in particular that there will be an increased need to support opportunities to access higher education by mature full-time and part-time undergraduates as the number of 18 year olds declines after 2010; recognises that any policy which had reduction of participation in higher education as an objective would undermine individual opportunity, capacity for regional regeneration, innovation and the development of a professional and skilled workforce and would run directly counter to the expansionist higher education policies being pursued and funded by China and other emerging, competitor economies; and urges the Government to re-state the economic case for funding improved participation in higher education.

As an Amendment to Ms Dari Taylor's proposed Motion (University Participation):

Mr Robert N. Wareing
* 1
Line 16, at the end add `; and looks forward to the day when tuition fees and top-up fees are abolished.'.
28:3:06(a1)


1895TESTING THE NATION'S HEARTS CAMPAIGN23:3:06
Mr Andrew Lansley
Dr Doug Naysmith
Steve Webb
Mr David Amess
Sandra Gidley
Laura Moffatt
* 42
 Kelvin HopkinsDr Julian LewisTim Loughton
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMrs Janet DeanChris McCafferty
 Sir Nicholas WintertonMr Nigel EvansPaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonDr William McCrea
 Stephen WilliamsJo SwinsonDavid Simpson
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House is concerned that cardiovascular disease (CVD) remains the main cause of death in the UK, killing more people than cancer and accounting for four out of 10 of all deaths; notes that raised cholesterol can increase the risk of heart disease and that raised blood pressure is a major risk factor in strokes; further notes that the cost to the NHS in treating high cholesterol levels through lipid regulating drugs was £769 million in 2004 and that stroke cost the NHS over £2.8 billion in 2005; welcomes the efforts of HEART UK in raising awareness that everyone can benefit from knowing what they can do to reduce the risk of CVD; supports the charity's forthcoming Testing the Nation's Hearts campaign to undertake a major cholesterol and blood pressure testing and education programme across the UK; and calls on the Government to support this campaign to raise awareness of the risks of unhealthy levels of cholesterol and blood pressure among the general population together with the importance of primary prevention.


1896COMMUNITY HOSPITALS ACTING NATIONALLY TOGETHER PARLIAMENTARY RALLY23:3:06
Mr Boris Johnson [R]
Mr Graham Stuart [R]
Bob Spink
Peter Bottomley
Ann Winterton
Mr Nigel Evans
* 10
 Dr Julian Lewis [R]Tim LoughtonSir Nicholas Winterton
 Mr Stewart Jackson
   That this House notes with concern that many community hospitals remain under threat of imminent closure; supports Community Hospitals Acting Nationally Together's (CHANT) ongoing work in raising awareness of and campaigning against these closures; further and specifically supports the CHANT rally of Parliament being held on 28th March 2006; and calls on the Government to listen to local communities and save these vitally important hospitals.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1897DOUBLE SUMMER TIME23:3:06
Mr Greg Hands
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Mr Adrian Sanders
Mr Greg Knight
Mr Mike Hancock
* 11
 Dr Rudi VisRobert KeyChris McCafferty
 Paul FlynnStephen Williams
   That this House supports moving clocks forward an additional one hour in England and Wales to create a system of summer time/double summer time which could lead to a reduction in deaths and serious injuries of some 2,500 per annum, would create an extra hour's afternoon light every day for sports and outdoor activities of all kinds and would give relief from night time aircraft noise.


1898MICHAEL GAULT AND UK SHOOTING SUCCESS AT THE COMMONWEALTH GAMES23:3:06
Mr Martyn Jones
Bill Wiggin
Peter Bottomley
Bob Spink
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr John Whittingdale
* 20
 Kate HoeyDavid TaylorPaddy Tipping
 Mr Nigel EvansFrank CookMr Peter Atkinson
 Mr Martin CatonDr William McCreaDr Hywel Francis
 Philip DaviesDavid Simpson
   That this House congratulates home nation medal winners in the shooting events at the Commonwealth Games in Melbourne; further congratulates Michael Gault on winning his 14th Commonwealth Games medal and becoming the UK's most decorated Commonwealth Games athlete; further congratulates all members of the home nations' shooting teams; notes the continuing success that UK shooters have at major championships and the Olympic Games; recognises the important contribution that UK shooters will make at the 2012 Olympic Games in London; and supports responsible gun ownership.

As an Amendment to Mr Martyn Jones's proposed Motion (Michael Gault and UK Shooting Success at the Commonwealth Games):

Derek Wyatt
* 1
Line 8, at end add `but is dismayed at the lack of honours the team has won despite its outstanding success over the last decade.'.
28:3:06(a1)


1900NEW NATIONAL FEDERATION OF RETAIL NEWSAGENTS' CODE OF PRACTICE ON OFFENSIVE MATERIALS IN NEWSAGENTS27:3:06
Ms Diane Abbott
Bob Russell
Andrew George
Mark Durkan
Jim Dobbin
Lynne Jones
* 22
 Derek WyattDr Rudi VisMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynMr Colin BreedMr David Drew
 Mrs Janet DeanPaul FlynnMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin CatonMr Mike WeirLynne Featherstone
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the new code of conduct outlined by the National Federation of Retail Newsagents (NFRN) to prevent children being exposed to grown up titles in newsagents; notes that the new more elaborate guidelines relate not only to adult top-shelf titles but cover also what are known as `lads mags' as well as tabloids and other newspapers which carry images of women, along with written content which is potentially harmful not only to children but to gender equality issues in general; applauds the NFRN for being responsive to the growing number of consumer complaints relating to inappropriate display of `lads mags' and newspapers which contain degrading images of women; is concerned that the code remains entirely voluntary; and calls for the scrutiny of the implementation of this code of practice and for a statutory code to govern the display of offensive materials if adherence levels under voluntary arrangements are unsatisfactory.


1901FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE SCHEME (No. 2)27:3:06
Derek Wyatt
Bob Spink
Mark Durkan
Jim Dobbin
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 12
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet Dean
 Paul FlynnMr Martin Caton
   That this House commends the Government for recognising the problem of occupational pension schemes in deficit by introducing the Pensions Protection Fund and the Financial Assistance Scheme (FAS); notes that the FAS has an initial budget of £400 million; suggests that because this sum is to be used for approximately 85,000 employees and former employees in over 160 schemes the fund will have a substantial shortfall; and calls on the Secretary of State for Work and Pensions to bring forward a final payment solution that will remedy the issue as soon as possible.

As an Amendment to Derek Wyatt's proposed Motion (Financial Assistance Scheme (No. 2)):

David Taylor
Mr David Drew
* 2
Line 6, after `shortfall;', insert `notes that, taking into account the costs of compensation, the total cost of the scheme over a 60 year period would be £100 million per year net present value;'.
28:3:06(a1)


1902READING FOOTBALL CLUB AND THE PREMIER LEAGUE27:3:06
Martin Salter
Bob Russell
Angela Eagle
Stephen Pound
Mr Stephen Hepburn
Mr Richard Benyon
* 44
 Damian GreenJonathan ShawDerek Wyatt
 Laura MoffattMartin LintonAlan Keen
 Dr Rudi VisJohn McDonnellFrank Dobson
 Jeremy CorbynKate HoeyMrs Janet Dean
 Mr Adrian BaileyDr Nick PalmerMr John Grogan
 Jeff EnnisAndrew MillerMr Nigel Evans
 Mr Robert N. WareingMr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin Caton
 Dr William McCreaDr Hywel FrancisMr Kevan Jones
 Huw Irranca-DaviesMr Shahid MalikDavid Mundell
 Mr Sadiq KhanDavid SimpsonMr Jim Devine
   That this House congratulates Reading Football Club on securing promotion to the Premier League for the first time in its 135 year history in record breaking time which included a record run of 33 games without defeat; congratulates Club Chairman John Madejski, Manager Steve Coppell, Captain Graeme Murty and all the players and staff at Reading Football Club on their fantastic achievement; applauds the importance of the partnership between Reading Football Club and Reading Borough Council which helped deliver the Premiership quality Madejski Stadium vital for the Club's success; and looks forward to Reading FC achieving further success next season with victories against the likes of Arsenal, Manchester United and Chelsea.


1903NEW VISION FOR CANCER DOCUMENT27:3:06
Dr Ian Gibson
Mr John Baron
Sandra Gidley
Dr Richard Taylor
Bob Russell
Andrew George
* 39
 Derek WyattTim LoughtonDr Rudi Vis
 Mr Andrew DismoreJeremy CorbynMr Colin Breed
 Mr David DrewMrs Janet DeanJeff Ennis
 Chris McCaffertySir Nicholas WintertonPaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonDr William McCrea
 Dr Hywel FrancisStephen WilliamsDavid Simpson
   That this House supports the launch of the All Party Parliamentary Group on Cancer's New Vision for Cancer which can be seen at www.appg-cancer.org.uk; notes that improvements in cancer care have been realised thanks to recent increases in funding and to the dedicated work of NHS staff; nevertheless regrets that postcode prescribing remains a concern and that the UK lags behind other European countries when it comes to access to new cancer treatments; believes that a new, comprehensive, cross-departmental cancer strategy is urgently needed to bridge the gap between health and social care, and which will set enforceable national standards and entitlements to cover the entire patient journey; further believes that a New Vision for Cancer should educate professionals and the public, improve prevention diagnosis and treatment, and facilitate research into genetics, and the causes of, and treatments for cancer; and urges the Government to advance health policy to ensure this Vision becomes a reality.


1904SCOTTISH COMMONWEALTH GAMES TEAM27:3:06
Mr Angus MacNeil
Pete Wishart
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Mike Weir
* 7
 Mr Elfyn Llwyd
   That this House congratulates the England Commonwealth Games team's tremendous success in finishing in second place; further congratulates Paul Bush and his Scottish Commonwealth Games team, who finished sixth overall in the medals table; notes that an amazing 18 per cent. of the Scottish team won medals, with 72 per cent. of the team finishing in the top eight or better; further notes that Scotland finished higher than 25 other nations who are entitled to compete in the Olympics; and further notes that if Scotland and England were to compete as independent teams in the Olympics, many more people could participate and win many more medals.


1905150th ANNIVERSARY OF THE MISSION TO SEAFARERS27:3:06
Mr Julian Brazier
Chris Grayling
Ms Diane Abbott
Tim Loughton
Gwyn Prosser
Bob Russell
* 39
 Mr Gerald HowarthDr Julian LewisDerek Wyatt
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMr David DrewMr Ken Purchase
 Mr Lindsay HoyleMr Nigel EvansPaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydDr William McCreaMr Mike Weir
 Stephen WilliamsStephen HammondDavid Simpson
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House salutes the Mission to Seafarers in its 150th anniversary year; notes the many travails and traumas suffered on an increasingly regular basis by merchant seafarers and is especially concerned at the dramatic increase in piracy and crew abandonment on the high seas; commends the Mission and its chaplains for their sterling work looking after the physical, mental and spiritual welfare of seafarers, be they British or foreign, of any faith or none; recognises their efforts in improving the lot of seafarers through work at the United Nations, the International Maritime Organisation and the International Labour Organisation; and wishes them every success in the coming century.


1906QUEEN ELIZABETH HOSPITAL GATESHEAD27:3:06
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
John Cummings
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
Paul Flynn
Dr Rudi Vis
* 8
 Jeremy CorbynMr Martin Caton
   That this House congratulates the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Gateshead on being judged the third best hospital in the country in Saga's recent study of UK hospitals; notes that this was assessed on standards of quality of care, patient experience, staff numbers, infection control, handling of MRSA and waiting times; further notes that such national recognition is long-deserved for a hospital widely recognised in the North East as a standard-setter; and wishes it future success in further improving the health of the people of Gateshead and Washington.


1907FUNDING FOR THE NATIONAL PROBATION SERVICE27:3:06
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Dr Ian Gibson
David Taylor
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Lynne Jones
Mrs Ann Cryer
* 22
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Colin BreedMrs Janet DeanMr Ken Purchase
 Jeff EnnisChris McCaffertyMr Paul Truswell
 Jim DobbinMr Lindsay HoylePaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonMr John Leech
   That this House sees the privatisation of the National Probation Service in England and Wales as a fundamental misjudgement of the nature of its work; believes that it is likely to reduce the effectiveness of the service at the cost of communities; and further believes that instead the Government should ensure the service is properly funded in its current form.


1908ENGLISH AS THE BUSINESS LANGUAGE OF EUROPE27:3:06
Keith Vaz
Bob Spink
John Cummings
James Brokenshire
Mrs Ann Cryer
Peter Bottomley
* 15
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattDr Rudi Vis
 Mr Andrew DismoreMrs Janet DeanChris McCafferty
 Mr Lindsay HoyleStephen Williams
   That this House welcomes the statement of Ernest-Antoine Seilliere at the Spring European Council that English is now the accepted language of business in Europe; notes that 70 per cent. of 18 to 24 year olds in Europe speak English; further notes that 83 per cent. of high school students in the European Union are learning English; hopes that President Chirac can be present for Mr Seilliere's next presentation on resisting national protectionism in Europe; and calls on the European Union to recognise the predominant position of English in such areas as establishing a European Patent Office.


1909TURNER BEQUEST28:3:06
Mr Austin Mitchell
Mr Andrew Dismore
Jeremy Corbyn
Bob Spink
* 4
   That this House is concerned that the trustees of the National Gallery continue to disregard JMW Turner's intentions for his first art bequest to the nation with the consequence that they deprive the people of Great Britain of the opportunity to make this bequest a Royal Tribute to HM Queen Elizabeth II on her 80th Birthday as Champion of Humanity's Progress in Peace; and therefore calls on the Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport to intervene and require the National Gallery to display properly this crown jewel of Turner's output in time for HM the Queen's Birthday on 21st April; and to review and reform the Trustee system of the National Gallery which is unaccountable to the British people who own the art therein.


1910MICROFINANCE IN THE DEVELOPING WORLD28:3:06
Keith Vaz
Andrew George
Mark Durkan
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr John Leech
Dr Rudi Vis
* 15
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynMr Martin CatonBob Spink
 Mr Mike WeirStephen WilliamsJo Swinson
   That this House supports the efforts of governments and non-governmental organisations in providing microfinance schemes to those living below the poverty line in the developing world; recognises that in order to become self-employed the poorest of the developing world lack the relatively tiny sums of investment capital required to start a business; further notes the recent report of the Microcredit Summit Campaign that in 2004 more than 66 million of the world's poorest people, 84 per cent. of them women, received tiny loans last year to start or expand micro businesses; and fully supports microfinance projects as effective and efficient schemes that tackle poverty, reduce the need for aid, empower women and spur development.


1911READING FOOTBALL CLUB PROMOTION TO PREMIERSHIP28:3:06
Mr Rob Wilson
Mr Oliver Heald
Mr Richard Benyon
Angela Browning
Damian Green
Mr Andrew Mackay
* 9
 Mrs Theresa MayMr Mike HancockDr Rudi Vis
   That this House congratulates Reading Football Club on its successful season, culminating in promotion to the Premiership; notes the massive contribution made by club Chairman John Madejski OBE and Manager Steve Coppell; and welcomes the anticipated boost to the town's profile and economy that Premiership football should bring.


1913STATEMENT OF UN SPECIAL RAPPORTEUR ON IRANIAN BAHį'IS28:3:06
Lembit Öpik
Bob Russell
Mark Durkan
Mr John Leech
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 13
 Mr Mike HancockAndrew GeorgeMr Adrian Sanders
 Peter LuffMr Nigel EvansMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin Caton
   That this House expresses grave alarm at the news that Iran's military and intelligence apparatus are identifying and monitoring all of that country's Bahį'i minority, as revealed by a recent statement of the UN Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion and Belief; registers deepest concern at the mounting threat to the Bahį'i community, who have faced prolonged persecution; and urges Her Majesty's Government to seek immediate guarantees for the safety of the Bahį'is from the Iranian authorities.


1914DEREGISTRATION OF WELSH LABOUR28:3:06
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Adam Price
Hywel Williams
Mr Mike Weir
* 4
   That this House notes the demise of Welsh Labour as an official unit of the Labour Party; further notes that the Electoral Commission does not recognise Welsh Labour as a distinct political unit; and is surprised that the leader of New Labour in Wales was not aware of the decision to scrap Welsh Labour.


1915WELSH COMMONWEALTH TEAM28:3:06
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
Adam Price
Hywel Williams
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Mike Weir
Mr Martin Caton
* 10
 Mr Nigel EvansBob SpinkDr Hywel Francis
 Stephen Williams
   That this House congratulates the Welsh Commonwealth Games team on their performance and success in Melbourne, especially the 18 medal winners, gold medallists David Davies, Michaela Breeze and Dave Phelps, silver medallists David Eaton, Julie Crane, Elizabeth Morgan, Robert Weale and Kevin Evans, and bronze medallists Nicola Cooke, Hayley Tullett, Beverley Jones, David Roberts, David Davies, Geraint Thomas, Gruffudd Morgan, David Phelps, Johanne Brekke and Jamie Cress; wishes them the best for the future; and congratulates all athletes and staff connected with the Welsh Commonwealth team.


1916MASSACRE OF REPATRIATED SLOVENE SOLDIERS IN 194528:3:06
John Austin
Mr David Amess
Adam Price
Mr Paul Keetch
Dr Rudi Vis
Mr Andrew Dismore
* 14
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattJeremy Corbyn
 Andrew GeorgeMr Nigel EvansMr Elfyn Llwyd
 Mr Martin CatonMr Mike Weir
   That this House notes with regret that the repatriation of disarmed Slovene soldiers at the end of World War II against their wishes resulted in the summary execution of many by their political enemies in their home country; believes a mistake was made by the British authorities that resulted in the loss of some 12,000 lives; notes that this regrettable act, albeit at a time of some confusion and chaos in southern Austria in May 1945, has never been acknowledged publicly by the United Kingdom Government; believes that as a contribution to post-war reconciliation, it is time to be honest and open about this matter to Slovenia, which is now a partner in the EU and ally in NATO, contributing to peace-keeping efforts in many parts of the world and sharing common values of democracy and transparency; and calls on the Government and the Foreign Secretary officially to express their sincere regrets for this mistake, as they did to the relatives of those massacred at Srebrenica.


1917BRITISH COUNCIL JOBS IN MANCHESTER28:3:06
Mr John Leech
Mr Martin Caton
Jeff Ennis
Stephen Williams
* 4
   That this House notes with concern that the British Council is reported to be considering moving jobs from Manchester to London; recognises that this would be in stark contrast to the current trend of moving jobs from London out to the regions; and therefore calls on the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in their discussions with the British Council to remind management of the benefits of retaining jobs in Manchester.


1918150th ANNIVERSARY OF BIRTH OF WILLIAM MASSEY28:3:06
Mr Gregory Campbell
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
Mr Peter Robinson
Mrs Iris Robinson
Dr William McCrea
Bob Spink
* 7
 David Simpson
   That this House notes the 150th anniversary of the birth of William Ferguson Massey, born in Limavady, Northern Ireland, on 26th March 1856; further notes that his familiy emigrated to New Zealand; recognises the outstanding acheivements of Massey, who became Prime Minsiter of New Zealand and remained so from 1912 untill his death in 1925; and warmly commends the fond memory of Massey which the peoples of Northern Ireland and New Zealand share.


1919POST OFFICE CARD ACCOUNT (No. 3)28:3:06
Mr Mike Weir
Mark Durkan
Mr John Leech
Mr Elfyn Llwyd
John Cummings
Andrew George
* 9
 Mr Mike HancockJeremy CorbynBob Spink
   That this House notes with concern that Citigroup, who operated the Post Office Card Account on behalf of the Post Office, indicated that they transferred the business to an alternative provider on 6th March before holders of such accounts were informed of the intention to do so; believes that such action undermines further confidence in the Post Office Card Account, coming after the revelation that the Department of Work and Pensions intends to remove support from the account in 2010; further believes that the Post Office Card Account is an important vehicle for many people, many of whom do not have access to a bank, and that its end will increase financial exclusion; and calls upon the Government urgently to review their policy on the account and to reverse the stance of the Department of Work and Pensions.


1920HOPE NOT HATE TOUR28:3:06
Jon Cruddas
Mrs Ann Cryer
Rob Marris
Keith Vaz
Tony Lloyd
Mr Robert N. Wareing
* 32
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattDr Ian Gibson
 Dr Rudi VisGlenda JacksonMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynAndrew GeorgeMr David Drew
 Mrs Janet DeanMr Ken PurchaseJeff Ennis
 Jim DobbinJohn CummingsMr Nicholas Brown
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonStephen Williams
 Mr Ian AustinMr John LeechMs Katy Clark
 Mark DurkanMr Jim Devine
   That this House congratulates the trade union movement for its continued work in combating the rising threat of racism and fascism, in both the workplace and the community; welcomes Billy Bragg's Hope not Hate tour, supported by Amicus, GMB, RMT and UNISON, together with Love Music Hate Racism, Unite Against Fascism, Searchlight and the Left Field; and fully supports the campaign's objectives of highlighting the dangerous, fascist and racist threat posed by the BNP, whilst noting that the tour will be hoping to portray a positive, anti-fascist and anti-racist message of Hope not Hate in various workplaces and communities, in towns and cities in the run up to the May local elections.


1921SETTLEMENT OF EQUAL PAY CASES IN THE PRISON SERVICE28:3:06
John McDonnell
Julie Morgan
Mrs Ann Cryer
Mr Neil Gerrard
Sandra Gidley
Bob Russell
* 22
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattDr Ian Gibson
 Dr Rudi VisGlenda JacksonMr Andrew Dismore
 Jeremy CorbynMr Lindsay HoyleMr Robert N. Wareing
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonBob Spink
 Stephen WilliamsMr John LeechMs Katy Clark
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the settlement of over 3,000 equal pay cases of predominately female members of staff working in the Prison Service after seven years of litigation; pays tribute to the thousands of members of the Public and Commercial Services Union who work in prisons across the country in administrative, executive and support roles and congratulates them on their victory, which ensures they will receive equal pay regardless of gender; believes that closing the gender pay gap is a priority and more positive action from the Government needs to be taken in order to address this problem across all Civil Service departments, agencies and non-departmental public bodies; urges the Government to lead by example to ensure comprehensive equal pay audits are completed in each Government department, agency and non-departmental public body to ensure public servants are paid equally, regardless of their gender; and further urges the Government to introduce class actions so as to end the unnecessary bureaucracy inherent in the Equal Pay Act, which requires each individual employee to submit a tribunal claim.


1922BURTON HOSPITALS NHS TRUST28:3:06
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Mark Todd
Mr Brian Jenkins
David Taylor
Mr David Kidney
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 10
 Dr Rudi VisMr Andrew DismoreMr Martin Caton
 Dr Hywel Francis
   That this House congratulates the Chairman, Chief Executive and staff at Queen's Hospital in Burton-upon-Trent for their hard work in reducing the projected deficit of the Burton Hospitals NHS Trust for the current financial year from a predicted £2.4 million last April, £1.2 million in October to a current projected deficit now of £500,000; condemns the misinformation contained in an article in the Daily Telegraph of 21st March 2006 in which a dossier of deficits compiled by the Conservative Party quoted the Burton Hospitals NHS Trust as having a predicted overspend of £31 million, asserting this to be £29,850,000 more than expected in September; recognises that the Conservative Party has admitted that there was a typing error but believes that the mistake caused considerable distress to everyone at Queen's Hospital, undermining the great progress the Trust has made over the past year.


1923SOUTH EASTERN TRAINS (No. 2)28:3:06
John McDonnell
Gwyn Prosser
John Austin
Kelvin Hopkins
Bob Russell
Dr Rudi Vis
* 13
 Derek WyattMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Mrs Janet DeanMr Robert N. WareingMr Martin Caton
 Ms Katy Clark
   That this House notes with regret that on 1st April 2006, South Eastern Trains, which is currently in the public sector, will be privatised; is deeply concerned that this will be the first outright privatisation of a train operating company under a Labour Government and that this is in contradiction to a Labour Party policy of an integrated, accountable and publicly-owned railway; believes that public ownership of the railway would provide a better deal for the passenger and tax payer; and believes that the privatisation of South Eastern Trains represents a missed opportunity to get the railways back on track.


1924PUBLIC SERVICES28:3:06
Michael Connarty
Jon Cruddas
Julie Morgan
Kelvin Hopkins
Mrs Joan Humble
Colin Burgon
* 37
 Mr Mike HancockDr Ian GibsonDr Rudi Vis
 Mr Andrew DismoreJeremy CorbynMrs Janet Dean
 Mr Ken PurchaseMr Dennis SkinnerJim Dobbin
 Mr Lindsay HoyleMr Robert N. WareingJohn Cummings
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin CatonMr Mike Weir
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House expresses its concern at the increasing trend in Government for the privatisation of public services, including the promotion of contestability and outsourcing, which puts at risk the accountable and effective delivery of a wide range of public services and a large number of public sector jobs in health, education, the Civil Service, prisons and probation, defence, transport, fire safety and community services; and welcomes the launch of the Public Services Not Private Profit campaign, which brings together trade unions across the public sector, calling upon the Government to introduce a moratorium on privatisation and to engage in a constructive dialogue over how Government, local communities and the trade unions can work together to provide the high quality public services the country needs.


1925ISAMBARD KINGDOM BRUNEL AND BRITON FERRY28:3:06
Dr Hywel Francis [R]
Mr Roger Williams
Mr Stephen Crabb
Hywel Williams
Mr Martyn Jones
Mrs Siān C. James
* 28
 Mr Mike HancockDr Rudi VisJeremy Corbyn
 Mr David DrewMr Ken PurchaseMr Nigel Evans
 John CummingsMr Elfyn LlwydMr Martin Caton
 Bob SpinkStephen WilliamsMr John Leech
 Mr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the many celebrations of the bicentenary of the birth of Isambard Kingdom Brunel, one of the world's greatest engineers; congratulates volunteers in Briton Ferry who have campaigned to restore the Brunel Dock, its floating gate and tower as major features of a local regeneration project; notes that restoration work will soon begin thanks to funding mainly from the Neath Port Talbot County Borough Council; and pays tribute to local schools and colleges for the celebrations they are planning in co-operation with the National Waterfront Museum and the Institute of Civil Engineers.

[R] Relevant interest declared


1926HEALTH AND SAFETY (S.I., 2006, No. 557)28:3:06
Mr David Cameron
Chris Grayling
Mr Julian Brazier
Stephen Hammond
Mr Owen Paterson
Mr Patrick McLoughlin
* 9
 Dr Julian LewisMr Nigel EvansBob Spink
   That an humble Address be presented to Her Majesty, praying that the Health and Safety (Enforcing Authority for Railways and Other Guided Transport Systems) Regulations 2006 (S.I., 2006, No. 557), dated 2nd March 2006, a copy of which was laid before this House on 9th March, be annulled.


1927GRETNA FOOTBALL CLUB AND THE SCOTTISH CUP SEMI-FINAL28:3:06
David Mundell
Mr Angus MacNeil
Mr Rob Wilson
Jim Sheridan
Mr Ben Wallace
Mr Alistair Carmichael
* 14
 Dr Ian GibsonDr Rudi VisJeremy Corbyn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMr Mike WeirJo Swinson
 Mr John LeechMr Jim Devine
   That this House congratulates Gretna Football Club on winning the Scottish Second Division Championship; wishes them well for their historic Scottish Cup semi-final at Hampden on Saturday 1st April; congratulates a club which made its debut in senior football in 2002 and its owner Brooks Mileson, Chairman Ron MacGregor, Secretary Helen MacGregor, Manager Rowan Atkinson and all the players and staff at the club on their fantastic achievement; and looks forward to Gretna FC achieving further success next season.


1928LAUNCH OF NATIONAL BOWEL CANCER SCREENING PROGRAMME (No. 2)28:3:06
Steve Webb
Dr Ian Gibson
Mike Penning
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mark Durkan
Mr John Leech
* 20
 Mr Mike HancockDerek WyattDr Rudi Vis
 Mr Andrew DismoreJeremy CorbynAndrew George
 Mrs Janet DeanJeff EnnisSir Nicholas Winterton
 Mr Nigel EvansMr Martin CatonBob Spink
 Philip DaviesMr Jim Devine
   That this House notes that bowel cancer kills 16,000 people a year and is the second biggest cause of cancer death in the UK; observes that early screening reduces mortaility rates by about 15 per cent.; welcomes the Government's commitment to introduce a National Bowel Cancer Screening Programmme in April 2006, which will be the first NHS cancer screening programme in England for men as well as women; but is alarmed that no funding has yet been allocated despite the fact that it will then take another six months for services to be commissioned; notes the recent British Medical Journal editorial which stated that the NHS financial crisis is clearly the cause of the delay; and calls on the Government to ensure that the planned screening programme is begun without further delay and that the necessary funds are released as a matter of urgency.


1929OMBUDSMAN'S REPORT ON OCCUPATIONAL PENSIONS28:3:06
Mr Philip Hammond
Dr Liam Fox
Mr Andrew Mitchell
Mr Andrew Lansley
Mr David Willetts
Mrs Theresa May
* 26
 Mr Andrew MackayDr Julian LewisMr Mike Hancock
 Sir John ButterfillRobert KeySir Nicholas Winterton
 Mr Nigel EvansBob SpinkMr Mike Weir
 Mr Stewart JacksonPhilip Davies
   That this House condemns the Government's rejection of the findings of the Parliamentary and Health Ombudsman's report Trusting in the Pensions Promise, which found the Government guilty of maladministration which misled thousands of people as to the security of their occupational pensions; further condemns the Government's use of an unsubstantiated figure of £15 billion as the cost of compensation to those identified by the Ombudsman's report, which is not discounted to reflect a net present value, and further wholly rejects the Welfare Reform Minister's incorrect calculation that this is equivalent to six pence on the basic rate of income tax; is critical of the Financial Assistance Scheme as it currently exists because of its limited scope and because only 27 people who have lost pensions and are eligible for help under the scheme have so far received any payment; and calls on the Government urgently to look at whether the Financial Assistance Scheme can be reconstructed to help a wider group of people who have suffered loss of pension rights through no fault of their own and to investigate the possible use of unclaimed assets to support the Financial Assistance Scheme.


1930EXEMPTIONS FOR THE SPORT OF OLYMPIC PISTOL SHOOTING28:3:06
Kate Hoey
Mr Martyn Jones
Mr Peter Atkinson
Mr Roger Williams
Frank Cook
Mr Andrew Mackay
* 13
 Derek WyattRobert KeyPaddy Tipping
 Sir Nicholas WintertonBob SpinkStephen Williams
 Philip Davies
   That this House recognises the importance of the success of Michael Gault in the pistol shooting events in the Commonwealth Games in Melbourne; and conscious of the fact that most of his training and that of other world-class pistol shooters has had to take place outside Great Britain due to the gun laws; calls on the Home Secretary to exempt the sport of Olympic pistol shooting from the handgun ban to allow athletes for the London Olympics to train at home.


1931BLUE PETER BADGES AND INTERNET AUCTION SITES29:3:06
John Barrett
Andrew George
* 2
   That this House recognises the importance and value of Blue Peter badges in this country; notes that these badges entitle the recipient to free entry to over 200 UK events and attractions; believes that such badges should be earned, not bought or sold; expresses concern that unscrupulous buying and selling of these badges on internet auction sites serves to devalue their status; regrets that visitor attractions such as Edinburgh Zoo have been forced to abandon free visits for badge holders due to misuse and subsequent financial loss; and calls on internet auction sites to take action to prohibit the selling of these badges online.


1932CITIZENS' PENSION29:3:06
Mr Mike Weir
* 1
   That this House welcomes the report from the Pensions Policy Institute calling for a flat rate pension to lift pensioners out of poverty and for reform of the current system of tax relief on private pensions; notes that the Turner Commission and the Government in its initial response specifically ruled out reform of tax relief; and believes that this stance is misguided and that reform of the current unfair system of tax relief is essential and would provide much of the funding required to introduce a Citizens' Pension for all pensioners.


1933BLUE BADGE PARKING PERMITS29:3:06
Mr Robert Flello
Charlotte Atkins
Mrs Janet Dean
Mr Iain Wright
Joan Walley
Mr Brian Jenkins
* 9
 Dr Tony WrightMr Khalid MahmoodPaul Farrelly
   That this House notes with concern that local authorities can effectively write their own rules regarding the display in vehicles of the blue badge disability parking permits; notes that this can lead to a disparity between different parts of the UK; calls upon the Government to bring about national mandatory rules for parking permit display that are clear and unambiguous; and further calls on the Government to require local authorities to train parking attendants fully and ensure they actively look for permits.


1934CHASE FARM HOSPITAL29:3:06
Mr David Burrowes
Mr Charles Walker
Mrs Theresa Villiers
Mr Andrew Love
* 4
   That this House opposes the proposal by the Barnet and Chase Farm NHS Trust to dismantle Chase Farm Hospital's Accident and Emergency department which ignores the overwhelming public opposition in the Boroughs of Enfield, Barnet and Broxbourne to such a proposal; notes the worrying consequences of the proposed transfer of Chase Farm's Women and Children's Unit to Barnet; commends the hard work and dedication of hospital staff and volunteers; and calls upon the Secretary of State for Health to urgently review the proposals and restore a commitment to locally delivered accessible healthcare.


1935NATIONAL DEPRESSION WEEK29:3:06
Mr Andrew Lansley
Tim Loughton
Mr Stephen O'Brien
Mr John Baron
Dr Andrew Murrison
Mr Crispin Blunt
* 6
   That this House congratulates the Depression Alliance on their organisation of National Depression Week which runs from 17th to 23rd April this year; notes that more than 2.9 million people in the UK are diagnosed as having depression at any one time and that one in five people will be affected by depression at some point in their lives; further congratulates the Depression Alliance for arranging a series of events during National Depression Week which aim to increase awareness of depression; supports the decision by the Depression Alliance to theme this year's National Depression Week around the availability of complementary therapies; agrees with the Depression Alliance that those suffering from depression would often benefit from access to complementary therapies such as cognitive behavioural therapy, nutritional advice and exercise; further notes that the waiting lists for many alternative therapies are unacceptably long and that the number of people suffering from depression is rising; and believes that urgent action is needed to ensure that all people suffering from mental illness receive the treatment best fitted to their personal circumstances.


1936BICENTENARY OF THE BIRTH OF IK BRUNEL29:3:06
Stephen Williams
Jenny Willott
Kerry McCarthy
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Andrew George
* 5
   That this House notes the bicentenary of the birth on 9th April 1806 of the great engineer Isambard Kingdom Brunel; acknowledges that much of Brunel's work endures to this day, most notably the line of the Great Western Railway from London Paddington to Bristol Temple Meads, the extension of the line to Cornwall including the Royal Albert Bridge over the Tamar and the Taff Vale Railway from Cardiff to Merthyr Tydfil and Aberdare; further notes that the greatest concentration of Brunel's achievements was in the City of Bristol where he designed the Clifton Suspension Bridge and built the world's first iron-clad propeller-driven ocean-going liner, the SS Great Britain; further notes that Bristol plans a series of commemorative events throughout 2006; and recognises that the achievements of Brunel in the 19th century stand as an inspiration to the engineers and designers of today.


1937UK SUPERMARKETS AND CANADIAN FISH AND SEAFOOD PRODUCTS29:3:06
Mr David Drew
Judy Mallaber
Mr Mike Hancock
Miss Ann Widdecombe
Mr David Amess
Norman Baker
* 30
 Dr Desmond TurnerBob RussellMr Andrew Love
 John AustinDr Rudi VisMr Andrew Dismore
 Jim DowdAndrew GeorgeCharlotte Atkins
 Richard BurdenMr Alan MealeMike Wood
 Mr Paul TruswellAndrew MillerMr David Chaytor
 Tony LloydMr Lindsay HoyleFrank Cook
 Paul FlynnMrs Betty WilliamsJulie Morgan
 Mark TamiMrs Linda RiordanRosie Cooper
   That this House notes with grave concern the Canadian government's decision to increase the quota of seal pups to be killed in this year's commercial seal hunt on Canada's east coast to 325,000; expresses its revulsion at the unacceptable cruelty of the hunt; recognises the damage it is doing to Canada's international reputation; notes the Respect for Animals campaign, spearheaded by Sally Banks (Lady Stratford) the widow of the late Tony Banks (Lord Stratford) urging UK supermarkets and consumers to boycott Canadian fish and seafood products; believes that a boycott of those Canadian products will be popular with consumers and the wider British public, who are overwhelmingly opposed to this vicious hunt; notes that such a boycott would send the strongest economic signal to Canada that the hunt must stop; reiterates its call on the UK Government to prohibit the import of all seal products into the UK; and urges UK supermarket chains to boycott Canadian fish and seafood imports until the hunt is brought to an end.


1938SCALDING INJURIES FROM HOT BATH WATER29:3:06
Mary Creagh
Mrs Siān C. James
Dr Alasdair McDonnell
Mr Robert Walter
Mr Stewart Jackson
Sandra Gidley
* 71
 Kelvin HopkinsJohn BercowDavid Lepper
 Norman BakerBob RussellMr Mike Hancock
 Peter BottomleyMr Anthony WrightDr Ian Gibson
 Ann KeenTom BrakeJohn Austin
 Alan KeenMr Andrew DismoreJeremy Corbyn
 Harry CohenAndrew GeorgeMr Brian Jenkins
 Mr Bill OlnerSteve McCabeLynne Jones
 Jeff EnnisColin BurgonJon Trickett
 Mrs Ann CryerMr Paul TruswellAnn Winterton
 Mr David ChaytorJim DobbinMr Lindsay Hoyle
 Mr Robert N. WareingMrs Betty WilliamsMiss Anne Begg
 Mr Brian H. DonohoeMr John McFallMichael Connarty
 Dr William McCreaJohn SmithBob Spink
 Mr Mike WeirMr Gregory CampbellAnnette Brooke
 Mr Kevan JonesVera BairdDr John Pugh
 Albert OwenMrs Madeleine MoonKitty Ussher
 Dr Roberta Blackman-WoodsNatascha EngelMr Ian Austin
 Mrs Sharon HodgsonMs Diana R. JohnsonRosie Cooper
 Mr John LeechJessica MordenSarah McCarthy-Fry
 Mr Robert GoodwillLynda WalthoMr Sadiq Khan
 Barbara KeeleyMark DurkanDavid Simpson
 Mark HunterMr Jim Devine
   That this House notes that every day a child under five years is admitted to hospital with serious injuries resulting from scalding hot bath water, that scalding hot bath water kills 20 people a year, three-quarters of whom are pensioners and that scalding disproportionately affects the most vulnerable in society; therefore welcomes the introduction with cross-party support of the Prevention of Scalding Injuries (Bathing in the Home) Bill by the hon. Member for Wakefield; further notes that this Bill is supported through the Hot Water Burns Like Fire campaign by Age Concern, the British Burns Association, the Child Accident Prevention Trust, the Children's Fire and Burn Trust, Help the Aged and the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents; and further notes that this Bill would require a change to the building regulations so that thermostatic mixing valves are installed as standard to regulate the temperature of bath water to a maximum of 48 degrees centigrade, that this temperature would protect those most vulnerable in society but enable everyone to continue to enjoy safe hot baths and that the Scottish Parliament has implemented new regulations to this effect which come into force in May.


1939GAMBLING ADDICTION29:3:06
John Penrose
Mrs Joan Humble
Jenny Willott
James Brokenshire
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Andrew George
* 8
 Bob RussellStephen Williams
   That this House recognises and is concerned by the damage through debt and family breakdown that gambling addiction causes in all parts of society; is particularly concerned about the potential for children to become gambling addicts if gambling is not conducted in a responsible and controlled fashion; applauds the work of Gamblers Anonymous, the Responsibility in Gambling Trusts, and others in helping compulsive gamblers to conquer their addiction; and calls on the Government, through the Gambling Commission, to work with the gambling industry to initiate a public information campaign about gambling addiction of the kind which has run successfully in countries such as South Africa, to establish a momentum behind efforts to reduce the number of gambling addicts in the UK as the Gambling Act comes fully into force.


1940PUBLIC SERVICES NOT PRIVATE PROFIT CAMPAIGN29:3:06
John McDonnell
Michael Connarty
Jon Cruddas
Julie Morgan
Kelvin Hopkins
Mrs Joan Humble
* 22
 Bob RussellGlenda JacksonKate Hoey
 Mr David DrewMark FisherClare Short
 David TaylorAlan SimpsonMr Austin Mitchell
 Mr Michael ClaphamChris McCaffertyColin Burgon
 Jon TrickettJim CousinsPaul Flynn
 Mrs Betty Williams
   That this House expresses concern at the increasing trend in Government for the privatisation of public services, including the promotion of contestability and outsourcing, which puts at risk the accountable and effective delivery of a wide range of public services and a large number of public sector jobs in health, education, the Civil Service, prisons and probation, postal services, public service broadcasting, defence, transport, fire safety and community services; and welcomes the launch of the Public Services Not Private Profit campaign, which brings together trade unions across the public sector, calling upon the Government to introduce a moratorium on privatisation and to engage in a constructive dialogue over how Government, local communities and the trade unions can work together to provide the high quality public services our country needs.


1941IMPROVING PAYMENT PRACTICES IN THE CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY29:3:06
Mrs Claire Curtis-Thomas
Mr John Spellar
Tony Baldry
Richard Younger-Ross
* 4
   That this House believes that security of payment in the construction industry especially for small and medium-sized businesses is a prerequisite to achieving trust and collaboration in the industry; therefore, urges the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry to use the opportunity presented by the current review of Part II of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, initiated by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, to amend the Act to ensure that there is a statutory mechanism for defining the amount to be paid at the date for payment, that all conditional payment provisions and cross contract set-off are outlawed, that progress payments start from commencement of contract and that the Act provides effective protection for firms in the supply chain from `upstream' insolvencies; and believes that payment security will be a major factor in the successful delivery of the construction projects for the 2012 London Olympics.


1942SINGLE FARM PAYMENT29:3:06
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr David Crausby
Andrew George
* 3
   That this House notes with concern that many farmers in England have not received their entitlement under the Single Farm Payment Scheme; further notes that farmers in Scotland and Wales have been paid while farmers in England continue to struggle without the money that they are owed; and calls on the Government to provide farmers with interim payments as a matter of urgency with farmers being granted a compensation payment for the period of delay.


1943MR DAVID BEATTIE'S SHOOTING MEDAL IN THE COMMONWEALTH GAMES29:3:06
David Simpson
Dr William McCrea
Mr Jeffrey M. Donaldson
Mr Gregory Campbell
Sammy Wilson
* 5
   That this House congratulates Mr David Beattie of Portadown, Co. Armagh on winning the silver medal in the shooting competitions at the Commonwealth Games in Melbourne.


1944PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY OF EU LEGISLATION29:3:06
Keith Vaz
* 1
   That this House notes that in the combined 2003-04 and 2004-05 parliamentary sessions only eight hours thirty minutes was spent in this House on considering EU documents, out of 1,746 hours available; further notes that other national parliaments in the European Union have established closer structural links with their counterparts in the European Parliament; recognises that European politics can no longer be considered in isolation from the business of the House; and calls on all political parties to look at ways to better scrutinise European legislation.


1945PAID LEAVE FOR ALL OFFSHORE WORKERS29:3:06
Geraldine Smith
Mr David Crausby
Mr Kevan Jones
Jim Dobbin
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
Mr Bob Laxton
* 7
 Dr Brian Iddon
   That this House notes that the working time regulations Horizontal Amended Directive came into effect in August 2003 which extended the provision for four weeks' paid leave for offshore workers for the first time; is concerned that employers argue that the Directive does not apply beyond territorial waters, a 12-mile radius from the coastline, which accounts for about 99 per cent. of offshore installations; and calls on the Government to clarify or amend the legislation to ensure that all offshore workers enjoy paid leave.


1946INTERNATIONAL LAW AND THE IRAQ WAR29:3:06
Alan Simpson
John McDonnell
Mr Robert N. Wareing
Ms Diane Abbott
Jeremy Corbyn
Dr Ian Gibson
* 7
 Mr Robert Marshall-Andrews
   That this House notes that Office of the United Nations Secretary General, in reply to detailed evidence submitted to him asking for an inquiry into breaches of the United Nations Charter, the Hague and Geneva Conventions and the 1945 Nuremberg Charter during the war against Iraq, has replied to say that the matters raised `are of extremely serious concern' and has referred the matter to the UN High Commissioner of Human Rights; and calls for the appointment of a Select Committee to examine this evidence and report to the House as soon as possible.


1947SOLAR PYRAMID IN STAVELEY29:3:06
Natascha Engel
Lembit Öpik
Tom Levitt
Mr Nick Clegg
Mr Mark Todd
Judy Mallaber
* 75
 Martin SalterMichael Jabez FosterAndrew Mackinlay
 Mr Mike HancockJonathan ShawGwyn Prosser
 Paul ClarkDerek WyattMartin Linton
 Tom BrakeStephen PoundMr Andrew Love
 Ms Diane AbbottMr Andrew DismoreFrank Dobson
 Harry CohenKate HoeyRoger Berry
 Mr David DrewMr David WinnickMr Adrian Bailey
 Mr Dennis SkinnerMr Bob LaxtonLiz Blackman
 Mr Patrick McLoughlinDavid TaylorMr Graham Allen
 Jeff EnnisMr Michael ClaphamMr Terry Rooney
 Mr David CrausbyDr Brian IddonJim Dobbin
 Mrs Joan HumbleMr Lindsay HoyleMr Gordon Prentice
 Mrs Claire Curtis-ThomasMr George HowarthMs Dari Taylor
 Mr Chris MullinChris RuanePaul Flynn
 Mr Elfyn LlwydMiss Anne BeggMr Eddie McGrady
 Mark TamiMr John MacDougallJon Cruddas
 Mr Tom HarrisVera BairdHuw Irranca-Davies
 Mr Iain WrightMr David AndersonKerry McCarthy
 Stephen WilliamsKitty UssherJenny Willott
 Edward MilibandJo SwinsonLynne Featherstone
 Ms Diana R. JohnsonDanny AlexanderGreg Mulholland
 Jessica MordenEd BallsMr Sadiq Khan
 Mary CreaghBarbara KeeleyMr Jim Devine
   That this House welcomes the construction of the Solar Pyramid in Staveley, a sundial that will be the UK's largest public work of art and the world's largest timepiece; is certain that it will be a landmark regeneration project of national and international significance; recognises that it will be a powerful stimulus to and symbol of the economic, cultural and scientific renaissance of the UK's former coal and steel heartland; and wishes the project every success.


1948NUCLEAR, THE RIGHT ANSWER CAMPAIGN29:3:06
Michael Connarty
Andrew Miller
Anne Moffat
Mr John Spellar
Mr Russell Brown
Mr Jamie Reed
* 8
 Mr John MacDougallJim Sheridan
   That this House notes the lobby of Parliament by 60 representatives of the 60,000 employees from the UK's 12 nuclear electricity generating sites who put the case for Nuclear, The Right Answer; accepts that their sites generate 20 per cent. of the UK's energy needs and that the nuclear contribution has been allowed to fall from 28 per cent. thereby increasing dependence on climate damaging carbon-based fuels; further notes that the UK is failing to meet the target it set for carbon dioxide emission reductions and has been economically damaged by spiralling prices for oil and gas; recognises that increasing nuclear electricity generation could assist in reducing climate change as it does not contribute to carbon dioxide emissions and could assist with problems of security of energy supply in a time of growing energy demand in the UK and worldwide; and calls on the Government to recognise these facts in its Energy Review and to ensure that it puts in place policies that would facilitate a programme of new replacement nuclear power stations as a necessary contribution to the UK's long-term energy requirements.


1949PAYMENTS BY RESULTS TARIFF29:3:06
Rosie Cooper
Helen Jones
Mrs Sharon Hodgson
Ms Celia Barlow
Mr David Crausby
Mr Lindsay Hoyle
* 13
 Mrs Ann CryerAndrew MillerGeraldine Smith
 Angela EagleMrs Betty WilliamsJulie Morgan
 Meg Hillier
   That this House recognises that under the current Payment by Results Tariff arrangements, which are underpinned by the market forces factor adjustment, NHS trusts with newly or recently built facilities are unfairly penalised by only attracting an allocation based on average overhead costs; and, in order to avoid financially penalising clinically efficient, clean and modern facilities in favour of low cost inefficient provision, calls upon the Secretary of State for Health to correct this wholly unfair anomaly by adjusting funding allocations to such compromised NHS trusts.


NAME WITHDRAWN

1924PUBLIC SERVICES:
John McDonnell has withdrawn his name.




NOTICE OF MOTION WITHDRAWN

1899SCALDING INJURIES FROM HOT BATH WATER No 1:
Mr Stewart Jackson has withdrawn his motion.




 
House of Commons home page Houses of Parliament home page House of Lords home page search page enquiries

© Parliamentary copyright 2006
Revised 30 March 2006